Do the colts have the worst roster in football?

[12isthenew18]

Seriously. I've talked with my friends of all nfl fandom: eagles, ravens, steelers, rams etc. I see outside of Luck We have the worst roster and the only reason we are even considered one is because of Luck. Like what on paper or even in the field do we have better than even our division as a whole that isn't Luck. 

[TheRustonRifle#7]

Easily...

[21isSuperman]

Do the Colts have the worst roster?  No.

Is this an overreaction to what we've done in free agency so far?  Yes.

 

There are still several good free agents available, and the draft.  There's still lots of time and opportunity to add talent to our roster.

[NewColtsFan]

 

Just now, 12isthenew18 said:

Seriously. I've talked with my friends of all nfl fandom: eagles, ravens, steelers, rams etc. I see outside of Luck We have the worst roster and the only reason we are even considered one is because of Luck. Like what on paper or even in the field do we have better than even our division as a whole that isn't Luck. 

 

 

Now why would you go and ask such a silly question?

 

If your friend are really saying that then they don't know football....

 

We don't even have close to the most roster in football.....

 

Goodness.....

 

[12isthenew18]

Like this isn't an attack on us or even like an advocacy for signing everyone but I truly believe except for the niners, without Luck we have the worst roster AGAIN in football

[BProland85]

I think we are in the discussion. Outside of Luck, what other players have All Pro potential? 

[12isthenew18]

1 minute ago, BProland85 said:

I think we are in the discussion. Outside of Luck, what other players have All Pro potential? 

vontae and pat

[BProland85]

Just now, 12isthenew18 said:

vontae and pat

I'd maybe give you Vontae. But he needs to bounce back to what he was the year previous to this past season. 

 

McAfee is a punter. I'm talking about true difference playmakers on the team 

[JColts72]

1 minute ago, BProland85 said:

I think we are in the discussion. Outside of Luck, what other players have All Pro potential? 

TY, Adam, Pat, Jackson, Davis, Adams, but yes it's flawed by the FA moves of getting aging players.

[shakedownstreet]

jack doyle alone elevates the colts to the middle of the pack

[12isthenew18]

Just now, JColts72 said:

TY, Adam, Pat, Jackson, Davis, Adams, but yes it's flawed by the FA moves of getting aging players.

jackson and adams lmao. T.Y. knows there is too much competition for him to be an all pro over like green,brown, beckham etc.

[Nesjan3]

the worst? absolutely not, bottom 10 in the league , easily

[DougDew]

13 minutes ago, 12isthenew18 said:

Seriously. I've talked with my friends of all nfl fandom: eagles, ravens, steelers, rams etc. I see outside of Luck We have the worst roster and the only reason we are even considered one is because of Luck. Like what on paper or even in the field do we have better than even our division as a whole that isn't Luck. 

The Colts have always been sold as a soft indoor team who's undeniably great QB carries an otherwise bad team to the playoffs year after year.

 

That narrative helps to feed the mindset that dopes in NE, Pitt, Balt, Clev , and NY are tough minded real football fans because they are willing to pay a $100 dollars to sit in 25 degree weather and still buy $10 beers and $5 hot dogs.  And because of it, those fans are told they have good rosters even when they have down years....otherwise, they'd feel stupid freezing in the stadium paying to get drunk.

 

IOW, don't listen to your friends because they are just parroting a narrative.

[BOTT]

I'm not sure there is another defense desperate for difference makers.

[jvan1973]

15 minutes ago, 12isthenew18 said:

Like this isn't an attack on us or even like an advocacy for signing everyone but I truly believe except for the niners, without Luck we have the worst roster AGAIN in football

How did we win 8 games without luck for a large part of the year

[shakedownstreet]

3 minutes ago, jvan1973 said:

How did we win 8 games without luck for a large part of the year

 

we used tricks with lights, mirrors, and lasers 

[NBColtsFanatic]

You guys are ridiculous. Stop with this BULL! Just because your favorite player wasn't signed doesn't mean anything. Everything is fair game in September, not in March. And no, we don't, we went 8-8 in a season with what, 5 qbs? We're obviously good.

[wig]

6 minutes ago, jvan1973 said:

How did we win 8 games without luck for a large part of the year

 

More accurately, how did we go 6-3 without him and 2-5 with him if he's the entire roster?

[jim scheurich]

12 minutes ago, BOTT said:

I'm not sure there is another defense desperate for difference makers.

hope I'm not stepping on any toes here. I just jog through these statements and respond to ones that get my attention. Defense needs help badly, but colts are stuck between a rock and a hard place. Cant let luck get pummeled like last year.

[buccolts]

6 minutes ago, shakedownstreet said:

 

we used tricks with lights, mirrors, and lasers 

And pumped in sound.

[COLTS449]

No. We're a G and C away from maybe the best offense in the NFL. We lack talent on D. But we still have Anderson, Langford, Davis, and Adams. If we could just sign a corner, G, and C in free agency we could have a top roster as long as we draft good. And by drafting good I mean getting 4-5 good promising young players and at least 2 who come in and start week 1.

[BOTT]

4 minutes ago, jim scheurich said:

hope I'm not stepping on any toes here. I just jog through these statements and respond to ones that get my attention. Defense needs help badly, but colts are stuck between a rock and a hard place. Cant let luck get pummeled like last year.

Agreed.  But talent wise the offense has some talent....I just wish more of that talent was on the offensive line.

[jim scheurich]

1 minute ago, BOTT said:

Agreed.  But talent wise the offense has some talent....I just wish more of that talent was on the offensive line.

so does andrew

 

[bababooey]

We beat the broncos last year so...

[MTC]

Talk about an overreaction. 

 

Wait and see until we create our 53 man roster.

[crazycolt1]

Just another whine thread.

[RollerColt]

[1959Colts]

I'm not sure we have the worst? But I think we have some serious holes in the roster.

Our dominance of the AFC South quickly is fading away.

Titans, Texans and Jags are all looking much improved.

[Moncrief]

We just need guys to play to their potential, and overachieve.

 

Like every other team doesn't have that thought as well lol

[IndyD4U]

Just going to place this here and slowly walk away.... 

 

It's March 9th

[BOTT]

6 minutes ago, 1959Colts said:

I'm not sure we have the worst? But I think we have some serious holes in the roster.

Our dominance of the AFC South quickly is fading away.

Titans, Texans and Jags are all looking much improved.

How did the Texans improve?

[jvan1973]

6 minutes ago, 1959Colts said:

I'm not sure we have the worst? But I think we have some serious holes in the roster.

Our dominance of the AFC South quickly is fading away.

Titans, Texans and Jags are all looking much improved.

How are they looking much improved?   Training camp is months away. 

[CR91]

threads about overreacting free agency. it must be the offseason

[Gabriel Alexander Morillo]

SI PUES

[Goatface Killah]

The dumbest thing I've ever read.

 

 

[Introspect]

11 minutes ago, 1959Colts said:

I'm not sure we have the worst? But I think we have some serious holes in the roster.

Our dominance of the AFC South quickly is fading away.

Titans, Texans and Jags are all looking much improved.

I agree with you!

We will struggle in this division in the next couple of years. Our years of dominance over our AFC South opponents is over.

Winner of this division will be 10-6. No better

[Track Guy]

No, it's not the worst. 

 

There is still time to pull a good team together. And the NFL is so unpredictable. For example, I thought the Panthers were headed for another 7 win season after Kelvin Benjamin went down for the year. We'll see what plays out over the rest of FA and the draft, and even then we won't really know. 

[Ryan Pelley]

One of the worst, yes.

[runthepost]

Bottom 5 lol

[Nesjan3]

all the people that come here just to comment that this is a "whine thread" or the "the dumbest thing ive ever read" is hilarious to me. Is it a byproduct of us not signing anybody and letting our guys walk and as well the Allen signing, absolutely, but in all reality there is a lot of truth to this topic, our roster is easily one the worst in the league and people just dont want to see that and continue to pretend. Where is that guy with meme "The truth? You cant handle the truth!" lol seriously a lot of whining and crying going on here lately but you know whats worse than a whiner is the guy who refuses to realize the facts and pretends everything is ok