Suh or Ngata and Knighton

[USAFHoosier]

With the possibility of Ngata being released the Colts could theoretically sign him and Knighton.  Would you rather the Colts sign both of them or sign Suh.  No indication any of this would happen just a hypothetical question.

[Dustin]

Suh

[Restored]

Ferrai, Benz or Chevy?

[IndyD4U]

$UH

[krunk]

I'll take Ngata and Knighton

[IndyD4U]

Ferrai, Benz or Chevy?

Lambo

[RealityIsLuck]

I'd date Suh, Knighton and Ngata together would most likely cost more. Give me Suh.

[12isthenew18]

wilfork will be released

[USAFHoosier]

I'd date Suh, Knighton and Ngata together would most likely cost more. Give me Suh.

I was trying to decide if they would cost more or not.  If Suh is wanting 16m per it might be close.

[theanarchist]

Ferrai, Benz or Chevy?

Alfa Romeo. First to four in under 60. Vroom...Goulet!

[Coltivated]

Or wilfork now

[RealityIsLuck]

I was trying to decide if they would cost more or not. If Suh is wanting 16m per it might be close.

I think Suh would be 13-16

Ngata 6-8

Knighton will get overpaid 6-8 aswell forsure

They could be close, But I still would rather have Suh.

[csmopar]

I'll take Ngata and Knighton

I agree. 2 impact players for 18 million> better than 1 impact player who's never played in a 3-4 and wanting 16 million...

[Bluefire4]

I think Suh would be 13-16

Ngata 6-8

Knighton will get overpaid 6-8 aswell forsure

They could be close, But I still would rather have Suh.

Suh will want more like 16-20+.

[colts_100nascar17fan]

If they pay suh, they better structure it so they can get out of it if he turns into one of those guys that have thier play go into a downward spiral after big pay days. And be smart and not mortgage the future so ur hand cuffed bad with cap problems.

[CanuckColtsFan]

I think you could probably get Ngata and Knighton for close to the price. the run d would be improved but would you see 8 more sacks from those two or as a result of them being on the field? I would lean toward the two players but I'm not sure they'd play for 16m between the two of them, if they would I probably would go for them. The two players only generated 3 sacks them selves. Now from that could you say Mathis and newsome would benefit from that and be able to get at the QB more often. Suh is really talented I just wish he wasn't all about the money.

[CanuckColtsFan]

If they pay suh, they better structure it so they can get out of it if he turns into one of those guys that have thier play go into a downward spiral after big pay days. And be smart and not mortgage the future so ur hand cuffed bad with cap problems.

Albert Hayensworth

[GGW4Micheal]

Id rather have Ngata and Knighton. We could get 2 good players instead of one and which the one is only one play away from probably being suspended for awhile.

[bababooey]

GIVE ME SUH. dont know why people think 4-3 vs 3-4 all of a sudden he's going to be a bust. he could be a hall of famer and he is entering his prime RIGHT NOW. Could care less about his on field fines or actions. We need a bully. It's not like he's out getting arrested for DUI's or assaults like our other players. A suspension is the risk you take with him but ONE superbowl is worth all of it.

[#12]

Suh.  He's the type of player who can potentially make everyone around him better. 

 

If we somehow do land him, hopefully Mathis can somewhat return to form and Jonathan keeps coming on.  Mathis/Freeney/Suh, for example,  would have been devastating. 

[Luck_Is_Skilled]

I'll take Ngata and Knighton

 

[ColtJax]

Suh will break the bank, and with his character issues do we really want to make the same mistake the Redskins did with Haynesworth?? Ngata is EXACTLY what a 3-4 defense needs..

[BProland85]

I think Suh would be 13-16

Ngata 6-8

Knighton will get overpaid 6-8 aswell forsure

They could be close, But I still would rather have Suh.

For only 6-8 mil per year I'd definitely prefer Ngata. He fits the defense better than any other DT in free agency. And would allow us to still go out and get FS Devin McCourty and OG Clint Boling.

[ProblChld32]

Personally i would love to have Suh. but i dont want to break bank for him. 

[UKColt13]

Ngata and Knighton would be cheaper and certainly in my mind a better move.

[Deano1818]

Suh AND Ngota

23m

Bully RG

6m

29m

Win the SB

Do mr Luck next year

Draft safety, OLB, ILB

Done and done

A man can dream...... Right?

[coltsfanatic24]

I would rather have Ngata, Suh is going to cost too much and he'll be in a new scheme. We also have too many other needs on the team. The only player that should have that much guaranteed money is Luck. Suh is not that valuable to a team like a QB is.

[Coffeedrinker]

Sign all three.  I'm sure they could work out deals where all three could be signed and take up about $40 mill of this years cap, save the rest for signing draft picks and bada bing bada boom the Colts win the back to back SB, Ngata retires, Knighton gets injured and released and Suh gets traded for a top 5 draft pick.

[HtownColt]

Suh

[buccolts]

Sign all three.  I'm sure they could work out deals where all three could be signed and take up about $40 mill of this years cap, save the rest for signing draft picks and bada bing bada boom the Colts win the back to back SB, Ngata retires, Knighton gets injured and released and Suh gets traded for a top 5 draft pick.

 

Simple enough.

[21isSuperman]

Ngata and Knighton without a doubt.  They'd probably be cheaper and you get 2 solid players instead of 1 very good player.  Plus, Knighton and Ngata have played well in a 3-4 whereas we don't know how Suh will do in a 3-4.

[Smurphy1]

Ngata and Knighton no contest

[aaron11]

ngata. he'll cost half as much and wont have to switch schemes.  i think suh could be ok in a 3-4 but he may not be worth as much as he would in a 4-3

[JohnnyP]

With the possibility of Ngata being released the Colts could theoretically sign him and Knighton.  Would you rather the Colts sign both of them or sign Suh.  No indication any of this would happen just a hypothetical question.

I love Suh, but he's not JJ Watt....and he shouldn't get paid Watt money.  ...for that reason alone, i say no.....whether it's Ngata + Knighton ...or some other combo, it seems this a good time to be in need of free agency help along the defensive line. .....let's take advantage of that and get multiple players along the line.  .....plus we would still have the option to fill some other needs (Worilds, Hali..if he gets cut) ?  ....we can draft Goldman in RD1 or maybe even Brown...if he slides.  ...that would be a great new start to rebuilding the front 7.

 

Goldman or Brown

Ngata

Jones

 

plus Worilds/Hali  ....I have very little expectations for Mathis this year. 

 

we would still have money left over to  be competitive filling in other needs

[Restored]

Ngata and Knighton without a doubt.  They'd probably be cheaper and you get 2 solid players instead of 1 very good player.  Plus, Knighton and Ngata have played well in a 3-4 whereas we don't know how Suh will do in a 3-4.

 

We've seen the Colts try and get 2 "solid" players before it hasn't worked out too well. Knighton hasn't played in a 3-4 either. Don't mean to nitpick you here. Just saying.

[Dark Superman]

Suh. I'm sick of being embarrassed by the Patriots.

[Dark Superman]

Have Suh, jones and Hardy across the line..

Tom Brady would retire immediately..

[Track Guy]

I highly doubt we get both Knighton and Ngata.

[MTC]

Jared Odrick and Stephen Paea. 

[HeSoColt]

If you get Knighton and Ngata... where do they play? Does one guy start and one guy come off the bench?