Seen all of Wentz I need to see/ Give us 1 good reason to keep Carlson Wentz. (merge)

[Aces101]

Curtis Painter > Jim Sorgi > Carson Wentz 

[masterlock]

36 minutes ago, Detectacon said:

You have got to be kidding. Caldwell?!? Hard pass. 

LOL. And while we're at it, let's re-sign Trent Richardson.

[husker61]

4 minutes ago, Wentzszn said:

He wasn’t great bur Reich and the oline did him no favors. He had trouble just getting time to get to his second read.

He has to make decisions faster, that’s what top qb’s do! A lot of qb’s have the physical skills, that isn’t what makes a top Qb.

[masterlock]

29 minutes ago, JediXMan said:

How do you beat the Pats, Cards, Bills but lost to the Raiders and Jags smh.

With an inconsistent quarterback who misses wide-open receivers and throws the occasional left-handed pass for good measure.

[indyagent17]

8 minutes ago, ThorstenDenmark said:

Jesus Freaking Christ.....

 

WTH just happened?  

 

One of the worst chokes ever seen in the last two weeks of the season.

 

Wentz is a disaster and both he and Reich who brought him to Indy should be fires.

 

I would rather have a man in a wheelchair behind Big Q then Carson Wentz...

 

Hope that we will see huge changes tomorrow.  

Dude I appreciate your mad but being blasphemous is not cool

[jbaron04]

22 minutes ago, luv_pony_express said:

It’s remarkable how many easy passes he misses.

 

I’m not being dramatic or hyperbolic:  I saw HS quarterbacks this year that were better than him in that department.  It’s simply inexcusable for a starting QB in the NFL.  And it needs to be conceded and addressed, not pushed off as if it’s our imagination.

Yea slot of times he should have took the check down , but to be fair the whole team looked bad and I think he might have been rattled cause oline sucked and got destroyed 

[IrsaysArmy]

We’re in purgatory. Wentz will be back next year and probably won’t be any better. 

[Colt.45]

2 hours ago, Wentzszn said:

He isn’t going anywhere. We have a lot more issues then Wentz.

The Colts have many issues. The biggest of them is at QB. If Rivers was QBing this team this year, they win 11 games minimum.

Sure he doesn't have Wentz's arm but his brain is something Wentz will never have....and your arm is useless if you're brain can't make the right calls.

[GoHorse1992]

While Wentz has all the physical tools in the world, the last 4 games have showed me that he doesn’t have it mentally and probably never will. I thought that one or two poor games would be an anomaly but sadly I was wrong. Ugh!

[Dasteez]

2 hours ago, AustinnKaine said:

imagine trading your first round pick for someone who misses wide open receivers on a regular basis

I wish I was imagining. 

[bestQBever]

Alongside Wentz, our receivers outside of pittman are probably the worst in the NFL. Mo Allie Cox isn't a starting TE. Jack Doyle can only run a 2-5 yard stick route. Hines worst season of his career by far. We have nobody on offense outside of Taylor. Pittman is just decent. Something I learned/was reminded of this year: It doesn't matter HOW great the rest of your team is. If you don't have a QB, you don't have a team. So next year, if we go on a winning streak, if that winning streak isn't the direct result of Carson playing lights out, I won't have faith in this team.

[Malakai432]

See a lot of people talking about either Frank or Wentz but as one goes, so does the other lol.  These two are kind of binded at the hip going forward.

[Hawkeyecolt]

5 minutes ago, bestQBever said:

Alongside Wentz, our receivers outside of pittman are probably the worst in the NFL. Mo Allie Cox isn't a starting TE. Jack Doyle can only run a 2-5 yard stick route. Hines worst season of his career by far. We have nobody on offense outside of Taylor. Pittman is just decent.

I agree but how can you tell for sure when the QB is continuously late and throwing behind receivers.   The receivers are always well out of their break when he throws.  On most of his bad decisions throwing the ball there’s an open receiver or an open check down.  
 

 

[coming on strong]

8 minutes ago, bestQBever said:

Alongside Wentz, our receivers outside of pittman are probably the worst in the NFL. Mo Allie Cox isn't a starting TE. Jack Doyle can only run a 2-5 yard stick route. Hines worst season of his career by far. We have nobody on offense outside of Taylor. Pittman is just decent. Something I learned/was reminded of this year: It doesn't matter HOW great the rest of your team is. If you don't have a QB, you don't have a team. So next year, if we go on a winning streak, if that winning streak isn't the direct result of Carson playing lights out, I won't have faith in this team.

i think wentz is making the guys look even worse than they are .   he just stinks no beating around the bush he is not a starting QB in this league period .   he is cam newton 2.0 the same throws cam misses throwing high are the same throws carson misses .   they are the same guy one good year then gets exposed .

[bestQBever]

1 minute ago, Hawkeyecolt said:

I agree but how can you tell for sure when the QB is continuously late and throwing behind receivers.   The receivers are always well out of their break when he throws.  On most of his bad decisions throwing the ball there’s an open receiver or an open check down.  
 

 

I'm pretty sure about my points on Doyle and Cox. Maybe TY would have been a bit better if Carson wasn't as bad but doesn't change the fact he is completely washed up and injury prone. Parris Campbell has been literally non-existant for us. Pascal is a scrub who made his name blocking CB's instead of running away from them.

[Restinpeacesweetchloe]

2 minutes ago, coming on strong said:

i think wentz is making the guys look even worse than they are .   he just stinks no beating around the bush he is not a starting QB in this league period .   he is cam newton 2.0 the same throws cam misses throwing high are the same throws carson misses .   they are the same guy one good year then gets exposed .

Why don’t we wait and see what happens in the offseason and how next season goes. We have a lot more issues then just the QB. But yes Wentz has to put in some work too.

[Restinpeacesweetchloe]

14 minutes ago, bestQBever said:

Alongside Wentz, our receivers outside of pittman are probably the worst in the NFL. Mo Allie Cox isn't a starting TE. Jack Doyle can only run a 2-5 yard stick route. Hines worst season of his career by far. We have nobody on offense outside of Taylor. Pittman is just decent. Something I learned/was reminded of this year: It doesn't matter HOW great the rest of your team is. If you don't have a QB, you don't have a team. So next year, if we go on a winning streak, if that winning streak isn't the direct result of Carson playing lights out, I won't have faith in this team.

Continually to fail at the offensive skill positions thinking all you need is a QB is a recipe for losing. No QBbId going to fix these bad weapons. If Ballard isn’t going to set his QB up to succeed I am really done with him.  It’s not fair to the coach or the QB. Puts way ri much pressure on things to be perfect.

[Restinpeacesweetchloe]

2 hours ago, Colt.45 said:

The Colts have many issues. The biggest of them is at QB. If Rivers was QBing this team this year, they win 11 games minimum.

Sure he doesn't have Wentz's arm but his brain is something Wentz will never have....and your arm is useless if you're brain can't make the right calls.

Rivers would of been in his second year so yea we would of been better. Rivers also has elite processing skills that’s rare in any QB. Mahomes don’t even have that.

 

You guys will be better off not dwelling on the past. Let’s look forward and see what Ballard does in the off season and see how year two goes. One year is not a make or break for Wentz.

2 hours ago, IrsaysArmy said:

We’re in purgatory. Wentz will be back next year and probably won’t be any better. 

He won’t be if Ballard stays ststus quo.

[open window]

Better than tolzein less than Brissett 

[IinD]

I just read a funny tweet, you have to laugh after games like this .... Colts fans boo'd Andrew Luck so God gave them Carson Wentz...I legit lol'd...

[IndySouthsider]

3 hours ago, IrsaysArmy said:

We’re in purgatory. Wentz will be back next year and probably won’t be any better. 

That's why you don't do purgatory. Blow it up 

[IndyEric07]

Wentz=Luck mentally! Difference is, Wentz hasnt quit YET!

[GRUMPY OLD MAN]

5 hours ago, AustinnKaine said:

imagine trading your first round pick for someone who misses wide open receivers on a regular basis

what was ballard thinking

[colts89]

3 minutes ago, IndyEric07 said:

Wentz=Luck mentally! Difference is, Wentz hasnt quit YET!

 

Some of y'all are insanely blasphemous regarding Luck.

[icf]

Virtually every member of the organization that set foot on the field or sidelines today stunk.

 

The loss wasn't all on Wentz, but I dont see him ever being a QB that will lead a team to anything important.

 

That said, this team needs major upgrades at WR and TE.  JT is amazing, but until the QB can actually complete passes down the field, teams are going to put 8 guys up front and dare Wentz to beat them.

 

This team has 1 good WR in Pittman and that's it.  Everybody else out there is pretty much roster filler or guys that would be 2nd string on most playoff teams.

 

For all the praise heaped by some here on Ballard....his roster is .500 over his tenure and has 1 playoff W.  That's not good enough.  Ballard needs to find a way to get more talent on both sides of the ball but especilly guys to help give Wentz a chance to overcome his short comings....a few CB's wouldn't be a bad thing either.

 

 

[Numba1Colt]

if Wentz and Frank are here for 1 more season it will be as useless as Chuck Pagano's final season in 2017 without Luck... a waste of time

[2006Coltsbestever]

Give your honest answer, if Luck said he wanted to come back next season, would you take him or still roll with Wentz? Even Kurt Warner was much older than Luck is now when he took the Cards to the SB in 2008. Luck is only 32. QB's now days can play until they are 40 with the right team around them. If we had a healthy un-rusty Luck we would win the SB within 2 years. I hope Wentz is reading this but I Believe this. 

[IndyEric07]

Enough of this crap, aint never gonna happen! Lucks never EVER coming back, get over it!

[SurfinKal]

right now Jim Irsay is calling Luck like:

[Architects08]

Anyone that would take Wentz over Luck needs to be in a straitjacket locked in a padded room. 

[Malakai432]

8 minutes ago, 2006Coltsbestever said:

Give your honest answer, if Luck said he wanted to come back next season, would you take him or still roll with Wentz? Even Kurt Warner was much older than Luck is now when he took the Cards to the SB in 2008. Luck is only 32. QB's now days can play until they are 40 with the right team around them. If we had a healthy un-rusty Luck we would win the SB within 2 years. I hope Wentz is reading this but I Believe this. 

Luck in a flipping heart beat!  He’s not coming back though but miracles do happen lol!

[IndySouthsider]

I would take Peyton Manning tomorrow if he walked through that door. Heck, I would take Jeff George at the moment. 
 

There is no one worth drafting at QB either. 

[RollerColt]

Of course take Andrew. The talent level isn’t even remotely close. 
 

But it’s over. I still miss him, but it doesn’t matter. He’s never coming back my friend… We’re stuck with Carson for another year at least…

[Numba1Colt]

welcome back to the NFL Luck!!! 

 

i would be there first home game 

[GoColts8818]

Andrew Luck isn’t coming back.  It’s turning into the Lions fans who kept saying if Barry comes back…

[ojsglove]

DUH

[IrsaysArmy]

2 minutes ago, GoColts8818 said:

Andrew Luck isn’t coming back.  It’s turning into the Lions fans who kept saying if Barry comes back…

Yea. It’s like when Ace Ventura goes to visit Ray Finkles parents. “He ain’t coming back”

[IinD]

I'd say Andrew I love you, but I like chicks.

[Restinpeacesweetchloe]

Can we stop with this. It’s not good for anyone’s mental health to be thinking like his. Luck is gone.

[Smoke317]

You give Luck these same group of receivers and he’s well over 4000 yards with 30 plus touchdowns.  The exact same group.  He’d probably have more interceptions but teams wouldn’t dare stack the box against Taylor.  Wentz has to get better. Period. Point blank.  
 

Go get him Ertz to make him comfortable. Don’t know if Ertz is still a hundred plus target tight end but I’m sure he will be with Wentz regardless. Then there will be no more excuses.  Either Wentz hits 4K yards and 30 td’s and wins the division or him and Frank gotta go.