First completely random (and useless) off-season thread...

[Slick_Rick]

If you could bring back one old Colts player (not named Peyton) and put them on this Colts team as a rookie to play out their career, who would it be and why?

[Smonroe]

Appropriate title. So many good choices.

Glenn, Bubba, Hendricks... Too many others to name.

[SteelCityColt]

By no means not the first usual off-season post but not a bad topic  

 

Assuming you mean bring them back now as a 2014 rookie to play out with the current roster I'd say Marvin. That or if he could play out his career without being made of glass Bob Sanders. 

[Slick_Rick]

SteelCity, that's what I meant. Thank you for clarifying. For me, I think I'd want Jeff Saturday. I think he has a great mind for football, definitely could have developed the same relationship he had with Peyton with Andrew.

[adamthyst]

Tarik Glenn or Ryan Lilja to help that damn line.

[jvan1973]

Marshall Faulk

[bertjones#1]

Mike Curtis.... We need someone that can tackle

[jvan1973]

Mike Curtis.... We need someone that can tackle

he would draw a lot of penaltys in the new nfl...lol

[TonyBungee]

Eric Dickerson?

[cdgacoltsfan]

If you could bring back one old Colts player (not named Peyton) and put them on this Colts team as a rookie to play out their career, who would it be and why?

A healthy Bubba Smith...he and Redding at DE's would be a tough combo.

[throwing BBZ]

I will go with an Indy Colt.
Marvin was such a great playmaker he would edge out Marshall or Dickerson.

Reggie & Saturday are Rocks also.

[Malakai432]

Jeff George, people would bow to his mullet....

[Tark The Shark]

Jeff Saturday. We definitely need some help at C.

 

That and Big Daddy Limpscomb from the old Baltimore days. He would be perfect for a NT, DE, in our 3-4 scheme.

[No 1 Manning Fan]

Wow. At any position? That's really hard.

My top 5 list would be...

1. Johnny Unitas (I love Luck, but Johnny U is a legend)

2. Marvin Harrison

3. Marshall Faulk

4. Tarik Glenn

5. Raymond Berry

[Coltsfanman1953]

Art "fatso" Donovan.

[indycrazy1887]

Can't forget about geno marchetti!

[JoKeR]

Marvin Harrison, Tarik Glenn, Edge, and Bob Sanders.

Could you imagine having Marvin lined up next to veteran Wayne and T.Y?

Edge was the total package as a RB

Tarik Glenn just might be the most helpful rightnow.

Just having a young Bob Sanders for 1 year would be amazing with The Monster.

[JoKeR]

2 men walk into a bar,

Slick_Rick shoots them

Funny name and avatar dude.

[lollygagger8]

If we could somehow infuse his glass body with adamantium, then Bob Sanders fo sho. 

 

[lollygagger8]

2 men walk into a bar,

Slick_Rick shoots them

Funny name and avatar dude.

Hahhahahhaha

[Mike Tahoe]

Mike Vanderjagt

 

 

...kidding

 

 

Definitely would be Dean Biasucci

[JoKeR]

If we could somehow infuse his glass body with adamantium, then Bob Sanders fo sho. 

 

I don't know, the arthritic pain might be too much. I say give Bob Wolverines healing abilities.

[Balzer40]

Hard question to answer. It would just about have to be somebody in the last 20 yrs. that could fit in with todays football. I've seen several answers to some really old school players and while those players were great in their time, if they were to play in todays NFL they would probably get destroyed. Players are so much more bigger, athletic, and faster compared to what they were 40 yrs. ago. So all in all, I really don't have a good answer to the question.

[OffensivelyPC]

If I could guarantee health, Bob Sanders, no question.  But otherwise, I'd say flip a coin between Marshall Faulk or Erik Dickerson. 

[JoKeR]

I'm kinda surprised with everyone wanting Faulk over James. Not that either are the wrong answer of course.

[Horse Shoe Heaven]

Mike Curtis.... We need someone that can tackle

Curtis was an animal!!

[Guest TeamLoloJones]

Can we have another Reggie Wayne?  If we can have duplicate players then I would want another Andrew Luck.  That way Luck #2 can play back-up QB and be our starting ILB.

[Hammer]

Marv, Eric Dickerson, John Mackey/Raymond Chester, Lenny Moore.

[Indygal1218]

Jeff George, people would bow to his mullet....

 

[schwamm]

Brandon Burlsworth. Just because it was a shame his life ended without ever playing a snap. Tragic on a level far beyond football, but I would love to see how his career would have gone.

[BOTT]

Tony Siragusa

[Flying Elvis]

Whatever you do, don't bring back Joe Washington. I hated that guy. He killed us every time.

http://www.nfl.com/videos/nfl-game-highlights/09000d5d80747a43/Top-Ten-Elusive-Runners-Joe-Washington

[buccolts]

Whatever you do, don't bring back Joe Washington. I hated that guy. He killed us every time.

http://www.nfl.com/videos/nfl-game-highlights/09000d5d80747a43/Top-Ten-Elusive-Runners-Joe-Washington

 

Ah, good times.

[GOCOLTS_ROLLTIDE]

Cato June... Could you imagine him inside with Freeman... ridiculous

[braveheartcolt]

Freeney. If he was a rookie coming into a 3-4, he could be coached differently and become a much better all round player.

Just trying to be creative, so no need for anyone to get their cami's in a crease.

[Malakai432]

I take it you're not a Jeff George fan???

 

 

[jamesie jr]

Jeff Saturday

[Le Neon]

Jeff George, people would bow to his mullet....

lol

He was actually good for about thirty seconds in Oakland. Then got denied the Pro Bowl popularity contest, poor guy.

Pre injury Edge was a thing to behold. <---My choice.

[backshoulderfade]

Edge. That is all.

[Gramz]

Marvin,  no question.   After Peyton, he is next in line as my favorite to watch.