Jump to content
Indianapolis Colts
Indianapolis Colts Fan Forum

hilton, dorsett, moncrief vs harrison, wayne, stokely


CR91

  

88 members have voted

  1. 1. who do you pick

    • hilton dorsett moncrief
      9
    • harrison wayne stokley
      79


Recommended Posts

Marvin= outside of J.Rice, the greatest WR of all time. I dare anyone find stats, to prove the contrary, WAYNE, probably the second greatest colt WR and HOFamer, Stokely trade pait. Hilton, and etc. are young players getting better, Dorset is like lebron, getting credit before he hits the court/field. So let's not get ahead of ourselves. Besides, Hilton, Dorsett, Moncrief are like 2/3/4th WR anyways.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Marvin= outside of J.Rice, the greatest WR of all time. I dare anyone find stats, to prove the contrary, WAYNE, probably the second greatest colt WR and HOFamer, Stokely trade pait. Hilton, and etc. are young players getting better, Dorset is like lebron, getting credit before he hits the court/field. So let's not get ahead of ourselves. Besides, Hilton, Dorsett, Moncrief are like 2/3/4th WR anyways.

 

IMO Randy Moss > Marvin Harrison if we're talking about GOAT outside of Rice. Harrison easily cracks the top 5 or 10, but Moss was otherworldly. Big, had absurd hands, virtually uncoverable, freakish speed, commanded double teams and still had amazing statistics. Anyone remember when Revis tried to cover him 1-on-1 and blew his hamstring while hauled in the TD? Honestly, I've never seen a more pure and just naturally talented receiver than Moss. Sure he never got a ring, but neither did Barry Sanders.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

moncrief has tons of talent and he's bigger just needs more time to develop he didn't get a lot of playing time

If he starts to play the ball more agressively, uses that frame to box out corners more often and continues developing his route tree then I believe we have a perennial 1000-yard wide out on our hands.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

This should be a landslide, 100% to 0%. Not even a question.

 

Correct. I assumed, when I saw the title, there would be some kind of a twist or something. The only way this poll is close is if you said "today, right now, who do you take..."  :goat:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hay @steamboat_shaun,and @IndyTrav.I don't mean to take the steam out of your engine, but if we want to use your sites, you actually prove my point.

Moss= Games =219, yards = 15,200

Marvin= 190, yards= 14,500

T.Owens= 219, yards= 15,900

What we see here is that, Owens and moss played 29 more games right? And had 1500 more yards. How many games are in a season 16 right? They almost played 2 whole seasons more than Marvin. So if Marvin played just as many games, what does that mean? Just becuz B.Farve played for half a century, doesn't make him the greatest QB ever. You got to be more careful.

And Moss only had 700 more yards than Marvin, despite playing 29 more games.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

....TO was better.... Hands weren't as good as Marvs, but was an athletic freak....Total nut job, and diva, but an absolute monster on the football field.....

TO had a ton of drops in crucial situations. Jimmy Johnson even charted them on FOX one morning.....it wasn't pretty. But I guess Marvin's post season troubles kinda cancels that out as far that debate.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hay @steamboat_shaun,and @IndyTrav.I don't mean to take the steam out of your engine, but if we want to use your sites, you actually prove my point.

Moss= Games =219, yards = 15,200

Marvin= 190, yards= 14,500

T.Owens= 219, yards= 15,900

What we see here is that, Owens and moss played 29 more games right? And had 1500 more yards. How many games are in a season 16 right? They almost played 2 whole seasons more than Marvin. So if Marvin played just as many games, what does that mean? Just becuz B.Farve played for half a century, doesn't make him the greatest QB ever. You got to be more careful.

And Moss only had 700 more yards than Marvin, despite playing 29 more games.

It means that one of the above played with Peyton Manning. Not saying you don't have a valid argument, although I disagree, but just throwing up stats isn't going to change anyone's mind.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Stokely is one of my all time favorite Colts (and players, for that matter). 

 

The three of them are a historic trio. Dorsett hasn't caught a ball yet. If the new trio can do some damage for a couple seasons then we can start having that discussion. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

O.o Stokely was pretty good, why the hate?

He was, just didn't really care for him. No hate, just less appreciated of the 2 before him lol

Harrison & Wayne paired with Clark.... really wasn't a need for Stokely. But I thank him for all he did for us, just wasn't one of my favorite colts is all

Link to comment
Share on other sites

He was, just didn't really care for him. No hate, just less appreciated of the 2 before him lol

Harrison & Wayne paired with Clark.... really wasn't a need for Stokely. But I thank him for all he did for us, just wasn't one of my favorite colts is all

Fair enough, :thmup: but that was a pretty good cast with Clark at the TE and Stokely in the slot. I hope our

TE and WR squad can come close to the excitement that these guys brought to the games.

 

Heckuva receiving game back then.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
  • Thread of the Week

  • Topics

  • Posts

    • This is true. But even once AR started throwing downfield more (comeback against LAR and TEN game), AP still only had one downfield target. With AD here and Downs coming into year 2, I just don't see a huge bump for AP coming. 
    • I think AD can win on the nine routes well enough to be that deep threat (he's got the long speed), but more importantly, he also can win on all the routes where AP really hasn't (AD really shined in the RZ too at Texas).   I think he will be a RZ threat right away and can be a really solid WR2 (assuming he becomes a willing blocker and the effort stuff is behind him). Don't know if he will ever a YAC machine though.   Does Harmon mean that his evaluation of AP coming out of college was similar to the "DK can only run nine routes and can't move laterally" evaluation? I don't entirely remember DK's evaluation, but I recall it sounding something like that.
    • Lawrence Owen recently said that Brandon Aiyuk is a "system WR who wouldn't put up 700 yards on 90% of NFL teams." He's about as untrusty of a narrator as you can possibly get. And like us watching at home, he is not privy to the route calls, the playcalls, the reads, etc.    But I watched the video. AP had a great game. However, Lawrence is driving this narrative with this one game against arguably the worst pass defense in the NFL last year. Fulton (#26), who was on AP much of this game, was especially bad last year, registering a 46 PFF grade.     They had mismatches all over coming into the game and they exploited it from the beginning, hence AP's involvement. It's really not any deeper than that. This game was a complete outlier from any other game too, as far as production.       So Minshew held back the whole team, but benefited MPJ and Downs?    If AP was getting open all the time and it was "like this every game", he wouldn't have ended up #124 in win route rate or #110 in avg. separation (min. 45 tgts). The people who watch every game and the tools that track these stats don't support this idea.   As someone said earlier, targets are earned. Minshew is executing the offense, but Steichen is the calling the plays and assigning reads in the RPO. So why wasn't Steichen dialing up more plays after this TEN game? Minshew made the throws in this game, so clearly he can make the throws.   And even with AR, who we know can make all the throws, they were hardly dialing up plays for AP either.   With the drafting of AD, it speaks volumes about who is holding back AP.
    • It’s gotta be one of those two or Laiatu.  I guess I’d say Odunze, since TE didn’t end up being a position we hit at all, so there’s no proof CB considered it a need.  However, that doesn’t mean we wouldn’t trade up for a unique talent (Bowers) for whom we have a “plan”…
    • Does it mean anything to you that Kwity had 2 less sacks than $170M Joey Bosey? Bosa played 180 more snaps. Kwity did a great job playing his edge, the run, and covering his flat. He also got his breather on a lot of 3rd downs because... we were developing Dayo and had Lewis who was very effective in rotation on limited snaps.     
  • Members

    • jvan1973

      jvan1973 10,913

      Senior Member
      Joined:
      Last active:
    • HOZER

      HOZER 4,639

      Senior Member
      Joined:
      Last active:
    • ColtsHappy

      ColtsHappy 7

      Member
      Joined:
      Last active:
    • Lifetime Colt

      Lifetime Colt 176

      Member
      Joined:
      Last active:
    • NJFanatic

      NJFanatic 45

      New Member
      Joined:
      Last active:
    • Trace Pyott

      Trace Pyott 317

      Member
      Joined:
      Last active:
    • IndyJoe

      IndyJoe 0

      Rookie
      Joined:
      Last active:
    • AwesomeAustin

      AwesomeAustin 2,411

      Senior Member
      Joined:
      Last active:
    • That Guy

      That Guy 262

      Senior Member
      Joined:
      Last active:
    • IndyD4U

      IndyD4U 1,437

      Senior Member
      Joined:
      Last active:
×
×
  • Create New...