Which Colts Comeback Game was your favorite?

[ColtsHappy]

Peyton vs. Tampa or Andrew vs. Kansas City?

 

I can't decide, both epic, that is for sure!

 

Any others?

 

ColtsHappy

[Bluesmith]

Colts vs. New England AFCCG

[ar1888]

How about Colts vs Patriots 2006 season Championship game.

[jvan1973]

Hands down 06 AFCCG.

[IndyD4U]

I have to say Luck era, at home vs. GB 2012. The atmosphere, Pagano's diagnosis, BA, the comeback... the sheer emotion in that game was indescribable. I've never felt anything like it. Unbelievable

[Boiler_Colt]

AFCCG against NE because of the stakes and emotion of it. But I was just thinking about this today, I would say of my top 5 favorite comebacks 3 are from the Luck era: GB, Detroit and KC. TB and NE from the Manning era.

 

Special shout outs to the 4th and 2 game and the Rosencopter game.

[crazycolt1]

All those mentioned are very good choices.

[Stephen]

That Detroit game I was certain we'd lose and then the td as time ran out was heart attack material

[Steagles]

2006 AFC Championship

[BlueShoe]

That Detroit game I was certain we'd lose and then the td as time ran out was heart attack material

 

We were down like 3 scores with about 5 minutes to go. The only reason the Colts/Lions game is not discussed with the Colts/Bucs game is because it was not on prime time. 

[bestQBever]

I'll go with the second biggest comeback in postseason history.

[Nobody]

06 AFCCG, followed by the Packers game

[BigQandTheManiac]

can't go wrong with either

[UKColt13]

Purely because I wasn't around during most of the Peyton era, I would have to say our game in GB. Emotion and sheer determination to succeed.

 

Amazing.

[Hoosier]

The AFCCG is an obvious choice, but I was at the Chiefs playoff game, so I might have to go with that.

[ColtsHappy]

I was even thinking about the Pats Colts AFC Championship Game. I think that one was so stressful I had blocked it out!

 

     

 

I agree, all very good choices!

 

ColtsHappy

[ProblChld32]

06 championship game 

[Kyle]

Colts vs. New England AFCCG

This one.

 

Neither of the other 2 games made me go to the bathroom pretend I had to pee so that no one saw me start to tear up.    lol

[Malakai432]

I would have to agree w the AFCCG, the KC game was phenomenal and so was the Tampa game..

[ashtray]

What has always amazed me about Peyton's comebacks is how quickly they happened.  Against Tampa and Houston, they were down 3 scores with only a few minutes left.  They came back so quickly that they still had to fend off a late drive in each of those games.  In 06 against NE, they were down 18 late in the first half but had the game tied early in the third quarter. 

 

With Luck, it seems like his comebacks have been more sustained and have taken more time.  Hopefully Indy will get to the point where a Luck comeback is not needed.

[chad72]

The KC Chiefs playoff game comeback tops every other Luck comeback win to me.

 

The Tampa Bay Bucs comeback on MNF was Peyton's best comeback, given how little time was present and the fact we were down by 3 TDs, not just 3 scores.

[superrep1967]

Peyton vs. Tampa or Andrew vs. Kansas City?

 

I can't decide, both epic, that is for sure!

 

Any others?

 

ColtsHappy

Colts against Patroits AFC Championship

[southwest1]

Yes, the 2006 championship Game carried the most Lombardi significance I agree, but that Tampa Bay Bucs game against Warren Sapp, John Lynch, & Derrick Brooks was incredible in it's own right. 

[Farns01]

I will go with the Bucs game because we beat the defending Super Bowl Champion. More importantly Meshawn Johnson was mic'd up and talking smack about Marvin. Saying in head to head games with receivers in the same draft class he has beaten them all. Marvin made Meshawn look the fool. I just want throw in the 97 game against defending Super Bowl Champion Packers with Brett Farve. We beat them in the dome at an 0-10 season so far with back-up QB Paul Justin replacing an injured Jim Harbaugh.

[KokomoCorona]

It wasn't a win but the game i always think of is 1995 AFC championship. If Quentin Coryatt holds on to the int , we beat Dallas in the Super Bowl.

[Blue Horseshoe]

The 4th and two game against New England.

[OffensivelyPC]

2012 Colts vs Lions.  Best comeback in the Luck era and it's not even close.

[ColtsBlueFL]

My top 5:

 

Tied-

 

1a.  2003 Colts vs. Bucs  the reigning Super Bowl champs- Top D vs. Top O, Tony Dungy returns to Tampa Bay, on MNF

1b.  2112 Colts vs. Detroit Lions  (less drama than 1a though)

***************************************************************************************************************************************************8

2006 Colts vs. Patriots AFCCG  Epic second half showing versus a nemesis

2112 Colts vs. GB Packers Coltstrong!  Chuckstrong!!

1995 Colts vs. Miami  wk 6, Captain Comeback (Jim Harbaugh) bests Marino, Cardiac Kids barely make it to P.O. and AFCCG, lose to Steelers on last play Hail Mary

2013 Colts vs. KC Chiefs P.O.

[rittdk01]

Last years Chiefs game was my favorite comeback.  The Pats game in 06 to go to the SB is second.

[Buck Showalter]

'06 Pats AFC Champ game was awesome, especially being there,

but the Chuckstrong '12 win over GB is the only football game that has ever choked me up...