Andrew Luck, I see potential, but I just don't know

[YourNextGM]

I still question his arm strength.  I just don't see a big arm when he's playing outdoors.  I thought the gm would end on an int,  but a strip fumble is on Luck too imo.  

[Dustin]

Great thread OP. I agree, we should replace him ASAP. Which QB in the upcoming draft has the strongest arm? 

[BOTT]

YourNextTroll

[JlynRN]

Has everyone forgotten how well he played his 1st 3 years in the league???  Everyone acts like last year was his rookie season, so therefore he sucks.  

[YourNextGM]

I'd take Watson over him.  And probably Kaaya.  

[backshoulderfade]

Then you have no clue what you are watching. Denver had great coverage all day. Talib made a great play for the pick 6. Line let him down today against the most dominant front 7 in football. Strip sack wasn't on him.

[BPindy]

Already? I guess I shouldn't be surprised at how quick trolls are

[MTC]

1 minute ago, YourNextGM said:

I still question his arm strength.  I just don't see a big arm when he's playing outdoors.  I thought the gm would end on an int,  but a strip fumble is on Luck too imo.  

 

#BringBackHasselbeck

[SilentHill]

Hey mods, can we close this troll thread down?

[CantBeStopped]

5 sacks what the hell do you expect

[JlynRN]

How long did it take this thread to appear after the game ended??  30 seconds??  ROFL

[JPFolks]

He has had a bottom 10 top to bottom roster collectively since he's been here with marginal coaching (except for his brief time with Arians) and a GM who misses more than hits and fails to address issues in a timely manner. 

[snkdy]

Luck wasn't great tonight, but that strip sack wasn't his fault.

[threeflight]

I have said this for over a year. 

 

Is he a very good QB?  

 

Yes.

 

Should he be the highest paid player in the NFL?

 

Not even close.

 

He has a lot of faults. In fact I think fundamental wise, he was a much better QB his last year at Stanford then he is now.  He has regressed and I pin much of that on the OL and coaching.

[Bluefire4]

Would you rather have Cam Newton? Week one against Broncos he had 194 yards- one touchdown and a pick on 54% completion percentage.

 

This is a really good defense dude.

[Indyfan4life]

4 minutes ago, YourNextGM said:

I still question his arm strength.  I just don't see a big arm when he's playing outdoors.  I thought the gm would end on an int,  but a strip fumble is on Luck too imo.  

I didn't realize Luck has to avoid 5 guys by himself. What's that group of players called that are supposed to protect him? On the tip of my tongue... Can't name it. 

[YourNextGM]

1 minute ago, backshoulderfade said:

Then you have no clue what you are watching. Denver had great coverage all day. Talib made a great play for the pick 6. Line let him down today against the most dominant front 7 in football. Strip sack wasn't on him.

He missed wide open guys im the 1st qtr. I'm tired of him getting a pass from these slow starts.  And I hate his throwing motion w/ a passion.  Him and Phillip Rivers have the worst mechanics.  Horrible.  

[AKB]

I heard we are gonna trade him for Mark Shanchez

[Indyfan4life]

Just now, YourNextGM said:

He missed wide open guys im the 1st qtr. I'm tired of him getting a pass from these slow starts.  And I hate his throwing motion w/ a passion.  Him and Phillip Rivers have the worst mechanics.  Horrible.  

K. Bye. I'm sure you can go root for another team then. 

[NorthernBlue]

I just don't even know what to say at this point

[BOTT]

8 minutes ago, threeflight said:

I have said this for over a year. 

 

Is he a very good QB?  

 

Yes.

 

Should he be the highest paid player in the NFL?

 

Not even close.

 

He has a lot of faults. In fact I think fundamental wise, he was a much better QB his last year at Stanford then he is now.  He has regressed and I pin much of that on the OL and coaching.

You do know that they were playing the most dominant defense in the league, right?

 

i don't know what makes men dumber, women parts or football.

[Jules]

The Patriots have several backup QBs we can trade for.

 

Just kidding.

 

 

[Malakai432]

Denver's D is dominant, they make a lot of QBs look like crap. Lol

 

theyre super bowl champions and could probably win another soley based off their D.  

[a06cc]

The only thing Andrew did today that was his fault was that pick 6. That was on him. We have to get healthy period though.

[deedub75]

5 minutes ago, JlynRN said:

Has everyone forgotten how well he played his 1st 3 years in the league???  Everyone acts like last year was his rookie season, so therefore he sucks.  

 

He's put the team in some big holes and had some miraculous comebacks but he hasn't been consistent. 

[BOTT]

5 minutes ago, YourNextGM said:

I'd take Watson over him.  And probably Kaaya.  

Bubba Watson?

[jbaron04]

How was that on luck he made some bad throw and reads, I'm just happy he leaving the game healthy the way rietz was playing 

[coltsfanatic24]

Denver has a great defense but I do think at times the media seem to overhype him. He will never be Rodgers, Brady, or Peyton because of the turnovers. I said this two years ago but Luck is very similar to Farve. He's a gunslinger that will continue to make risky throws. 

[deedub75]

6 minutes ago, backshoulderfade said:

Then you have no clue what you are watching. Denver had great coverage all day. Talib made a great play for the pick 6. Line let him down today against the most dominant front 7 in football. Strip sack wasn't on him.

The line isn't good. How can you say the line let him down?  They are easily overmatched by average to good defenses. 

[SteelCityColt]

3 minutes ago, threeflight said:

I have said this for over a year. 

 

Is he a very good QB?  

 

Yes.

 

Should he be the highest paid player in the NFL?

 

Not even close.

 

He has a lot of faults. In fact I think fundamental wise, he was a much better QB his last year at Stanford then he is now.  He has regressed and I pin much of that on the OL and coaching.

 

 

Shocker I know, but the contract amounts given out don't correlate just to your current ability. It's a market and as such other forces are in action.

 

Ask the question another way... if he was a FA, how much do you think he'd get paid?

[SP_21]

7 minutes ago, YourNextGM said:

I'd take Watson over him.  And probably Kaaya.  

Watson is a system QB with no great qualities other than his mobility. Kaaya is pretty good but nowhere near Lucks level. 

 

Please go away troll 

[Jules]

Can we get Tebow out of baseball?

 

Is Manziel sober enough to play?

 

 

[BOTT]

1 minute ago, coltsfanatic24 said:

Denver has a great defense but I do think at times the media seem to overhype him. He will never be Rodgers, Brady, or Peyton because of the turnovers. I said this two years ago but Luck is very similar to Farve. He's a gunslinger that will continue to make risky throws. 

Yeah, with chudzinski he's had one interceptions in 3 games. Taking risks all the way /s

[backshoulderfade]

Just now, deedub75 said:

The line isn't good. How can you say the line let him down?  They are easily overmatched by average to good defenses. 

How is that performance not letting him down? Regardless of whether the line is bad or not. Good or bad, they still let their QB down. Not sure what you are even trying to say here 

[BOTT]

Now I understand the Trump thing.........

[AKB]

Just now, BOTT said:

Now I understand the Trump thing.........

It's shocking isn't it? And they're everywhere. 

[Smonroe]

7 minutes ago, YourNextGM said:

He missed wide open guys im the 1st qtr. I'm tired of him getting a pass from these slow starts.  And I hate his throwing motion w/ a passion.  Him and Phillip Rivers have the worst mechanics.  Horrible.  

 

Now you know how most of us feel about you.  

[deedub75]

Just now, backshoulderfade said:

How is that performance not letting him down? Regardless of whether the line is bad or not. Good or bad, they still let their QB down. Not sure what you are even trying to say here 

 

I would put that more on the GM than the players themselves. 

[coltsfanatic24]

1 minute ago, BOTT said:

Yeah, with chudzinski he's had one interceptions in 3 games. Taking risks all the way /s

It's not just the INT's It's the fumbles. Since Luck entented the league he's been top 5 in turnovers. It's the gunslinger mentality and holding on to the ball far too long. 

[JPFolks]

13 minutes ago, YourNextGM said:

I'd take Watson over him.  And probably Kaaya.  

Watson hasn't looked great this year so far against weak college competition and we've seen the RG3/Kaepernick/Geno Smith QB's who run like crazy but die in the NFL.... beyond that you''re not going to be anyone's next gm with that assessment.