If You Could Trade For Anyone...

[tvturner]

If you could do a realistic trade with any team in the league for your dream player, who would you want, and what would you give? 

I'd take any of these guys:

Patrick Peterson

J.J. Watt

Kam Chancellor

Earl Thomas

Jamaal Charles

 

[#BringBobBack]

Kam Chancellor out of that list without a doubt for a 1st round pick

[C0lts088]

Jj watt for sure although there's no way I see him 'realistically' being traded

Revis would be interesting, pairing him with Vontae

Would love me some clay Matthews as well

Megatron?

[SDakColts]

I'll take Earl Thomas out of that list, and we would finally get the FS we have been looking for. Definitely have to give up a 1st this year and a 3rd next year to even be in the ballpark. Another option I would love would be giving up a 1st this year and a conditional 2nd or 3rd round pick the following year for Khalil Mack.

[backshoulderfade]

I don't think there is a realiatic trade but JJ Watt.

[esmort]

[Gavin]

Watt

[akcolt]

You obviously would want a franchise QB or the best non QB. We have our franchise QB so JJ Watt not sure what a fair deal would be

[backshoulderfade]

You obviously would want a franchise QB or the best non QB. We have our franchise QB so JJ Watt not sure what a fair deal would be

To be honest, Grigson would be laughed out the room at the suggestion of trading for any of these guys. Multiple firsts would not do it.

[Nobody]

Patrick Peterson, with his awful play, huge contract, and now he turns out to be diabetic? I would not trade for him

[Yoshinator]

I would trade for someone not on your list that is an awesome player, Luke Kuechly. Hopefully our 1st and 2nd this year along with our 1st and 3rd next year would do it.

[RealityIsLuck]

JJ Watt, no question.

[wig]

I would trade for someone not on your list that is an awesome player, Luke Kuechly. Hopefully our 1st and 2nd this year along with our 1st and 3rd next year would do it.

I'm with you. A stud ILB changes the defense completely.

[Dustin]

Watt and Thomas would be the only ones I'd consider. That being said, it's JJ Watt. 

[12isthenew18]

i'm going to act like there's a cap so I'd say

Reshad Jones

Eric Weddle

Bashaud Breeland

Desmond Trufant

Leveon Bell

Shady

Andrew Whitworth

Either pouncey brother

John Brown

Damon Harrison

Others but not to mind

[BOTT]

Duh

[rock8591]

1st rounder for Jamie Collins. HIGHLY HIGHLY HIGHLY doubt they trade a future cornerstone to a division rival.

[COLTS449]

Obviously JJ Watt. He's the best defensive player in the league and would fill a position of desperate need. Also. Patrick Peterson is a really good corner, but he's still somewhat overrated.

[BlueShoe]

If you could do a realistic trade with any team in the league for your dream player, who would you want, and what would you give? 

I'd take any of these guys:

Patrick Peterson

J.J. Watt

Kam Chancellor

Earl Thomas

Jamaal Charles

 

J.J. Watt is the best defensive player in the NFL. The Colts need more on the defensive side of the ball, so this is a no-brainer. 

 

If we are looking at this from a Colts point of view, then I would take some offensive linemen over anyway not named J.J. Watt on that list. 

[12isthenew18]

1st rounder for Jamie Collins. HIGHLY HIGHLY HIGHLY doubt they trade a future cornerstone to a division rival.

we're in different divisions. I thought people knew plus we aren't rivals with NE because rivalries aren't one sided

[Briggs32]

JJ Watt. Best defensive player and possibly the best overall player in the game. 2nd would be Thomas. best DB in the game.

[FalseStart]

Leon Sandcastle....

[BlueShoe]

Leon Sandcastle....

 

If he was 20 years younger then hell yeah. He would be a perfect fit for this current Colts team. His job would be simple here too; play man on the outside, and rarely even have to make a tackle. 

 

Can you imagine Sanders and Davis together in this scheme?

[BProland85]

Bill Bellichick...you said anyone and he's by far the best coach in the game.

[UKColt13]

Well it would always be JJ Watt.

He's a gamewrecker.

But unless we gave them Luck I don't see it ever happening for all the picks in the world. Plus it would ruin us cap-wise.

But a guy can dream, right?

[open window]

Watt or Trent Williams, Calvin Johnson would also be scary with Luck. Hopefully the Johnson we signed still has his game at least this first year.

[jseg18]

One that won't seem out of reach. How about Mohammed Wilkerson from the Jets

[21isSuperman]

JJ Watt is the most dominant defensive player in the game and a legit MVP candidate.  I'd take him out of anyone else on the list.

[Gavin]

Watt

[Superman]

If you could do a realistic trade with any team in the league for your dream player, who would you want, and what would you give? 

I'd take any of these guys:

Patrick Peterson

J.J. Watt

Kam Chancellor

Earl Thomas

Jamaal Charles

 

JJ Watt, and I'd give up anyone on our team not named Andrew Luck. I'd probably give up any two players on our team, aside from Luck. Yes, that includes a Hilton and Davis combo.

 

Or I'd give up any one player not named Luck + our entire draft class, or two years of first rounders.

 

And it's not even a hard decision. I'd hate to lose our guys, but for Watt? I'd push the button so fast and hard I'd probably break it.

[John Dee]

A STUD ILB is ONLY as good as the stud's DT's playing in front of him...

 

I'm with you. A stud ILB changes the defense completely.

[John Dee]

JJ is the ONLY answer.   He is a TRUE impact player...  which makes him unrealistic...    but what ever.. I'd take him over any player on Indy like S said...      not named LUCK>   ANYONE 

JJ Watt, and I'd give up anyone on our team not named Andrew Luck. I'd probably give up any two players on our team, aside from Luck. Yes, that includes a Hilton and Davis combo.

 

Or I'd give up any one player not named Luck + our entire draft class, or two years of first rounders.

 

And it's not even a hard decision. I'd hate to lose our guys, but for Watt? I'd push the button so fast and hard I'd probably break it.

[wig]

A STUD ILB is ONLY as good as the stud's DT's playing in front of him...

Not true at all. Elite players at any position cover up other's mistakes.