Erlinger’s replacement

[indyagent17]

Let’s face it Flacco. Is nearly 4 and  on a one year deal and Erlinger doesn’t look like he’s ever gonna be ready for prime time. I hoping Slovis or Pennix can step up 

[Patrick Miller]

16 minutes ago, indyagent17 said:

Let’s face it Flacco. Is nearly 4 and  on a one year deal and Erlinger doesn’t look like he’s ever gonna be ready for prime time. I hoping Slovis or Pennix can step up 

You mean bean? Isn’t pennix a RB?

[indyagent17]

7 minutes ago, Patrick Miller said:

You mean bean? Isn’t pennix a RB?

Yes sorry about that 

8 minutes ago, Patrick Miller said:

You mean bean? Isn’t pennix a RB?

WR

[2006Coltsbestever]

Who is Erlinger? Penix got drafted by the Falcons . Flacco is our backup and good one. He won a SB.

[2006Coltsbestever]

This thread is confusing. 

[DattMavis]

9 minutes ago, 2006Coltsbestever said:

This thread is confusing. 

I had a dream Wednesday night that all of the draft choices for the entire draft had somehow been leaked in advance by Rapoport. The Colts were taking a QB in the 1st round.

This thread confused me more than that dream.

[Yoshinator]

11 minutes ago, DattMavis said:

I had a dream Wednesday night that all of the draft choices for the entire draft had somehow been leaked in advance by Rapoport. The Colts were taking a QB in the 1st round.

This thread confused me more than that dream.

I had a dream two nights ago that I was playing Killer Instinct with Mike Tyson and beat him with Combo. Except the game had Super Smash Bros mechanics. Then after I won, Mike Tyson wanted a rematch the next day. I said no problem. Never got to give him that rematch and woke up for day 3 of the draft. 

 

That dream was also confusing lol. 

[DattMavis]

2 minutes ago, Yoshinator said:

I had a dream two nights ago that I was playing Killer Instinct with Mike Tyson and beat him with Combo. Except the game had Super Smash Bros mechanics. Then after I won, Mike Tyson wanted a rematch the next day. I said no problem. Never got to give him that rematch and woke up for day 3 of the draft. 

 

That dream was also confusing lol. 

That's a sick fever dream!

I played Smash semi-competitively in high school, so I used to only have really stressful dreams about Smash Bros. 😂

[Yoshinator]

1 minute ago, DattMavis said:

That's a sick fever dream!

I played Smash semi-competitively in high school, so I used to only have really stressful dreams about Smash Bros. 😂

I was a very good Marth player on Melee, but never played any big tourneys. Never really got into any of the modern Smash games. With Ultimate I thought about it, but the sheer number of characters they put on the game ruined it for me. Didn't feel special anymore.

[DattMavis]

13 minutes ago, Yoshinator said:

I was a very good Marth player on Melee, but never played any big tourneys. Never really got into any of the modern Smash games. With Ultimate I thought about it, but the sheer number of characters they put on the game ruined it for me. Didn't feel special anymore.

I mained Marth in Melee as well. I moved to Ike with Brawl, which was my last game. I really just played in some local and regional stuff. 

I play Ultimate with my nephews once or twice a year. It's fun, but nothing beats the nostalgia of 64 or Melee.

[2006Coltsbestever]

1 hour ago, Yoshinator said:

I had a dream two nights ago that I was playing Killer Instinct with Mike Tyson and beat him with Combo. Except the game had Super Smash Bros mechanics. Then after I won, Mike Tyson wanted a rematch the next day. I said no problem. Never got to give him that rematch and woke up for day 3 of the draft. 

 

That dream was also confusing lol. 

[John Waylon]

[Yoshinator]

45 minutes ago, John Waylon said:

Did you have a dream about Beavis and Butthead? LOL  

[Chucklez]

8 hours ago, DattMavis said:

I mained Marth in Melee as well. I moved to Ike with Brawl, which was my last game. I really just played in some local and regional stuff. 

I play Ultimate with my nephews once or twice a year. It's fun, but nothing beats the nostalgia of 64 or Melee.

I can never decide which I loved more, 64 or Melee.

64 for the pure nostalgia and it being the first.... Melee for really building on 64 and improving it. Such good games.

Btw Link for ever, with a side of Pikachu.

[Smonroe]

6 hours ago, Yoshinator said:

Did you have a dream about Beavis and Butthead? LOL  

 

This thread went off the rails.  Just like this AI interview.  

 

 

[indyagent17]

All I wanted to do is get a conversation going about Erlinger’s replacement.

[Smonroe]

12 minutes ago, indyagent17 said:

All I wanted to do is get a conversation going about Erlinger’s replacement.

 

Flacco is clearly # 2.  I'm not sure if Elhinger should make the 53.  Unless he's basically a coach or a whiz in the film room.  Even then, with the new rules he'd be safe on the PS.  

 

There are dozens of guys who could fill his spot if you're looking towards the future.

[Chucklez]

1 hour ago, indyagent17 said:

All I wanted to do is get a conversation going about Erlinger’s replacement.

I don't think there will be one.

 

Ehlinger is the 3rd string. Flacco is Minshews replacement as number 2. If both Richardson and Flacco are down for any amount of time the season is over anyways. 

 

We will ride out Sam Ehlingers contract and then let him drift off to whoever wants him.

[ADnum1]

53 minutes ago, Chucklez said:

I don't think there will be one.

 

Ehlinger is the 3rd string. Flacco is Minshews replacement as number 2. If both Richardson and Flacco are down for any amount of time the season is over anyways. 

 

We will ride out Sam Ehlingers contract and then let him drift off to whoever wants him.

I tend to agree with this.

 

Although I would give Sam the opportunity to compete with Flacco for the number 2

[1959Colts]

I predict Sam will keep his spot on the roster thru 2024

[Smonroe]

8 minutes ago, 1959Colts said:

I predict Sam will keep his spot on the roster thru 2024

 

I think you're probably right, but for the life of me I don't know why.  They're paying him $1M if he stays on the 53.  But that's not a concern.

 

The spot could be used for an extra player, maybe a specialist, or another ST player.

 

They could put Sam on the PS and activate every week if they wanted, as the emergency QB.  

 

 

[BlackTiger]

He will compete with Slovis and Bean for a spot this year

[AustexColt]

Erlinger will be our 3rd QB. Ballard and Irsay loves this kid. He is 100% better than the current Univ Texas QB, Quinn Ewers who has been throwing to AD Mitchell. Aside of AR he is mobile whereas Flacco is not.

[Shive]

I could see Slovis challenging Ehlinger for QB3. He's more athletic than Ehlinger and showed flashes of a potential 1st round QB prospect as a freshman at USC. Some stability and a chance to reset might be exactly what he needs. His upside is WAY higher than Ehlinger's and we've already seen him do it. It's just a matter of if he can get back to that level of play.

[CoachLite]

On 5/2/2024 at 10:12 AM, AustexColt said:

Erlinger will be our 3rd QB. Ballard and Irsay loves this kid. He is 100% better than the current Univ Texas QB, Quinn Ewers who has been throwing to AD Mitchell. Aside of AR he is mobile whereas Flacco is not.

Don't perpetuate Sam's name spelling errors! It's Ehlinger!

[lollygagger8]

Erlinger 

 

[MikeCurtis]

On opinion from the peanut gallery

 

Sam E is going into year 3

 

If he was practicing well and had command of this offense I don’t think we are spending the cash on a vet to back up AR

 

Im not sure that he will ever be someone to turn the team over to 

 

IMHO I hope the 2 QBs that we brought in as udfas get a true competition against Sam E

 

 

[indyagent17]

On 5/3/2024 at 5:24 PM, MikeCurtis said:

On opinion from the peanut gallery

 

Sam E is going into year 3

 

If he was practicing well and had command of this offense I don’t think we are spending the cash on a vet to back up AR

 

Im not sure that he will ever be someone to turn the team over to 

 

IMHO I hope the 2 QBs that we brought in as udfas get a true competition against Sam E

 

 

Let’s face it AR news to stop getting an injury positions. Secondly Flacko is almost 40 years old and Sam looks terrible. Whatever he is out there. I hate to say it, but there is a decent chance that the third string quarterback could play a game this season, especially with an illness or a minor injury.

[AwesomeAustin]

I will be honest. The third string QB spot really is of little concern only bc it should be used to groom the future backup in hopes to free up salary cap space. However, if we are going to contend with a running type QB, I believe we will always be spending money on a good backup. Would be great to get a guy on a rookie contract capable of filling the position but typically those guys need 3-5yrs of “grooming” to be nfl ready. So, I guess I consider #3 Qb no man’s land and just throwing stuff against the wall to see what sticks. Whoever they choose has little to no bearing on this team. If we get down to this guy we are most likely dead in the water. 

[John Hammonds]

Ok, here's my prediction.

Both Flacco and Ehlinger will be on the team this year.  And for similar reasons.

1. Flacco is here expressly to lead the team to the playoffs as a seasoned veteran quarterback, in case AR5 gets injured again.
2. Ehlinger is here in case both quarterbacks go down, if they just need somebody to play.

Next year?

1. Flacco will probably not be here, simply because of his age.
2. Ehlinger will probably not be here, simply because there's no reason to give him a contract beyond his rookie deal.

I predict that next year, we will sign yet another seasoned veteran quarterback.  To do the exact same thing that Flacco is here to do.  Lead the team to the playoffs in case AR5 is hurt.

And I also predict we draft another mid-round quarterback.  For the same reason Ehlinger is here.  To be an inexpensive guy to play the position just in case both quarterbacks go down.

 

Who is my veteran quarterback for next year?  I'm guessing Andy Dalton.  No, he's not my choice for starter.  But if I needed a guy to back up AR5, who's a "been there, done that" kind of guy, to play just in case...  Yeah, I would think so.

[holeymoley99]

On 5/3/2024 at 9:48 AM, Shive said:

I could see Slovis challenging Ehlinger for QB3. He's more athletic than Ehlinger and showed flashes of a potential 1st round QB prospect as a freshman at USC. Some stability and a chance to reset might be exactly what he needs. His upside is WAY higher than Ehlinger's and we've already seen him do it. It's just a matter of if he can get back to that level of play.

Yeah I think Slovis has a legit shot, had that great freshman season where as was stated looked like a possible 1st round pick then never got back there but if coaches can tap into it no reason he cant beat out Sam. As for Bean he was bench at KU for Jalon Daniels, he is also very thin framed so appears to be a camp arm only (Having been a college teammate of Cole Ballard who was his understudy once Daniels was injured didnt hurt thats for sure).

[OhioColt]

Let's all make it through this season first. 

 

After that I wouldn't mind going after Mac Jones as our #2 backup behind AR.  Do realize Jones was traded to the Jaguars but currently listed as a 2024 free agent.  Jones' 2020 season still is the highest-graded season by a FBS QB in PFF College era since 2014 and still leads all QBs with an impressive 95.8 grade.  Zach Wilson also in 2020 had a 95.4 grade, Joe Burrow in 2019 had a 94.9 grade, Jayden Daniels in 2023 had a 94.7 grade, and Kyler Murray in 2018 had a 94.6 grade.  

 

Still a lot of hope around AR and yet still a lot of uncertainty given his short college career.  Very similar to Caleb Williams.  More worrisome about injury projections.  Flacco should be good for one season.  Unfortunately for the Colts signing Flacco we lost out of any 2025 NFL Draft compensatory picks losing Gardner Minshew.  My top upcoming NFL draft replacements for Flacco, after Mac Jones, would be Jalen Milroe (Alabama) and Jaxson Dart (Mississippi).  A lot to like about both.  Milroe is a dual threat QB and Dart elevated his play in Lane Kiffin's RPO/play-action-heavy offense.  Dart's already breaking Eli Manning's college records.  Dart's great at working outside of the pocket and clearly needs to get better staying in the pocket.

 

As for Ehlingher's replacements can see the Colts look at Coastal Carolina's Grayson McCall another mobile pocket passer with quick release speed or K.J. Jefferson (Arkansas) another dual threat QB.

[Scott Pennock]

Slovis will earn the 3rd QB spot - here are my reasons:

 

Coached in HS by Kurt Warner

Compares favorably to Minshew with Pocket Prescence, fearless nature and his accuracy in the short and intermediate levels - which SS has proven he can adapt the offense to and still win

At USC ran a version of the Air Raid offense throwing balls to Pittman, Amon Ra St. Brown, Tyler Vaughns (former Colt - UDFA) and Drake London - good batch of receivers to throw to I would say

At Pitt he operated a run-heavy pro-style system

At BYU he operated a motion style system

Well versed in many different styles of play and SS uses a bit of all of those concepts in his RPO Style offense

 

Bean will earn the 4th all while transitioning to WR on the PS

 

I think he sticks around purely based on his athleticism

If he makes a successful conversion to WR then imaging him being on the gameday roster as your 4rd QB and/or a trick play machine and/or decoy

[craigerb]

On 5/6/2024 at 3:07 PM, John Hammonds said:

1. Ehlinger is here in case both quarterbacks go down, if they just need somebody to play.

Yes, Captain Obvious, if both quarterbacks go down, you do need somebody to play.

[Introspect]

6 hours ago, craigerb said:

Yes, Captain Obvious, if both quarterbacks go down, you do need somebody to play.

[RollerColt]

Is the forum experiencing a Prozac shortage or something? 

[AwesomeAustin]

2 hours ago, RollerColt said:

Is the forum experiencing a Prozac shortage or something? 

I find it funny what some people key in on and respond. Like that’s what you think needs added to conversation. We are all probably guilty of it at some time or another. 

[ImissPeyton18]

On 4/29/2024 at 10:08 AM, Chucklez said:

I don't think there will be one.

 

Ehlinger is the 3rd string. Flacco is Minshews replacement as number 2. If both Richardson and Flacco are down for any amount of time the season is over anyways. 

 

We will ride out Sam Ehlingers contract and then let him drift off to whoever wants him.

Sam Ehlinger does get paid for his services right? If he has no future here, then why pay him until his contract runs out when you can stick another qb in his spot an see what happens? Slovis or anyone else should be allowed to replace Sam without too much problem if Sam is not good enough to be a number 2 qb. Having 2 qb's suit up every week is needed. the third qb

is going to be on the practice squad. I would think 1 year on the practice squad is normal. year two on the practice squad seems like a waste of time. your not good enough to make the roster so why keep them around and deprive another athlete of a chance to be seen?

 

 

 

[Chucklez]

13 hours ago, ImissPeyton18 said:

Sam Ehlinger does get paid for his services right? If he has no future here, then why pay him until his contract runs out when you can stick another qb in his spot an see what happens? Slovis or anyone else should be allowed to replace Sam without too much problem if Sam is not good enough to be a number 2 qb. Having 2 qb's suit up every week is needed. the third qb

is going to be on the practice squad. I would think 1 year on the practice squad is normal. year two on the practice squad seems like a waste of time. your not good enough to make the roster so why keep them around and deprive another athlete of a chance to be seen?

 

 

 

You can absolutely argue this from a roster spot point of view, and from a kicking the tyres on someone else point of view.

But a think having Ehlinger around, who knows the system now, and has experience with this team and players as the 3rd QB has value as well. Helps with the the entire practice squad player's development. So his value is more as a supporting piece rather than as an individual player. 

But I get the argument for the extra roster spot for someone else to try out too.

[Dark Superman]

On 4/28/2024 at 9:15 PM, indyagent17 said:

Let’s face it Flacco. Is nearly 4 and  on a one year deal and Erlinger doesn’t look like he’s ever gonna be ready for prime time. I hoping Slovis or Pennix can step up 

You do realize Joe Flacco was signed to be the backup. There's no competition between him and Ehlinger. Ehlinger will be battling for a roster spot against Slovis and Bean.