I think that's a pretty good comparison. Smith has very soft hands. I have seen him snatch some balls you don't think he has a shot at. He pulls them up off the turf like he is playing baseball. Unlike Pierre I have not seen him drop easy ones.
I think the only thing that could send him to the PS is a limited route tree. That's about the Hawks O. When they needed a big play Smith was the man.I thought his long TD was going to get them past MSU
I'm not sure if that was really their plan. I think they wanted to rebuild and win now at the same time expecting Luck to be able to carry the team and cover up a lot of deficiencies. After 4 years, this team is still a work in progress. We are still and older than average team. I think they kind of hit the reset button this offseason with their FA signings and draft picks. Fortunately, we seem to have some young talent to develop now.
I think the die is cast on this question. The Super Bowl appearances pretty well lock up Wilson and Cam's Status for many years to come. The both play on much better teams than the Colts. They are going to keep winning and add more Sper Bowls to that record. Luck may win the stats battle but I do not expect him to keep pace with them in meaningful wins. I will be pleased if Luck corrects flaws in his game that lead him to take so much punishment. If he does not do that, he is the least likely of the three to still be playing in 2021. He will have all he can handle in trying to stay ahead or get ahead of young studs like Winston and And the Titans QB. The Colts are rebuilding and coming down to earth. I expect the other teams in the South to rise above them in coming years. I know that this is not a rosy picture that most will want to hear.