Jump to content
Indianapolis Colts
Indianapolis Colts Fan Forum

What If We Shock The World And Take Rg3?!


bWild

Recommended Posts

  • Replies 105
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Please...this is the last thing I want to think about...And what's with the comparison's of RG3 and Cam Newton??? RG3 is just over 6'2, 220lbs Cam newton is 6'5, 250lbs. Cam Newton was great cause of his size, you see him play in Charlotte?(I live in Charlotte and watched almost every game this year).

RG3 reminds me of Leaf the more I think about it and I can't see us passing on Luck...RG3 wasn't even close to Luck in the draft order till recently, he was projected at 5 in some earlier mock drafts. I think we would regret not taking Luck...I just want the Draft to get here so I can stop thinking of the "What if's"...

The risk is higher on RG3 with less reward in my opinion, I see Luck as the only decision, it's not even a question...

Link to comment
Share on other sites

no, Luck ran a 4.4...which is PLENTY fast enough for a guy who is supposed to THROW the ball, not run with it. Luck also hasnt already blown out an knee, like RGIII has... "enough said"

yeah so he was a whole .1 second slower then RG3. everything else he matched Cam Newtons combine stats and RG3 was behind luck.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I'm gonna get lit up for this but whatever.

The first time I saw an Andrew Luck/Stanford game, I thought of Tom Brady. I despise New England, but I respect Brady for his playing ability and his accomplishments. He is the enemy, but he's a great quarterback. 97% of the time he's calm, cool & collected in the pocket. He doesn't usually get rattled. He doesn't usually make bone-headed mistakes. Andrew Luck, at Stanford, looked the same way. But Luck has better mobility/athleticism and he's physically bigger/thicker.

RG3 may turn out to be a good NFL QB, and he's MUCH better above the shoulders than Ryan Leaf ever was. That said, I think it'd be a HUGE mistake if the Colts didn't draft Andrew Luck.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Let's be real; Grigson loves athletic players (Vick, Young, Jackson, etc.) and with the success of Cam Newton, it isn't out of the realm of possibility. RG3 won the Heisman, he's got a great attitude and work ethic, plus players rally around him in a pinch. I'm not saying that I don't think the same of Andrew Luck, but it's a new era of Colts football and a pocket passer might not be our direction. Think about it; a stout defense (which is in the building process), and an electrifying QB that could create a big play at any given moment= success at any level.

Our defense won't be cured over night, but it all begins with the players attitudes and the coach and his scheme that lead them to whatever success they have. Pagano is a players coach with a great & creative defensive mind. Don't think this will be Manusky's defense. It's Pagano's, and he'll have the reigns. I forsee big things from this unit next season.

Offensively, our philosophy would lean on the run more often and I think Donald Brown will have breakout season regardless of which QB we draft. If RG3 were in that mix it would increase our running potency tenfold. Not to mention our down-field potential in the passing game would benefit from it too. I'm not saying that this will happen, but what if?

Thoughts?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Please...this is the last thing I want to think about...And what's with the comparison's of RG3 and Cam Newton??? RG3 is just over 6'2, 220lbs Cam newton is 6'5, 250lbs. Cam Newton was great cause of his size, you see him play in Charlotte?(I live in Charlotte and watched almost every game this year).

RG3 reminds me of Leaf the more I think about it and I can't see us passing on Luck...RG3 wasn't even close to Luck in the draft order till recently, he was projected at 5 in some earlier mock drafts. I think we would regret not taking Luck...I just want the Draft to get here so I can stop thinking of the "What if's"...

The risk is higher on RG3 with less reward in my opinion, I see Luck as the only decision, it's not even a question...

RG3 is likely not even 6'2" when you see him in interviews. Looks like about 6' 1/2"

Link to comment
Share on other sites

he ran 2/10 of a second slower than RGIII....and how can you say "Let's be real; Grigson loves athletic players when Grigson has never been a GM until now, so "lets be real..." you have no idea who "loved" those players for the Eagles

Grigson was a scout. Scouts drool over guys like RG3, and for crying out loud, there's a difference between a 40 time and game speed.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Let's be real; Grigson loves athletic players (Vick, Young, Jackson, etc.) and with the success of Cam Newton, it isn't out of the realm of possibility. RG3 won the Heisman, he's got a great attitude and work ethic, plus players rally around him in a pinch. I'm not saying that I don't think the same of Andrew Luck, but it's a new era of Colts football and a pocket passer might not be our direction. Think about it; a stout defense (which is in the building process), and an electrifying QB that could create a big play at any given moment= success at any level.

Our defense won't be cured over night, but it all begins with the players attitudes and the coach and his scheme that lead them to whatever success they have. Pagano is a players coach with a great & creative defensive mind. Don't think this will be Manusky's defense. It's Pagano's, and he'll have the reigns. I forsee big things from this unit next season.

Offensively, our philosophy would lean on the run more often and I think Donald Brown will have breakout season regardless of which QB we draft. If RG3 were in that mix it would increase our running potency tenfold. Not to mention our down-field potential in the passing game would benefit from it too. I'm not saying that this will happen, but what if?

Thoughts?

Then I might decide to turn my back on the HorseShoe. They better take Luck.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

RG3 is no Leaf. He has more upstairs and a bigger heart. Leaf failed because of a lack of brains and desire, not because he lacked talent. If RG3 fails it's because his game doesn't translate to the NFL. As was said in an earlier post, he ran more of a spread offense from a shotgun formation. He had great stats, but the Big 12 had terrible defenses. I think I saw a stat that said he played against 5 defenses ranked in the bottom 25 in the country. It would also worry me that he only did it for 1 year. I know Newton also was a one year college wonder, but he is one of the very few to have success in the NFL.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

People are making ridiculous posts about bringing in Brandon Lloyd, trading for players like it was a game of Madden, and other silly scenarios, but I'm being crucified for asking what our team would look like taking RG3 over Andrew Luck?!

READ POSTS BEFORE YOU RANT!!!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Let's be real; Grigson loves athletic players (Vick, Young, Jackson, etc.) and with the success of Cam Newton, it isn't out of the realm of possibility. RG3 won the Heisman, he's got a great attitude and work ethic, plus players rally around him in a pinch. I'm not saying that I don't think the same of Andrew Luck, but it's a new era of Colts football and a pocket passer might not be our direction. Think about it; a stout defense (which is in the building process), and an electrifying QB that could create a big play at any given moment= success at any level.

Our defense won't be cured over night, but it all begins with the players attitudes and the coach and his scheme that lead them to whatever success they have. Pagano is a players coach with a great & creative defensive mind. Don't think this will be Manusky's defense. It's Pagano's, and he'll have the reigns. I forsee big things from this unit next season.

Offensively, our philosophy would lean on the run more often and I think Donald Brown will have breakout season regardless of which QB we draft. If RG3 were in that mix it would increase our running potency tenfold. Not to mention our down-field potential in the passing game would benefit from it too. I'm not saying that this will happen, but what if?

Thoughts?

I'm not sure why you are getting on people for responding why we should take Luck over RG3. Your post certainly looks more like you are making a case for drafting RG3 over Luck than does asking what the Colts would look like with RG3. That may not have been your intent, but when reading it it sure sounds that way.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

yeah so he was a whole .1 second slower then RG3. everything else he matched Cam Newtons combine stats and RG3 was behind luck.

thats my point (hopefully you're not arguing what i said! lol)... .1 seconds slower doesnt mean jack when you're supposed to be a QB and not a RB...especially when he's also the superior when it comes to throwing the ball, reading the defense etc

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Grigson was a scout. Scouts drool over guys like RG3, and for crying out loud, there's a difference between a 40 time and game speed.

scouts may drool over guys like RGIII, but if thats the case, then they would need a mop and bucket to clean up the drool over Luck...because he's the superior QB and only .1 seconds slower in a 40...which means absolutely NOTHING when you're a QB and not a RB or WR. Everyone went nuts over the #s that Cam Newton put up at the combine last year...well Luck either matched or beat every one of those, and is also much much better at THROWING the ball (which is important if you're the QB) and also much better at reading the other team's defense.

RGIII is the flavor of the month...Luck will easily be the better NFL QB. Scouts may drool over the #s that Michael Vick put up at the combine...but Peyton Manning is the greatest to ever play the position...and his combine #s wouldnt have wowed anyone

Link to comment
Share on other sites

People are making ridiculous posts about bringing in Brandon Lloyd, trading for players like it was a game of Madden, and other silly scenarios, but I'm being crucified for asking what our team would look like taking RG3 over Andrew Luck?!

READ POSTS BEFORE YOU RANT!!!

I'm not ranting. I'm just making fun of the fact there's another pick RGIII over Luck type of thread when there are already another 15 in the NFL draft section alone lmao

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Check out footage on him, I heard mechanicly he may need a little work but he can make all the throws, is athletic can run and as the post above mine said, he can run right through some one if he chooses, I would prefer he didnt but ya gotta do what ya gotta do

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Let's be real; Grigson loves athletic players (Vick, Young, Jackson, etc.) and with the success of Cam Newton, it isn't out of the realm of possibility. RG3 won the Heisman, he's got a great attitude and work ethic, plus players rally around him in a pinch. I'm not saying that I don't think the same of Andrew Luck, but it's a new era of Colts football and a pocket passer might not be our direction. Think about it; a stout defense (which is in the building process), and an electrifying QB that could create a big play at any given moment= success at any level.

Our defense won't be cured over night, but it all begins with the players attitudes and the coach and his scheme that lead them to whatever success they have. Pagano is a players coach with a great & creative defensive mind. Don't think this will be Manusky's defense. It's Pagano's, and he'll have the reigns. I forsee big things from this unit next season.

Offensively, our philosophy would lean on the run more often and I think Donald Brown will have breakout season regardless of which QB we draft. If RG3 were in that mix it would increase our running potency tenfold. Not to mention our down-field potential in the passing game would benefit from it too. I'm not saying that this will happen, but what if?

Thoughts?

ESPN & NFLN would be pleased.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Grigson was a scout. Scouts drool over guys like RG3, and for crying out loud, there's a difference between a 40 time and game speed.

But game speed hasn't kept Michael Vick or Vince Young off of the injury report... and Grigson had a front row seat to that.

I won't deny that Vick, Young, Newton and RGIII were or will be exciting players in their first 2-3 years. But sooner or later they get creamed by a defensive player or players that have nearly the speed they do and usually 30-60 lbs more weight and then the injuries start piling up.

It would shock the world... that much is true.

But I'm 99.9999999% sure Luck will be the pick.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

thats my point (hopefully you're not arguing what i said! lol)... .1 seconds slower doesnt mean jack when you're supposed to be a QB and not a RB...especially when he's also the superior when it comes to throwing the ball, reading the defense etc

lol no i wasnt arguing with what you said. i agree with what you said. Luck wasnt much slower then RG3 and he put up better numbers in the combine then RG3 other then that .1 second in the 40.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

lol no i wasnt arguing with what you said. i agree with what you said. Luck wasnt much slower then RG3 and he put up better numbers in the combine then RG3 other then that .1 second in the 40.

honestly, i dunno why so many people are concerned with a QB's 40 time...i doubt that Montana, Marino, Manning etc wouldve ran a good 40 time...and Tom Brady looked ridiculously bad as far as athletic potential, at his combine...

Michael Vick had a great combine...and now misses half of every single season he plays...

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Let's be real; Grigson loves athletic players (Vick, Young, Jackson, etc.) and with the success of Cam Newton, it isn't out of the realm of possibility. RG3 won the Heisman, he's got a great attitude and work ethic, plus players rally around him in a pinch. I'm not saying that I don't think the same of Andrew Luck, but it's a new era of Colts football and a pocket passer might not be our direction. Think about it; a stout defense (which is in the building process), and an electrifying QB that could create a big play at any given moment= success at any level.

Our defense won't be cured over night, but it all begins with the players attitudes and the coach and his scheme that lead them to whatever success they have. Pagano is a players coach with a great & creative defensive mind. Don't think this will be Manusky's defense. It's Pagano's, and he'll have the reigns. I forsee big things from this unit next season.

Offensively, our philosophy would lean on the run more often and I think Donald Brown will have breakout season regardless of which QB we draft. If RG3 were in that mix it would increase our running potency tenfold. Not to mention our down-field potential in the passing game would benefit from it too. I'm not saying that this will happen, but what if?

Thoughts?

Grigson also recognizes how often Vick was on the sidelines. And for an organization who is rebuilding, one thing you definitely don't want, is your "franchise" QB on the sidelines. It will be 2011 season over and over again. We'd be the Dolphins, still looking to replace our star QB a couple decades from now...RG3 has had multiple concussions and a history of ACL issues.

There is no good reason to take RG3 over Luck

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Its very possible, ppl act like they know who the colts will draft but until the colts call on luck its very well up in the air.... ppl want to act like luck is leaps and bounds over griffin when that's not even close to the case. Its not a tied race but its stills a race regardless.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

This whole RG3 is more athletic nonsense needs to stop. Without looking it up, Im pretty sure that Luck beat RG3 in every combine event except the 40 yd. dash that they both competed in, and even the 40 times were not that far apart (about a blink of the eye). So to say RG3 is the more athletic QB is just not true, he's just a little quicker and who gives a dippitydoo about that? I want my QB making plays from the pocket, not running around so he can get creamed by any defensive player looking to make a highlight reel.

Luck will be the pick, don't let a few RG3 people warp your mind, IT"S LUCK!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Both Luck and RG are walking in to buzzsaws, much like Manning did. When teams ahve the first pick or seconf pick it means they stink. Good luck to both QB's they are going to need it. Remember Roger Carr when he came to the Texans, he was slaughtered for the lack of OL protection and never made it back to a starting position.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I will be furious if the Colts draft RG3 over Luck, nuff said. I have not heard a single scout say "this is the best prospect we have seen since Elway/Manning" about RG3. Why try to be cute and draft the one year wonder (who is one season removed from a torn ACL)?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

honestly, i dunno why so many people are concerned with a QB's 40 time...i doubt that Montana, Marino, Manning etc wouldve ran a good 40 time...and Tom Brady looked ridiculously bad as far as athletic potential, at his combine...

Michael Vick had a great combine...and now misses half of every single season he plays...

yeah i dont see why either. the 40 time is only useful when its timed on a WR,DB or RB. and sometimes not even a RB if he knows how to read his holes right.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

RG3 in my honest opinion will be more of a Vince Young than he will be a Cam Newton.

Griffin is a gifted athlete but I don't feel he will put in the time to study defensive schemes and will mainly rely on his athletic ability to get him out of trouble. I predict a lot of INTs and a short leash by Shanahan. He may out gain most QB's in rushing yards but I would rather have a pocket passer that can move if needed than a look once then run type of QB. Never been a Michael Vick fan and I think that Griffin could turn into that.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.

  • Topics

  • Posts

    • Funny.   I would say that a GM's adequacy is directly related to the QB he's blessed or cursed with.  But there are exceptions.  Our previous GM was blessed with one of the best prospects to ever come out of college.  He had success for three years, but he was a mediocre GM at best.     Then there's John Lynch, who found ways to win without a top draft pick or even a highly paid veteran QB.  They're consistently in contention and one of the best teams in the league.  Double digit win totals all but 2 of his 7 seasons.   My biggest complaint with CB is that he didn't make a real attempt to draft a QB until AR.  All chips are in now.
    • If being a GM were easy, anyone could do it. Reality in life is like a hard teacher, she gives the test first, then the lessons come later.
    • Championing the Art of Mediocrity   In the realm of NFL management where big splashes and bold moves often steal the spotlight, Chris Ballard of the Indianapolis Colts stands as a beacon of mediocrity—oops, I mean, moderation and stability. Ballard has mastered the art of steering clear of both spectacular success and abject failure, opting instead for a comfortable middle ground where his team consistently hovers around average.   While other GMs chase after flashy signings and high-profile trades, Ballard prefers a more subtle approach. His teams are like the middle child of the NFL—neither the star of the family nor the problem child. Take, for instance, his draft picks: solid, dependable players who rarely make headlines but also rarely make Pro Bowls. It's a strategy that ensures the Colts remain perennially in the hunt for the playoffs without ever seriously threatening to win it all.   Critics may scoff at Ballard's reluctance to swing for the fences, pointing to the lack of marquee names on his roster or the absence of Lombardi Trophies in his trophy case. Yet, Ballard remains unfazed, steadfast in his belief that consistently finishing just outside the top tier is a commendable achievement in itself.   In a league where greatness is often measured by Super Bowl rings and MVP titles, Ballard's Colts serve as a refreshing reminder that there's honor in being consistently okay. While other teams chase after glory, Ballard quietly celebrates the virtues of stability and predictability—a strategy that ensures his team remains perpetually good enough to keep fans interested without ever giving them false hope of a championship.   So here's to you, Chris Ballard, our unsung hero of NFL mediocrity. May our Colts continue to embody the spirit of contentment in a league that sometimes seems obsessed with extremes. Your dedication to the middle ground is a testament to the fact that in a world of winners and losers, there's beauty in just being average.   Our Chris Ballard, the enigmatic mastermind behind the Indianapolis Colts' draft selections, continues to astound with his unconventional approach to player evaluation. Known for his ability to turn perceived draft flops into valuable lessons in resilience, Ballard has elevated the art of optimism in the face of adversity.   Take, for instance, his selection of Quincy Wilson, a cornerback whose career trajectory seemed to follow the path less traveled—straight to the sidelines. Wilson's ability to excel in the role of 'spectator extraordinaire' brought a new dimension to the Colts' bench, proving that even inactivity can be a form of contribution.   Then there's TJ Green, whose ability to redefine the term 'safety' by providing the opposing offense with a false sense of security is a testament to Ballard's commitment to strategic innovation. Green's unpredictable presence on the field undoubtedly kept quarterbacks on their toes, in excitement.    And who could forget Ben Banogu, a defensive end whose knack for demonstrating the art of camouflage by seamlessly blending into the turf has left spectators marveling at his commitment to environmental integration. Banogu's ability to remain inconspicuous during critical moments showcases Ballard's emphasis on adaptability and the importance of being one with your surroundings.   Ballard's genius lies not just in his ability to select players, but in his skillful navigation of the delicate dance between expectation and reality. His selections may not always align with conventional wisdom, but they consistently challenge perceptions and redefine what it means to be a draft bust.   As Ballard continues to forge ahead, his unorthodox approach serves as a beacon of hope for aspiring NFL general managers everywhere, including those perusing fan forums. Because if there's one thing Chris Ballard has taught us, it's that in the unpredictable world of professional football, even the most unexpected outcomes can be reframed as victories in disguise.   AKB
    • He started 14 games at SS in 2019 and started 8 games in 2018 for the Jags.  I meant to post this earlier in the thread.   https://www.pro-football-reference.com/players/H/HarrRo02.htm        
    • The additions of say Taylor, Raimann, and looking back to Leonard could be called important, savy drafting.  Our Colts have been waiting for awhile for a special, difference making player to surprisingly fall to US. Right when we really really needed it to happen, it sure looks like we got two of them. 🙏 for good health.  AR a surprise at 4, not at all.  But      
  • Members

    • AKB

      AKB 5,271

      Senior Member
      Joined:
      Last active:
    • John Waylon

      John Waylon 5,271

      Senior Member
      Joined:
      Last active:
    • Smonroe

      Smonroe 6,304

      Senior Member
      Joined:
      Last active:
    • jvan1973

      jvan1973 11,066

      Senior Member
      Joined:
      Last active:
    • TheNewGuy

      TheNewGuy 85

      New Member
      Joined:
      Last active:
    • iuswingman

      iuswingman 253

      Member
      Joined:
      Last active:
    • TheRadiantAerynSun

      TheRadiantAerynSun 6

      Rookie
      Joined:
      Last active:
    • dw49

      dw49 1,386

      Senior Member
      Joined:
      Last active:
    • bluephantom87

      bluephantom87 1,193

      Senior Member
      Joined:
      Last active:
    • compuls1v3

      compuls1v3 1,999

      Senior Member
      Joined:
      Last active:
×
×
  • Create New...