Kurt Warner has Andrew Luck#1

[twfish]

Thats right Kurt has our guy ranked number 1 halfway through the season. It goes

#5 Tom Brady

#4 Aaron Rodgers

#3 Peyton manning

#2 Big Ben

#1 Andrew Luck

Im not sure how been got #2 because of his firsy couple games. But im just surprised he has Andrew luck #1

[sreylas937]

I think of Luck as number 1, but that's the homer in me.... But that list  loses all credibility with putting Ben at 2 after 2 games 

[ColtsHoosiersBB]

If he can lead a beating on Brady and the Pats then maybe we can talk about

him moving up the ladder. Way too many picks/near picks and questionable

decisions to be #1 just yet but he will be just that in the next few years.

[braveheartcolt]

Brady had 'near' loses in his 3 SB wins. Yet he is a GOAT candidate. Stop being stupid.

[ReMeDy]

Brady had 'near' loses in his 3 SB wins. Yet he is a GOAT candidate. Stop being stupid.

 

Speaking of which, what ever happened to the tuck rule? I've never seen that called since that game. Did they get rid of it?

[twfish]

This is kurts pick through half of the season. Nothing from the past years and including all the games played so far this year. I dont really see a huge argument in it. Brady did play bad his first couple games.

[PATS16N0]

Speaking of which, what ever happened to the tuck rule? I've never seen that called since that game. Did they get rid of it?

 

They got rid of it last season and it was called many times, before the 01' AFCCG and after

[Indygal1218]

Speaking of which, what ever happened to the tuck rule? I've never seen that called since that game. Did they get rid of it?

I think they got rid of it this past off-season.

[southwest1]

I like Kurt Warner, but I'm not overjoyed at Luck being ranked #1 on his list. It's not a knock on Andrew's play on the field. It's more of a desire to not be the guy or the QB at the top. 

 

Yes, it means that a future HOF QB who played for St. Louis & AZ thinks highly of you singing your praises. But lowered expectations vs elite expectations during only Luck's 3rd year makes me feel more comfortable because it gives a QB more room to grow & improve. 

 

Yeah I know, it's just 5 spots & 1 NFL analysts list. I appreciate the love for Andrew from another elite QB himself. However, I don't wanna raise the bar too high on Luck as a fan myself. It's only year 3 not year 8. I prefer a patient & measured approach like a work in progress vs a finished product right here; right now. 

[chrisfarley]

thats insane rating Peyton, Brady, & Rogers below Luck.

[rabidfan77]

I like Kurt Warner, but I'm not overjoyed at Luck being ranked #1 on his list. It's not a knock on Andrew's play on the field. It's more of a desire to not be the guy or the QB at the top. 

 

Yes, it means that a future HOF QB who played for St. Louis & AZ thinks highly of you singing your praises. But lowered expectations vs elite expectations during only Luck's 3rd year makes me feel more comfortable because it gives a QB more room to grow & improve. 

 

Yeah I know, it's just 5 spots & 1 NFL analysts list. I appreciate the love for Andrew from another elite QB himself. However, I don't wanna raise the bar too high on Luck as a fan myself. It's only year 3 not year 8. I prefer a patient & measured approach like a work in progress vs a finished product right here; right now. 

Yeah, but Luck isn't playing like a work in progress although we know he still has quite a few things to clean up before we can confidently say he's number 1 overall, but if you look at the man's body of work 8 out of 9 games 300+ passing yards with 7 straight games (colts record) and 7 out of 9 games with at least 3 total td's it's hard to argue he isn't number 1 (obviously the turnovers stand out), but Luck's got more good than bad at this point.   

[HungarianColtsFan]

Thats right Kurt has our guy ranked number 1 halfway through the season. It goes

#5 Tom Brady

#4 Aaron Rodgers

#3 Peyton manning

#2 Big Ben

#1 Andrew Luck

Im not sure how been got #2 because of his firsy couple games. But im just surprised he has Andrew luck #1

 

 

In my opinion they are really the best 5 QBs this season in the NFL. Making any rank among them makes no sense.

[Valpo2004]

IDK right now Big Ben and Brady are hot.  Although Luck has been consistently good the whole season which probably helped him.  

[twfish]

IDK right now Big Ben and Brady are hot. Although Luck has been consistently good the whole season which probably helped him.

I think if brady hadnt done so poorly the first few games it would be a little diffrent, same with big Ben. But no one else has to the point been as consistently great

[Dr. Guildo]

They got rid of it last season and it was called many times, before the 01' AFCCG and after

Never trust a man who likes to tuck it. 

[ColtsLegacy]

Never trust a man who likes to tuck it.

[PeterBowman]

the scary thing is that the other qb's listed have long reached their peak (as high as it is for them) where as Luck still has a ways to go to get to his...once he puts it all together, look out.

[texascolt]

I think the rating is based on the stats for the 9 games this year.

[SilentHill]

thats insane rating Peyton, Brady, & Rogers below Luck.

 

Thanks for your opinion, I'll trust Kurt Warners on this one though.

[throwing BBZ]

This is kurts pick through half of the season. Nothing from the past years and including all the games played so far this year. I dont really see a huge argument in it. Brady did play bad his first couple games.

 

If Warner was picking the best QB to make a SB run, i doubt Andrew would be top 5. JMO of course.

 Andrews stats are at the top so Great job Kurt.

[throwing BBZ]

IDK right now Big Ben and Brady are hot.  Although Luck has been consistently good the whole season which probably helped him.  

 He stank the 1st half of our 1st 2 games.

 And had 40 incompletions the last 2 games.

 Lot of stats though.

[crazycolt1]

thats insane rating Peyton, Brady, & Rogers below Luck.

So the stats and numbers mean nothing?

[Football Knowledge]

Brady had 'near' loses in his 3 SB wins. Yet he is a GOAT candidate. Stop being stupid.

You had a lot of great quarterbacks in the HOF with much worse numbers then Tom (Tom and Peyton have similar numbers, both top 5 all time in most passing categories, only difference is Peyton played longer 1998 vs 2001 when Tom came in) that never even made it to the Superbowl, and some great QBs with only one ring that will be in the Hall so this statement alone is stupid.. How can he not be a GOAT Candidate?  I hate fans that use ignorance and stupidity towards hatred of a player not recognizing their greatness.. For example, I can't stand Kurt Warner but I'm not going to disregard that he is one of the best quarterbacks of all time.  Look at Tom's passer ratings in the last two superbowls that he won.. (not to mention he has been to two more) both over 93 rating and at least 2 TDs, and 250 yards against two great defenses (CAR 03, PHI 04).. and his clutch performance in the first SB.. strategically marching his team down field.. IN THE CLUTCH like he has done so often.. I hate haters.. makes me not want to discuss football because with haters you can't talk or debate because of lack of logic

[braveheartcolt]

You had a lot of great quarterbacks in the HOF with much worse numbers then Tom (Tom and Peyton have similar numbers, both top 5 all time in most passing categories, only difference is Peyton played longer 1998 vs 2001 when Tom came in) that never even made it to the Superbowl, and some great QBs with only one ring that will be in the Hall so this statement alone is stupid.. How can he not be a GOAT Candidate?  I hate fans that use ignorance and stupidity towards hatred of a player not recognizing their greatness.. For example, I can't stand Kurt Warner but I'm not going to disregard that he is one of the best quarterbacks of all time.  Look at Tom's passer ratings in the last two superbowls that he won.. (not to mention he has been to two more) both over 93 rating and at least 2 TDs, and 250 yards against two great defenses (CAR 03, PHI 04).. and his clutch performance in the first SB.. strategically marching his team down field.. IN THE CLUTCH like he has done so often.. I hate haters.. makes me not want to discuss football because with haters you can't talk or debate because of lack of logic

You clearly did not understand my point. And I have no intention of clarifying. Over.

[BOTT]

Oh boy, now I can brag to my friends at the bar tonight!!!! Yippee !

[Gavin]

I think Brady should be over Aaron Rodgers...He has done more with less , Other then that I agree

[jabbanobadda]

You had a lot of great quarterbacks in the HOF with much worse numbers then Tom (Tom and Peyton have similar numbers, both top 5 all time in most passing categories, only difference is Peyton played longer 1998 vs 2001 when Tom came in) that never even made it to the Superbowl, and some great QBs with only one ring that will be in the Hall so this statement alone is stupid.. How can he not be a GOAT Candidate?  I hate fans that use ignorance and stupidity towards hatred of a player not recognizing their greatness.. For example, I can't stand Kurt Warner but I'm not going to disregard that he is one of the best quarterbacks of all time.  Look at Tom's passer ratings in the last two superbowls that he won.. (not to mention he has been to two more) both over 93 rating and at least 2 TDs, and 250 yards against two great defenses (CAR 03, PHI 04).. and his clutch performance in the first SB.. strategically marching his team down field.. IN THE CLUTCH like he has done so often.. I hate haters.. makes me not want to discuss football because with haters you can't talk or debate because of lack of logic

 

I don't think anyone here has an issue with that.  ;)

[King Colt]

All favoritism aside let's just sit back and let Luck rack up his numbers and it appears judging from his performance so his numbers will surpass many if not all of the greats. Don't lose sight of his ability to take a hit and stay in the games. You can't build on your numbers when you are sidelined on the bench for however many games. After Peyton Manning and Andrew Luck what the heck can Colt fans expect 20 years from now, a guy from Metropolis with the ability to leap buildings in a single bound? Yeah, its a good feeling, a real good feeling.