Rg3 Roy

[Cynjin]

I do not give the award that much credence, but I do not agree with the selection.  RG3 had a very good year, however he did not even play in every game.  I think that Wilson was more deserving.

[FalseStart]

Alfred Morris > RGIII

[TKnight24]

Rg3 has the ROY award, but Andrew Luck has two knees- and a future.

AHHH!!!!!!!

I'm done with this site that's just foul man

[HGRekks]

I'd like to point out that the best players in the game today have not won the rookie of the year award.

Adrian Peterson, Big Ben, Jerod Mayo, Patrick Willis, and Matt Ryan say hello. Many of them haven't, true, but that's because there is only one winner each year, and players only qualify for one year. Of course the best players, or most of the best players, haven't won it. I would argue, however, the best player (singular) has won it - Peterson.

 

Personally, I don't think it's a predictor of success, but it's not a like it's a curse.

[jvan1973]

Didn't Peyton get second for rookie of the year? He ended up having a pretty good career

[Gavin]

Congrats to Robert Griffin III, he deserved it thats all I really have to say about that

[jvan1973]

I guess playing all the games isn't important. Wilson should have won it

[reality]

You're right about this topic being discussed ad nauseum here, but again, what do you expect? Our team isn't playing and about the only thing relevant to the fan base right now was the contention for ORotY and COtY. Do I feel like Luck was snubbed? I think he had a shot, but it's hard to say he was snubbed when there were two other very qualified applicants. I don't have any ill feelings towards RG3 or the redskins, but it's still amazing to me that people will get on this forum for what appears to be the sole purpose of bashing the people here who are obviously fans of the team the forum is based on. If you don't have anything of value to put into a conversation and merely egg the fans here on, than you're just a troll.

 

My purpose was not to bash.  In fact, I think you find that you and I are in agreement in the bolded part of your post.  People who say things like those I've referenced previously are adding nothing to intelligent discourse.  If you look at some of my previous posts, I've offered stats and numbers to support my viewpoints, as other users have for their own, which again I think we'd agree is the point of the message board.

 

The only reason I replied to this thread in particular is because I was pretty appalled by that one post in particular.  If you think your guys deserved it because of some criteria, great!  Tell us about it!  But snarky posts about real people who are suffering real injuries is absurd.

 

EDIT: See, this guy is a real troll v v v v

[smackdown]

I just want to know who were the 11 '* that voted for Luck. Luck is terrible. If not for Sanchez he leads the league in turnovers. Didn't deserve a single vote over Wilson or the illustrious RG3.

[smackdown]

Love the but hurt in this thread. Lemme guess..."knees"...."Vick"...."running game"....lol...I guess everyone is just miserable in flyover country!

[smackdown]

Can't win Rookie of the Year when your rating is 76.5. That's good for 54th in the league for all players with at least a single pass...

[Dustin]

I just want to know who were the 11 '* that voted for Luck. Luck is terrible. If not for Sanchez he leads the league in turnovers. Didn't deserve a single vote over Wilson or the illustrious RG3.

 

[smackdown]

AFC South is garbage. Always has been. Always will be. Worst division of all-time.

[Dustin]

AFC South is garbage. Always has been. Always will be. Worst division of all-time.

 

O yea u mad. Keep it coming you can do better than that. You're not trying hard enough.

[smackdown]

Mad about what? What your doing is called projecting. My guy won. Your guy sucks. Your GM should be fired for blowing the first overall pick. Andrew Luck doesn't even look like a first rounder.

[Colts20593]

What a bunch of manure

Bobby my team wins 2 games without me throw for 100 yards per game wins ROTY

[Dustin]

Mad about what? What your doing is called projecting. My guy won. Your guy sucks. Your GM should be fired for blowing the first overall pick. Andrew Luck doesn't even look like a first rounder.

 

You're not any good at this. Real shoddy trolling here.

[ConBro]

Butthurt much?  Stay classy, Indianapolis.

 

May I suggest: 

Welcome to the forum! 7 posts!

[smackdown]

AFC South is pathetic. Keep pumping in that crowd noise Colts. Let's see...the NFC Beast has 12 Lombardis,

[John Dee]

Andrew Luck did not win squatoooocchhooo  and still the worms come out of the wood work to do what they do.

 

 

hehe....   

[Dustin]

AFC South is pathetic. Keep pumping in that crowd noise Colts. Let's see...the NFC Beast has 12 Lombardis,

 

lololololol Come on come up with something new.

[haseo15]

I just want to know who were the 11 '* that voted for Luck. Luck is terrible. If not for Sanchez he leads the league in turnovers. Didn't deserve a single vote over Wilson or the illustrious RG3.

Suck that RG3 D*** some more. Lol

[ConBro]

Mad about what? What your doing is called projecting. My guy won. Your guy sucks. Your GM should be fired for blowing the first overall pick. Andrew Luck doesn't even look like a first rounder.

That GM that "sucks" is this year's Executive of the Year, but you know what you're talking about. Welcome to the forum, noobie. Can admins do something about these kind of posts?

[Dustin]

deleted.

[jvan1973]

Mad about what? What your doing is called projecting. My guy won. Your guy sucks. Your GM should be fired for blowing the first overall pick. Andrew Luck doesn't even look like a first rounder.

Your guy is hobbled and didn't even play a whole season.. How many games did your guy win? And don't count the two games cousins won

[vinatierifan4]

Luck 2 Legs, 1 Ivy League Brain

 

Griffin 1 Leg, 1 Mush brain from concussions.

[Dustin]

.

[smackdown]

Your guy is hobbled and didn't even play a whole season.. How many games did your guy win? And don't count the two games cousins won

Team sport there spanky. Last I checked each NFL roster had 53 players.

[jvan1973]

Team sport there spanky. Last I checked each NFL roster had 53 players.

And Bob had much better players around him.. Thanks for making my point

[smackdown]

Luck 2 Legs, 1 Ivy League Brain

 

Griffin 1 Leg, 1 Mush brain from concussions.

Lol. You couldn't tell by his play on the field. Bad decision after bad decision. Plus he has the charisma of a rock. My god that voice...sound like Andre the Giants long lost downsy brother...

[Dustin]

Team sport there spanky. Last I checked each NFL roster had 53 players.

 

Last I checked Luck had 2 knees.

[trailertrash]

AFC South is pathetic. Keep pumping in that crowd noise Colts. Let's see...the NFC Beast has 12 Lombardis,

Oh yeah, the same NFC "Beast" that got raped by AFC North this year, right? The same NFC "Beast" that has all of its teams drafting in the first round being in the top 20 right? The same NFC "Beast" whose defenses collectively are ranked 12th, 22nd, 24th, and 29th right? The same NFC "Beast" without the NY Giants have ZERO SBs in the last 2 decades right? Final question, are you sure this is the NFC "Beast" we're talking about? Sounds more like the NFC "SHEET"!

[Matugi]

Luck 2 Legs, 1 Ivy League Brain

 

Griffin 1 Leg, 1 Mush brain from concussions.

The knee part is fine, but don't joke about concussions.

[smackdown]

And Bob had much better players around him.. Thanks for making my point

Right. RG3 had a hall of fame wideout...wait, his top wideout was a guy the colts didn't even resign....that was hurt 50% of the season. And the Colts had a better defense. Only18 points given up on average in their 11 victories. Much more than what R3 had to work with. The defense carried that team....in the worst division of pro football.

[trailertrash]

Lol. You couldn't tell by his play on the field. Bad decision after bad decision. Plus he has the charisma of a rock. My god that voice...sound like Andre the Giants long lost downsy brother...

"Bad decision after bad decision. Plus he has the charisma of a rock. My god that voice...sound like Andre the Giants long lost downsy brother..."

 

Number of knees:

AL 12: 2

RG"Triage"10: 1

[Franklin County]

Congrats to RG3 and the trolls from Washington. But honestly I dont care. We have FREAKING Andrew Luck as our QB!!!!!!!!  I wouldnt trade him for their QB and shiny new trophy if they threw in their  O-Line, and we really need a new O-Line. We have LUCK!!!!!!!!!

[smackdown]

Oh yeah, the same NFC "Beast" that got raped by AFC North this year, right? The same NFC "Beast" that has all of its teams drafting in the first round being in the top 20 right? The same NFC "Beast" whose defenses collectively are ranked 12th, 22nd, 24th, and 29th right? The same NFC "Beast" without the NY Giants have ZERO SBs in the last 2 decades right? Final question, are you sure this is the NFC "Beast" we're talking about? Sounds more like the NFC "SHEET"!

12 Lombardis to 1. AFC South is straight garbage.

[Dustin]

Right. RG3 had a hall of fame wideout...wait, his top wideout was a guy the colts didn't even resign....that was hurt 50% of the season. And the Colts had a better defense. Only18 points given up on average in their 11 victories. Much more than what R3 had to work with. The defense carried that team....in the worst division of pro football.

 

So the Colts are better than the Redskins is what you're saying?

[ConBro]

My purpose was not to bash.  In fact, I think you find that you and I are in agreement in the bolded part of your post.  People who say things like those I've referenced previously are adding nothing to intelligent discourse.  If you look at some of my previous posts, I've offered stats and numbers to support my viewpoints, as other users have for their own, which again I think we'd agree is the point of the message board.

 

The only reason I replied to this thread in particular is because I was pretty appalled by that one post in particular.  If you think your guys deserved it because of some criteria, great!  Tell us about it!  But snarky posts about real people who are suffering real injuries is absurd.

 

EDIT: See, this guy is a real troll v v v v

Calling fans of the team whose forum you are browsing "butthurt" is not offering relevant statistical information.

[Dustin]

12 Lombardis to 1. AFC South is straight garbage.

 

It's funny how you're still insecure about your guy even after he won ROTY.