well moncrief had a good game

[Stephen]

plus he scored his first td

[James]

Him and TY are the future. If Reggie isn't ready next week, then Moncrief should be able to further contribute.

[AndrewQB1]

Big positive to take from the game along with how TY is developing.

[Captain Americolt]

He did pretty well today. 

[MTC]

Moncrief showed a lot of potential tonight. 

 

 

There is no reason for Nicks to get more snaps than Moncrief. Nicks had his oppertunity and didn't show it. 

[RockThatBlue]

He looked good.

[Drew1023]

Is this really what the forum has succumbed to?  That you must ignore one of the worst defensive performances of all time and instead focus on a backup rookie receiver to not get the thread locked.  Pathetic.

[TKnight24]

Trade Hakeem Nicks tomorrow!!!!!

[chad hugo]

Trade Hakeem Nicks tomorrow!!!!!

 

what is he worth ? his value hasnt really gone up or down 

[Stephen]

Trade Hakeem Nicks tomorrow!!!!!

for a pass rusher

[HOZER]

KEEP FEEDING MONCRIEF!!!!

[BlueCollarColts]

He should play over Nicks. 

[TKnight24]

what is he worth ? his value hasnt really gone up or down

The Jets will give up at least a 5th. I'll take anything to get him out of here

[chad hugo]

The Jets will give up at least a 5th. I'll take anything to get him out of here

 

what if another receiver goes down ? I would keep him as a back up 

[Boiler_Colt]

He left the game and Whalen took his place. Lets hope he's ok for next week. Nicks has nothing left in the tank

[Stephen]

what if another receiver goes down ? I would keep him as a back

i think a practice squad receiver is better than nicks at this point

[TKnight24]

what if another receiver goes down ? I would keep him as a back up

That works too. Give him the DHB treatment. But Bottomline Moncrief needs to be the #4..... Well #3 until Reggie gets back then go to the #4 slot

[ColtsRule815]

for a pass rusher

This seriously needs to happen after tonight's disaster.  When you make a crap team like the steelers look good, something is DREADFULLY wrong.

[James Harden]

what if another receiver goes down ? I would keep him as a back up 

Trade him away. Bring back Da'rick Rogers for cheaper. He already knows the playbook and that this would be his final chance. I would love a guy playing with a chip on his shoulder. 

[Andrew Luck fan club]

He played great. Did he get injured??

[NewColtsFan]

Moncrief is the one bright spot in the game.    He's clearly now our #3 receiver, ahead of Nicks.

 

He looked terrific out there.

 

Not sure what's going on with Nicks,  but he's not fast or quick and gets no separation.   He made a very nice catch on a fade, but that's it.     He looks plodding out there.    Struggling badly.   

 

Good thing Moncrief is not playing like a rookie.

[RockThatBlue]

what if another receiver goes down ? I would keep him as a back up

Nicks is almost as useless as dhb was. Nicks just makes an occasional catch here or there but thats it. Even whalen outplayed Nicks today. Time for Nicks to sit the bench at least while Moncrief plays

[jabbanobadda]

Moncrief is a stud. That is all...oh wait, so is Hilton...

[GOCOLTS_ROLLTIDE]

To the people wanting to trade Nicks. ....... #1 it's not all on Nicks .... #2 if it were and he was really that bad. . This is the same coaching staff that forced us to watch Gordy get abused these past 3 weeks lol

[mintor]

He should play over Nicks. 

 

 

true

[ricker182]

Moncrief and Luck actually seem to be on the same page.

For a "show me" year Nicks hasn't done anything.

[JlynRN]

Moncrief looked good today.  He should be getting more snaps for now.

[Dr. Guildo]

T.Y. and Moncrief should be the dynamic duo for the Colts going forward with Reggie providing his leadership, and show them the way. At this point I'd rather see Griff in over Nicks. 

[achcolts]

Moncrief and Whalen both looked good. Nicks needs to be benched

[ColtsLegacy]

To the people wanting to trade Nicks. ....... #1 it's not all on Nicks .... #2 if it were and he was really that bad. . This is the same coaching staff that forced us to watch Gordy get abused these past 3 weeks lol

 

Butler was abused tonight more than Gordy has been the entire year. Gordy has been good prior to tonight when everyone sucked.

 

OP: I'm shocked how bad Nicks has been and the few times he does get open Luck misses him by a mile. I really thought Nicks would be amazing for us, he has not. I never expected he'd be little more effective than DHB. Time to Feed Moncrief and bench Nicks.

[Dark Superman]

They need to have TY and moncrief out there with Wayne in the slot..

[Ja'Crispy]

Nicks just looked lazy to me. Slow, sloppy route running.  Moncrief should be getting more reps on effort alone, but the fact that he is producing makes it a no-brainer IMO. 

[GoColts8818]

He was a bright spot today. Between him and Hilton the Colts have a couple of really good young WRs.

[GoColts8818]

Trade Hakeem Nicks tomorrow!!!!!

i honestly doubt any team would give you anything for him right now. whats he done to make team want to trade for him?

[Superfly Jay]

I'm done with Nicks I tried to be optimistic about it. He even let Whalen show him up. It's time to ride the bench.

[CroatianColtsFan21]

That works too. Give him the DHB treatment. But Bottomline Moncrief needs to be the #4..... Well #3 until Reggie gets back then go to the #4 slot

 

  i don't get your depth chart...

[Valpo2004]

He should play over Nicks. 

 

+1

 

When Reggie comes back Moncrief should be the #3 guy.  If he keeps performing like that I would say he has Fleener beat as well.

[Stephen]

DHB 11 games started 29 rec 309 yards 1 td

Nicks 8 games started 18 rec 168 yards 2 tds

Moncrief 16 rec 216 yards 1 td

[TKnight24]

i honestly doubt any team would give you anything for him right now. whats he done to make team want to trade for him?

I'm sure we could get something

Bengals or Jets at least will give us a 5th maybe

[SkyBane]

I'm sure we could get something

Bengals or Jets at least will give us a 5th maybe

For a 1 year rental? Nobody will want to trade for him when they can just sign him in the offseason if they are interested, especially teams who's seasons are already done like the Jets. It would have to be a team that truly believes they are a depth WR away from making a playoff push, including the fact that mid season trade WR's don't produce nearly at the level they're capable until they've had an off season to work with the team.

 

Nick isn't going anywhere, because nobody wants to give up anything for a rental.