Who is the Better Manning?

[amfootball]

http://espn.go.com/nfl/story/_/id/9663087/peyton-eli-ultimate-manning-brothers-comparison

 

Given we were just talking about this, figured I would post this. ESPN just did a comparison of the two QBs. Some of it is pretty laughable IMO but worth the read.

[Dustin]

God I hate ESPN.

I like how they claim that being oblivious to blinside pressure is somehow a plus for Eli.

[Nobody]

Lol

[Moose Of Woe]

Wow.

[Gramz]

I pick Olivia  ;)   :bag:

[Coltsince4]

I pick Olivia   ;)   :bag:

As Smoky would say (sing) I SECOND THAT EMOTION......................................................

[Kenny]

Cooper gets the nod from me

[oldunclemark]

  Dad was the man.

 

Its hard to survive in pro sports with the name Archie

[Hoosierdome93]

 Its just impossible to beat your older brother.

 

 

Source: Oldest of 4 boys.

[Gramz]

 Its just impossible to beat your older brother.

 

 

Source: Oldest of 4 boys.

Every time I see you post, I think it's Shecolt (because of your avatar)  

[Warhorse]

The whole family rocks.

[Gramz]

The whole family rocks.

[DILLIGAFER]

Archie's the iron man. Peyton's the Brain's. Eli's the raw talent.

[oldunclemark]

http://espn.go.com/nfl/story/_/id/9663087/peyton-eli-ultimate-manning-brothers-comparison

 

Given we were just talking about this, figured I would post this. ESPN just did a comparison of the two QBs. Some of it is pretty laughable IMO but worth the read.

 

 

"Some of it is pretty laughable"  

 

 

 

well said.

[pgt_rob]

Peyton> Eli

[The Old Crow]

Please....Eli is the " Shemp" of Mannings !

[Yehoodi]

Please....Eli is the " Shemp" of Mannings !

 

. . . "is this Susquehanna 2222" . . .

[Dark Superman]

Cooper Manning.

[OffensivelyPC]

The only thing Eli has over PFM is the rings and playoff win percentage.  While those are team accomplishments, its' still part of the argument.  I still don't think it's enough to say that Eli is better than Peyton. 

[Poster X]

Archie's the iron man. Peyton's the Brain's. Eli's the raw talent.

 

 

Combine them all into one Frankenstein like monster... and it would be unstoppable, so long as you avoid using Eli's brain because being oblivious to the blindside can result in something abby normal.

 

[Yehoodi]

Combine them all into one Frankenstein like monster... and it would be unstoppable, so long as you avoid using Eli's brain because being oblivious to the blindside can result in something abby normal.

 

 

who's brain is that . . . ?

 

Abby . . .

 

Abby who . . . ?

 

Abby Normal .  . .

[amfootball]

The only thing Eli has over PFM is the rings and playoff win percentage.  While those are team accomplishments, its' still part of the argument.  I still don't think it's enough to say that Eli is better than Peyton. 

It really isn't . But in the end it is about the rings. That is why you play the game. Eli had a lot of luck too in both runs.

[tahuyaman]

Peyton is the better Manning and it isn't even close to being arguable.

[HarryTheCat]

OK, picture this.  You're an NFL GM, and you have a crystal ball, so you know how both Peyton and Eli are going to turn out.  Peyton and Eli are both 22 years old, coming up in the draft.  Who do you pick for your team?  Hands down, it's Peyton.

[Hoosierdome93]

Every time I see you post, I think it's Shecolt (because of your avatar)  

Ill be a team player and change it up for you..GO COLTS

[bayone]

It really isn't . But in the end it is about the rings. That is why you play the game. Eli had a lot of luck too in both runs.

 

Eli had basically last drive with any r time, a miraculous escape when should of been sacked big, a big heave and a catch onj a helmet that will never happen again

 

next time again a heave and again a great catch, this time a sideline skirting grab arching back to get to ball

 

, Thats Eli  's 2 highlights that has casted him into this ridiculous conversation

 

Plus a defense to stop Pats when needed too

[Synthetic]

To ask this question on a Colts forum is the equivalent of asking a Microsoft tech if he prefers his own company's brand or Apple.

 

 

You already know the answer to your question.