Would you rather the Colts won a Super Bowl or the Broncos?

[Insert Colts Pun Here]

Sounds like a silly question, I know. But how would you feel if the very organisation that Peyton loves so much (and that loves him back) was the organisation that stopped him winning one last ring?

I'd feel bad!

And that's why I think I'd rather the Broncos won it next year. Luck has got a great future ahead of him and should have plenty of chances a to win it. Peyton's time is running out...

[Bbswatching]

Im sorry.  I love Peyton.  But if its a choice between us and the broncos.  I choose us.  Cause you never know when you will get another shot.  I would like to see Peyton win one. But not at the expense of the colts.

[Gavin]

At the end of the day the NFL is a business ON and OFF the field, If Im a Colts fan Im wanting Peyton to eat grass (or turf) multiple times against us, beat him and then welcome him home when the time comes  ;)

[Flying Elvis]

There's too much love going on in this thread. As a Pats fan I wish Welker well but come playoff time he's the enemy.

[MTC]

     

 

[shakedownstreet]

 

 

[Dan]

Erm. I'm a Colts fan, not a Broncos fan, so Colts. Why is this even a question? 

[NewEra]

Colts!

[James]

 We're all fans of the Indianapolis Colts, not Peyton Manning. If they Colts get bounced in the playoffs, then sure I'd enjoy it if Peyton and the Broncos won it. But never at the expense of the Colts.

[Daddy]

At the end of the day the NFL is a business ON and OFF the field, If Im a Colts fan Im wanting Peyton to eat grass (or turf) multiple times against us, beat him and then welcome him home when the time comes ;)

[Insert Colts Pun Here]

I thought I'd get this kind of response

What if it was a Colts/Broncos Superbowl?

Man that would be harsh!

[BPM_Colt]

Not at the expense of the Colts. At the end of the day, I have all the respect and thank yous to give out to Peyton...

 

But I want us to win it every year. Create a dynasty in INDY

[In Luck We Trust]

if it came down to the colts and broncos playing each other in the ( i will make it interesting) AFC Championship game.... i would say better luck next year, manning! I would prefer the colts to win the superbowl before i  say manning. I don't care that he WAS the qb of the colts for so many years, he ISN'T our QB now. 

[oldunclemark]

 Its not a silly question ...........

....but it is stated in stated in 2 ways ....Josh..

 

(you said in your comments) NEXT YEAR?   I'd rather Denver win because they have Manning, Stokley/Freeney (either or) , Tamme.....all ex-Colts who are over-30...

 

Ex-Colts are still my guys.....especially if they didnt leave voluntarily.  I would never root against Manning and Freeney.

 

.....living legends

 

Peyton Manning and Dwight Freeney played for the Colts a lot longer than Cory Redding and Josh Freeman will..

 

But (as you said in the post) beyond that one (or two)-time 'happy ending'?

 

I'd want the Colts to beat Denver because I like the Colts and want them to be legends..

 

I'd rather they dont meet in the post-season until Manning and Freeney retire...

 

....and as long as they both make the playoffs every year...I can live with either outcome and root for the winner..

 

Sounds like a silly question, I know. But how would you feel if the very organisation that Peyton loves so much (and that loves him back) was the organisation that stopped him winning one last ring?

I'd feel bad!

And that's why I think I'd rather the Broncos won it next year. Luck has got a great future ahead of him and should have plenty of chances a to win it. Peyton's time is running out...

[In Luck We Trust]

Sounds like a silly question, I know. But how would you feel if the very organisation that Peyton loves so much (and that loves him back) was the organisation that stopped him winning one last ring?

I'd feel bad!

And that's why I think I'd rather the Broncos won it next year. Luck has got a great future ahead of him and should have plenty of chances a to win it. Peyton's time is running out...

dont ever say luck has plenty of chances, anything can happen to him to where his career is short * knock on wood * 

[oldunclemark]

There was a time that Adam Vinatiari was the enemy....

There's too much love going on in this thread. As a Pats fan I wish Welker well but come playoff time he's the enemy.

[In Luck We Trust]

 Its not a silly question ...........

....but it is stated in stated in 2 ways ....Josh..

 

(you said in your comments) NEXT YEAR?   I'd rather Denver win because they have Manning, Stokley/Freeney (either or) , Tamme.....all ex-Colts who are over-30...

 

Ex-Colts are still my guys.....especially if they didnt leave voluntarily.  I would never root against Manning and Freeney.

 

.....living legends

 

Peyton Manning and Dwight Freeney played for the Colts a lot longer than Cory Redding and Josh Freeman will..

 

But (as you said in the post) beyond that one (or two)-time 'happy ending'?

 

I'd want the Colts to beat Denver because I like the Colts and want them to be legends..

 

I'd rather they dont meet in the post-season until Manning and Freeney retire...

 

....and as long as they both make the playoffs every year...I can live with either outcome and root for the winner..

isn't he the QB for the Buccaneers??? when did we trade for him?? 

[In Luck We Trust]

There was a time that Adam Vinatiari was the enemy....

yeah but he signed with us!!! lol. and he gets booed sometimes in Foxboro. 

[Smonroe]

Sounds like a silly question, I know. But how would you feel if the very organisation that Peyton loves so much (and that loves him back) was the organisation that stopped him winning one last ring?

I'd feel bad!

And that's why I think I'd rather the Broncos won it next year. Luck has got a great future ahead of him and should have plenty of chances a to win it. Peyton's time is running out...

Marino went to a SB his rookie year. He had plenty of chances...

[CjMcGirt23]

Sounds like a silly question, I know. But how would you feel if the very organisation that Peyton loves so much (and that loves him back) was the organisation that stopped him winning one last ring?

I'd feel bad!

And that's why I think I'd rather the Broncos won it next year. Luck has got a great future ahead of him and should have plenty of chances a to win it. Peyton's time is running out...

[oldunclemark]

Oh yeah...Jerrell Freemen.....

 

The point is....I just cant throw over long term Colts because we cut them...

 

Its a tough choice...but there's no way I'd want Manning/Freeney defeated one or 2 games from the Super Bowl..in their final seasons

 

They were my guys for a decade...

 

isn't he the QB for the Buccaneers??? when did we trade for him?? 

[oldunclemark]

Exactly my point........I would never boo an ex-star player that we cut...

 

Would you?

yeah but he signed with us!!! lol. and he gets booed sometimes in Foxboro. 

[ruksak]

lol...What kind of question is this? 

 

I'm not even going to answer this ignorance. 

[ruksak]

 

Sounds like a silly question, I know. But how would you feel if the very organisation that Peyton loves so much (and that loves him back) was the organisation that stopped him winning one last ring?

I'd feel bad!

And that's why I think I'd rather the Broncos won it next year. Luck has got a great future ahead of him and should have plenty of chances a to win it. Peyton's time is running out...

 

 

 

The great forum wolf has spoken. 

[BrentMc11]

I thought I'd get this kind of response

What if it was a Colts/Broncos Superbowl?

Man that would be harsh!

Good News!!  This could not happen....only possibility is the AFC Championship!      !!

 

I have been sitting here this morning studying OLBs, DTs, and NTs in order to get our defense to where we can beat other teams 37-7 instead of the 43-40 days of heart attacks where number 18 brought us back.  GREAT MEMORIES!!!!   MEMORIES!!!

 

I also have great memories of a resilient team/organization that went to the playoffs with an 11-5 record....that made me PROUD to be a Colt fan even more.  Number 12 has provided some nice comebacks too....OH Yeah!!!

 

Yadda Yadda Yadda.......I want the Colts to go for the       EVERY year!  Go      !!! 

[ruksak]

I thought I'd get this kind of response

What if it was a Colts/Broncos Superbowl?

 

 

 

Are you trying to fail or........?

[Boiler_Colt]

I couldn't care less about the Broncos. Count me as the small minority that was kinda glad they lost last year.

[ALuck>RG3]

Is this even a real question?

[MR. Blueblood]

Colts all the way, who cares what former players were here....the key word being former.  I thank them for all they have done for this team, but they are no longer part of this team, which makes them just like every one of the other 31 teams in the league.....a team I want the Colts to beat.

[Nobody]

[ruksak]

I couldn't care less about the Broncos. Count me as the small minority that was kinda glad they lost last year.

Myself, I like the Broncs. I love me some PM. Great guy, great player. 

 

But between him and my horseshoe....forget about it!!!!

 

If the difference between my Colts winning and the Broncos winning was dependent on me hurling rotten eggs at Peyton, I'm gonna go loosen my arm up and start chuckin eggs. Sorry Peyton. 

[Qwiz]

I couldn't care less about the Broncos. Count me as the small minority that was kinda glad they lost last year.

[oldunclemark]

I care about former players.....

 

Peyton Manning, Dwight Freeney, Dallas Clarlk...I still want them to do well...

 

They did well by me for a long time....There's no forgetting that...

 

I want Denver and Indy to be the top 2 seds in the AFC.....so the winner of any meeting would go to the Super Bowl...and any meeting would come after playoff wins

[PrincetonTiger]

the only answer should be the Colts

[TKnight24]

Broncos. No Question

[dw49]

Sounds like a silly question, I know. But how would you feel if the very organisation that Peyton loves so much (and that loves him back) was the organisation that stopped him winning one last ring?

I'd feel bad!

And that's why I think I'd rather the Broncos won it next year. Luck has got a great future ahead of him and should have plenty of chances a to win it. Peyton's time is running out...

 

 

 

 

They said similar things about Dan Marino ... right ? 

[RealityIsLuck]

Really there's no question, the Colts are my team and always will be. Peyton still has a special place in my heart but when it comes to Colts or Broncos its a very obvious answer  .

[FearTomi]

Sounds like a silly question, I know. But how would you feel if the very organisation that Peyton loves so much (and that loves him back) was the organisation that stopped him winning one last ring?

I'd feel bad!

And that's why I think I'd rather the Broncos won it next year. Luck has got a great future ahead of him and should have plenty of chances a to win it. Peyton's time is running out...

 

So you are a Payton Manning fan, not a Colts fan...it is so strange that you would feel bad because your team stop Manning to win superbowl but you don't feel bad that you want a rival team to win superbowl....

[oldunclemark]

^{You can be both..}

[Bbswatching]

I thought I'd get this kind of response

What if it was a Colts/Broncos Superbowl?

Man that would be harsh!

That would be crazy since they are both in the AFC...lol