Colts fans, who is your favorite non-colt player?

[Rhodelesstraveled]

Denico Autry and it isn't close

[Dobbinblitz]

Fred Warner #54

[jimmy g]

6 hours ago, Nancy said:

Not my fav player but I always try to see what he is doing when the Titans play...is Nick Westbrook-Ikhine because he is married to my good friend's cousin!  He played at I.U.

But I was one of those that wanted Will Levis here so I kind of follow him.  He is a wild man! lol

I definitely wanted Levis here! (But I’m a Penn St fan and watched him there before he transferred).  I believe that, in five years, he and AR will be the same good NFL QB, but for now- I see Levis as 2-3 yrs ahead of AR in development.  Had the Colts drafted Levis, I believe we’d be challenging for the AFC South Title.

 

As to the Titans- our home is divided. I’ve been a Colts fan for more than 65 yrs! My Youngest and his Children  are a Titans family. Lots of discussion when we play each other!

[Rhodelesstraveled]

Then you are better than me. I thought Levis would bust.  But I have to say I was wrong with him.  I thought Stroud was the best of the bunch.  I am not sold on Young because he had stud WR at Bama.  

 

 

[Stephen]

Tyreek hill we need a wr like him

[Stephen]

19 minutes ago, Rhodelesstraveled said:

Then you are better than me. I thought Levis would bust.  But I have to say I was wrong with him.  I thought Stroud was the best of the bunch.  I am not sold on Young because he had stud WR at Bama.  

 

 

Levis still can bust

[Rhodelesstraveled]

Steven, I agree.  But Baldy is in on him too, and I think he knows more than I do. I hope he does but the tape does not lie. 

 

[NewColtsFan]

For me, it’s McCaffrey.   I thought he’d be very good, but I didn’t see him becoming the best running back in the NFL.  
 

And for obvious reasons, I’ve taken a liking to Travis Kelce.   And I’m not even a Taylor Swift fan.   But their story is compelling.  

[BProland85]

All time Drew Brees. For current I’ll go with Kittle from San Fran. 

[AKB]

8 hours ago, VikingsFanInChennai said:

 

I think everyone understands the description differently.

 

This whole forum is for Colts fans. I don't think categories are separated based on whether a topic is related to Colts fans or not.

 

Categories are differentiated based on whether the topic is Colts related or not.

 

The topic definition of "NFL General" says

 

If it's NFL and it's NOT COLTS, it goes here

 

As this topic is about NFL and "Non-Colts Players", it has to be in NFL General, by definition. 

but its not., because im talking to colts fans, which is colts related.

[AKB]

7 hours ago, Rhodelesstraveled said:

Denico Autry and it isn't close

man i like him but he's on the titans and always plays so good against us

[AwesomeAustin]

Jason Witten

 

Currently Jalen Hurts. Only bc I despised how the reporter who asked him seconds after the game how it felt to be benched in the national championship and his Tua went out and got the win.  He answered with class but you could tell he couldn’t believe they chose that moment. He stayed at Alabama and didn’t transfer until he graduated and came in and won the SEC championship game for them. I think he is a total class act and glad he has the success he has. 

[John Hammonds]

On 12/12/2023 at 5:30 PM, holeymoley99 said:

Darius Leonard-Eagles

Bobby Okereke-Giants

Rodney McLeod-Browns

Jacoby Brisset-Wash

Zach Pascal-Cardinals

Mark Glowinski-Giants

 

 

Justin Houston - Panthers

Denico Autry - Titans

Rock Ya-Sin - Ravens

Malik Hooker - Cowboys

Anthony Walker Jr - Browns

Nyheim Hines - Bills

Parris Campbell - Giants

Zach Pascal - Cardinals

George Odum - 49'ers

[holeymoley99]

4 hours ago, John Hammonds said:

Justin Houston - Panthers

Denico Autry - Titans

Rock Ya-Sin - Ravens

Malik Hooker - Cowboys

Anthony Walker Jr - Browns

Nyheim Hines - Bills

Parris Campbell - Giants

Zach Pascal - Cardinals

George Odum - 49'ers

Was easy 3 years back when Jets had 11 former Colts on roster at the same time.

[King Colt]

TJ Watt where every son is a superstar.

[JackWV]

On 12/13/2023 at 12:50 AM, 2006Coltsbestever said:

I was going to say that too but I figured I would get buried in here for saying so. To me by my eye test, only Tom, Montana, and Peyton have played the position better. Mahomes is exciting to watch and he is great. Aaron Rodgers is my 1b. To me Aaron is a top 10 QB of all-time.

Top 10 of all-time or top 10 of your time?

[2006Coltsbestever]

1 hour ago, JackWV said:

Top 10 of all-time or top 10 of your time?

I would say my time definitely that is since 1977 when I first started watching at 6 years old. Even if you included Unitas and Graham which is all-time, Rodgers would still be top 10 IMO. He has won 4 League MVP's and a SB + his stats are great. Hard to keep him out of the top 10. Not to mention his talent. I go by their play not who I like. So, I am not biased when doing a QB list. A lot of people hate Rodgers but that has nothing to do with his play.

 

I have Peyton 3rd and Unitas 5th, all-time. FWIW. You may have different opinions and that is fine. I would love to see your top 10 list, just to get a different perspective. .

 

To add to this, I watched most of the great QB's of the 70's and despite Bradshaw winning 4 SB's, he isn't in my top 10. He is more top 15ish to me. Great but was on loaded teams with arguably the greatest defenses of all-time.

[TrueBlue4ever]

I like to watch great tight-ends! Mackey, Chester, Clark and now next year Mallory!

I like to watch Kelce and Kittle.

[Colts.sb41]

[CheezyColt]

I'm a big 49ers guy as my "secondary team".  After we got Luck, I started watching Stanford on Saturday nights and got a full dose of CMC.  I've been rooting for him ever since.  I also love Deebo, Kittle, Aiyuk, and now I find myself on the Purdy bandwagon.  They're eating over there in SF, that's for sure.

[tfunky14]

Ray Lewis, best LB in my opinion. 

[Shepman]

Raiders Maxx Crosby, he is a beast and a game wrecker.  

[Trace Pyott]

On 12/12/2023 at 12:59 PM, Dingus McGirt said:

Ronald Acuna...

Are you a braves fan?  He’s my fav too. 

[AKB]

On 12/14/2023 at 4:28 AM, King Colt said:

TJ Watt where every son is a superstar.

shows how strong genetics are

[Dingus McGirt]

5 hours ago, Trace Pyott said:

Are you a braves fan?  He’s my fav too. 

Since 1967.  Heh

[husker61]

I have found myself rooting for Levi’s because of all the people here picking apart everything he does just to justify their infatuation with Richardson. Richardson COULD be good, but as of now there is no question who is better now. It’s fun to watch him and purdy play.

[sb41champs]

Patrick Mahomes

[Chrisaaron1023]

Was and still am a huge fan of Chad Johnson aka OchoCinco

 

Currently: Aaron Rodgers 

[LJpalmbeacher2]

On 12/12/2023 at 2:24 PM, RollerColt said:

I love Mike McDaniel lmao…

 

I have been getting into watches lately and my cousin said he has a really super duper expensive one. I seen a glimpse of it and it looked Huge. 

 

My favorite players are Joe Cool..... Kittle.....and still Aaron Rogers. I like Lamar Jackson too, I've never seen a player so slippery.... Henry too.

[RollerColt]

On 12/16/2023 at 11:18 AM, husker61 said:

I have found myself rooting for Levi’s because of all the people here picking apart everything he does just to justify their infatuation with Richardson. Richardson COULD be good, but as of now there is no question who is better now. It’s fun to watch him and purdy play.

https://www.titansreport.com/forum/4-titans-and-nfl-talk/

[LJpalmbeacher2]

On 12/16/2023 at 11:18 AM, husker61 said:

I have found myself rooting for Levi’s because of all the people here picking apart everything he does just to justify their infatuation with Richardson. Richardson COULD be good, but as of now there is no question who is better now. It’s fun to watch him and purdy play.

 

I don't know if Levis is or will be better than AR5. But he will be at the very least a very solid QB and has the arm talent to be very good in the near future imo. They both right now are looking up to Stroud while Bryce Young is looking up to everyone.