Luck for ROY

[gspdx]

From NFL.com

Between Luck, Seattle Seahawks quarterback Russell Wilson and Washington Redskins quarterback Robert Griffin III, you can pretty much flip a coin to decide who should win this award. I'd take Luck, because I think he's done more with a lesser supporting cast than Wilson or RG3. The Redskins and Seahawks have both outscored their opponents this season; Luck's Colts, meanwhile, have scored 37 fewer points than the opposition, yet have still managed to win nine games. That's more wins than any rookie quarterback drafted first overall. Luck has also led six fourth-quarter comebacks, the most by a rookie QB since the AFL-NFL merger. All three signal-callers are very good, but when it comes down to it, knowing what I know through Week 14, I'd still draft Luck first and RG3 second, with Wilson vaulting up to the third spot.

Discuss!

[FireJimCaldwell]

Discuss!

Sure

[Brooklyn Colt]

Sure

lol

[ColtsLegacy]

From NFL.com

Between Luck, Seattle Seahawks quarterback Russell Wilson and Washington Redskins quarterback Robert Griffin III, you can pretty much flip a coin to decide who should win this award. I'd take Luck, because I think he's done more with a lesser supporting cast than Wilson or RG3. The Redskins and Seahawks have both outscored their opponents this season; Luck's Colts, meanwhile, have scored 37 fewer points than the opposition, yet have still managed to win nine games. That's more wins than any rookie quarterback drafted first overall. Luck has also led six fourth-quarter comebacks, the most by a rookie QB since the AFL-NFL merger. All three signal-callers are very good, but when it comes down to it, knowing what I know through Week 14, I'd still draft Luck first and RG3 second, with Wilson vaulting up to the third spot.

Discuss!

I would like to see this three-sided coin.

[Malakai432]

Sure

FireJim!!! I'm sure you missed about 3 more !!!!

[Stephen]

Give it to all three

[Indyfan4life]

I have several three-sided coins if you want one.

[FireJimCaldwell]

FireJim!!! I'm sure you missed about 3 more !!!!

3? 3 times what?

[Malakai432]

3? 3 times what?

3 more threads on Luck vs RGiii. It's probably more like 50 though unfortunately.

[braveheartcolt]

This is the new 'Jerry Hughes comeback thread'.....

[Brooklyn Colt]

This is the new 'Jerry Hughes comeback thread'.....

I nearly choked on what I was eating..

[FireJimCaldwell]

3 more threads on Luck vs RGiii. It's probably more like 50 though unfortunately.

Oh I knew what you meant I was trying to say 3? Like just 3? More like 3 x what? 3 x 7?=21 3x 16= 48... sounds about right.

[LeRyan07]

This is going to be close race. Even though Wilson has been good, i don't think he will be in it. Its between Luck and RG3. When im watching analyst debate about who is better, its pretty much always a split. Luck and his interceptions might hurt him.

[Malakai432]

Oh I knew what you meant I was trying to say 3? Like just 3? More like 3 x what? 3 x 7?=21 3x 16= 48... sounds about right.

Yes + the Nash Equilibrium times the circular dimension of the galaxies largest black hole raised to alpha.

[Freenyfan102]

I would pick luck becuase look at the Line and the Wr One Good Wr and One Good Lineman that bascially it......Redskins have all the weapons and they just need a QB and the Seahawks have been coming up big since they won against the Saints in the playoffs

[Qwiz]

[Emma]

That's not exactly how you, uh, use that meme.

[Qwiz]

That's not exactly how you, uh, use that meme.

...but I did. ;)

[krunk]

Jeeesh! I'm sick of the "This Guy" Vs "That Guy" debates

[FireJimCaldwell]

Jeeesh! I'm sick of the "This Guy" Vs "That Guy" debates

Do you prefer "That Guy" Vs "This Guy" debates?

[Malakai432]

Do you prefer "That Guy" Vs "This Guy" debates?

Sounds much more professional.

[The Peytonator]

Jeeesh! I'm sick of the "This Guy" Vs "That Guy" debates

Don't be talking bad about my guy 'That Guy'....he's a good poster on here.

[southwest1]

I would like to see this three-sided coin.

I think Two Faced, the Batman villain would like to see this 3 faced coin too. He's not gonna be happy about this news at all...

[LeRyan07]

i really do hope Luck wins this.

[CardiacColts]

I want Luck to win, but not as bad as I would like to win a playoff game...I think Luck deserves it simply due to the fact that he is working with less talent than the other two and that you cannot discount him being the first number 1 drafted rookie QB to win as many games as he has. As for the scoring differential, that can also be attributed to better Defenses and Offensive lines not just QB play.