Greatest QBs of All Time: NFL.com Vote

[Andrew Luck's Beard]

http://www.nfl.com/qs/bracketology/round1.jsp

 

Of course there's no Andrew, and of course Russell Wilson is there...

 

Anyways, have fun! If you guys want, you should post your results here!

[Dustin]

>Russell Wilson

 

hahahahah my sides

[Colts_Fan12]

Who is the * that added Russel Wilson??

[Dustin]

Who is the * that added Russel Wilson??

 

Seriously.. that seems like some type of joke.

[jvan1973]

There are garbage qbs all over that board

[21isSuperman]

There's no way this will go poorly....

[Colts_Fan12]

Seriously.. that seems like some type of joke.

I agree I don't know how anyone can take it seriously

[bestQBever]

I stopped taking it seriously when I saw Russel wilson on the front cover of the bracketology link. All the analysts on NFL.com are calling Luck "the best young QB in the league" yet Russel Wilson gets to compete for best QB of all time? what a joke.

[Jaric]

Who let Eli Manning and Phillip Rivers on this list?

[jvan1973]

I stopped taking it seriously when I saw Russel wilson on the front cover of the bracketology link. All the analysts on NFL.com are calling Luck "the best young QB in the league" yet Russel Wilson gets to compete for best QB of all time? what a joke.

neither belong on that list yet

[Jaric]

And where the heck are Kenny Stabler and Len Dawson?  Bob Griese was a glorified handoff machine.

[Track Guy]

Voted for:

Brady

Brees

Rodgers

P. Manning

Favre

Warner

Young

Bledsoe

Montana

Kelly

Elway

Marino

Unitas

Staubach

Starr

Graham

 

Interestingly I think even thought the front 4 in the "right now" section are stronger than the "millenials" section, I think the back half is weaker. Roethlisberger, Rivers, Wilson, and E. Manning vs McNabb, McNair, Bledsoe, and Gannon (I think a better combination of 4). 

 

Best from the 4 sections I'd say "right now" toss up between Brady and P. Manning (if I have to chose I'm going with Manning), "millenials" Warner over Favre, "generation x" toss up between Montana and Marino (if I have to chose I'll pick Montana), "baby boomers" I'm not positive but I lean towards Johnny U.

[Fx Stryker]

Eli beats Brady, right? 2-0

[supremecoltsfan300]

How is Rodgers a higher seed than Brees....

And yes Wilson should not be on there. Replacing Wilson should be Romo or Flacco (personally I would have Romo).

Graham should not be an 8 seed. And Namath as a 5...you have got to be kidding me.

And Eli should be a 5 seed, a 6 at worst.

[supremecoltsfan300]

Prediction for later rounds (since they're already showing us the results for current ones):

Peyton (2) beats Brady (1).

Elway (2) beats Marino (1).

 

Currently, I'm shocked McNabb is beating Warner and by so much.  Warner was the better player easily in my eyes.

[chad72]

Eli beats Brady, right? 2-0

 

True, based on Pats fans logic, it is. It was always Brady beating Peyton when it came to Pats vs Colts.

 

Never mind, Peyton is 2-2 vs Brady in the playoffs and 2-1 in AFCCG.

 

But honestly, how did Russell Wilson get on that list? I can understand Big Ben and Eli to an extent but a 2nd year QB???

[bestQBever]

neither belong on that list yet

true. I would be happy if Andrew was on that list but he's not even close as of now. 

[Derakynn]

Where is Joe Flacco? I am enraged. 

[Bluefire4]

Of course Wilson is on there because of his super bowl ring.

[Colts_Fan12]

How is Rodgers a higher seed than Brees....

And yes Wilson should not be on there. Replacing Wilson should be Romo or Flacco (personally I would have Romo).

Graham should not be an 8 seed. And Namath as a 5...you have got to be kidding me.

And Eli should be a 5 seed, a 6 at worst.

Rodgers is a better QB then Brees Rodgers is a better QB then Brady too.

Peyton should be the 1 and Rodgers should be the 2 then Brady at 3

[Vance]

What no Trent Dilfer?

[Gabriel Alexander Morillo]

Marino in my book.

[Colts_Fan12]

Marino in my book.

But he didn't win a Super Bowl!! Jk

I got Peyton I don't think post season and SBs should be a factor. It takes a team to win those games the best to play the QB position IMO is Peyton

[Shane Bond]

They will finally select Joe Montana for his rings.

[jamesie jr]

Voted for:

Brady

Brees

Rodgers

Manning

Favre

Mcnabb

McNair

Aikman

Montana

Moon

Elway

Marino

Unitas

Namath

Tarkenton

Graham

 

Also how do you find out what the current results are?

[crazycolt1]

The whole subject of who is the goat has long been proven to be all just opinion. With that in mind there is no clear cut answer. This subject has been argued forever and never will be determined. Too many variables to even think that fans will ever agree on one. 

[adamthyst]

Why is Russell Wilson on this list? He hasn't even been in the league that long..

[King Colt]

Bobby Douglas Chicago Bears

[supremecoltsfan300]

Rodgers is a better QB then Brees Rodgers is a better QB then Brady too.

Peyton should be the 1 and Rodgers should be the 2 then Brady at 3

Legacy wise Rodgers is not better than those two. The seeding should be based on perceived legacy and then the voting can determine who is better. Rodgers hasnt acccomplished as much as those other guys yet.

[thedude]

http://www.nfl.com/qs/bracketology/round1.jsp

 

Of course there's no Andrew, and of course Russell Wilson is there...

 

Anyways, have fun! If you guys want, you should post your results here!

 

>Russell Wilson

 

hahahahah my sides

 

Who is the * that added Russel Wilson??

 

Seriously.. that seems like some type of joke.

Do you thin Andrew Luch is as bothered by this as you guys?

[Dustin]

Do you thin Andrew Luch is as bothered by this as you guys?

Seeing as how that's not a real person...no.

[Colts_Fan12]

Do you thin Andrew Luch is as bothered by this as you guys?

I never said Andrew should be on there but Wilson being on there is a damn joke

[thedude]

Seeing as how that's not a real person...no.

Ok, Andrew Luck..... must I.....?

[thedude]

I never said Andrew should be on there but Wilson being on there is a damn joke

Really?  He's certainly in the conversation as one of the best QB's today. 

[Colts_Fan12]

Really? He's certainly in the conversation as one of the best QB's today.

He is better then all the young QBs but none of them should be on there for GOAT. But if any of them should be on there is should be Andrew

[thedude]

If Luck had been the winningest QB in NFL history his first two seasons and led a team to a super bowl win he would have been on the list.

[Colts_Fan12]

If Luck had been the winningest QB in NFL history his first two seasons and led a team to a super bowl win he would have been on the list.

Lead his team to a Super Bowl win is a little bit of a stretch. More like followed his D to the Super Bowl

[thedude]

Lead his team to a Super Bowl win is a little bit of a stretch. More like followed his D to the Super Bowl

Without him, they wouldn't have made it to the super bowl. 

[thedude]

some of you seem to have an inferiority complex when it comes to Russell Wilson.

[Dustin]

some of you seem to have an inferiority complex when it comes to Russell Wilson.

No, if Luck had been on that list it would have been equally ridiculous.