hmmm.. what a quandary.

[sreylas937]

Heard this on the news, was wanting your all input. Will you be willing to give up the Win, to get Wayne back for the season?

[Kyle]

in B4 thread close

[ColtsUrUs]

Heard this on the news, was wanting your all input. Will you be willing to give up the Win, to get Wayne back for the season?

That's like saying giving up the win to get Ballard, Allen and Bradshaw up. That would mean we'll have our 1st round pick back. Injuries happen to every team. Only injury I would hate for any team to have is the QB. 

[AllYouNeedIsLuck]

Stupid thread. But yes, I'd rather be 4-3 with Wayne than 5-2 without

[PrincetonTiger]

It made me think when Trent Dilfer said it on. MNC

[pgt_rob]

Just a part of the game. It really does suck. Wayne set us up to get this far but I believe we can do it with a few minor changes as long as we can hold onto the ball.

[csmopar]

I think Reggie would rather the team succeed. Therefore, I'll vote for the win. While Reggie's injury sucked, it is part of the game, winning is the goal, Reggie knows this and that is why he tried to make the catch he got hurt on. For those that have never played, it maybe hard to grasp what I'm about to say. When you're part of a team, you put your body on the line for the team as a whole. Injuries are something no one wants to happen, but when they happen, you have to rally behind your teammates, lean on each other to overcome it. Debating whether or not you'd give up a win in my opinion is counter to the point of the game. Reggie is one of my all time favorite athletes. I've always liked how he led by example. I will miss seeing him on the field. However, there are 52 other players on our team. Lets rally behind them, nothing we do is going to bring Reggie back. So lets look forward and stop all these what if threads. We are the Colts, WE will be fine!

 

Rant over..

[BOTT]

Yes....but a pointless question

[WastedColt]

Yes, no question. We would still be leading the division and still have our best receiver

[TKnight24]

The time for the without Reggie Wayne was approaching anyway. This gives us the chance to see what it'll be like

[Warhorse]

Why entertain choices that do not exist in the universe? The threads about them would be endless.

[Gramz]

Hard to answer that one.

 

I am heartbroken that Reggie is Out.  One of my favorite players of all time.

I just hope that he can recover, and get at least one more season in.   

 

I would hate to think that this past Sunday could have been his last game ever.

Such a bittersweet Win...

 

Get Well, Reggie.

[WastedColt]

It won't be his last game. Reggie told Pagano that he doesn't want his career to end this way. He will rehab and come back next year. Maybe not in the same capacity, but we will see him on the field again

[Devildog]

It wouldn't be PB & J without either. You can still eat the sandwich with the jelly alone but it wouldn't be as good without the peanut butter. 

[sreylas937]

Ok some people are missing the point of the question... All it was,was a Hypothetical question... It's not what I think, But what I heard. To be honest I can care less If it's a stupid thread like 1 person has said... Is it really any worst then seeing the 500 threads about what WR should we trade for?  

[Nadine]

I would rather the one loss and we keep reggie.  We are much better with him and I love watching him play........and I think he's a funny guy

 

Just like having Reggie is all

[Kenny]

I'll take the win please. I love Reggie more than any other Colt, but it is a sad and unfortunate part of the game.

[Gramz]

Ok some people are missing the point of the question... All it was,was a Hypothetical question... It's not what I think, But what I heard. To be honest I can care less If it's a stupid thread like 1 person has said... Is it really any worst then seeing the 500 threads about what WR should we trade for?

okay then, yes... I'd give up the Win to keep Reggie.

[ColtsLegacy]

It'd be stupid to say no. Of course I'd give up one win to get Reggie back, he's worth so much more to this team than one measly regular season win.

[Gabriel Alexander Morillo]

This better not be his last game ever. But yes I'd have rather been blown out by 90 points than have Reggie get injured in the way he did.