QB Rankings

[Nobody]

http://bleacherreport.com/articles/1378923-midseason-report-card-grades-for-every-starting-nfl-qb

His main reason for RG3's A+? (and the only A+ of any QB) His completion percentage!

His main (only) reason for Luck's C+? (behind Tannehill and Wilson) He throws too many short passes.

[IndyD4U]

Seems pretty Schottey to me. Romo rated a B+?! Wha WHAT?

Just another fools opinion...unfortunately, they all have one

[MTC]

It's bleacherreport. What do you expect?

[Holden89]

IDK, I pretty much agree with the rankings. I think he was very harsh on Luck, though... What's funny is he is completely wrong about Luck "dinking and dunking" though... Part of our problem on offense is that we seem to refuse to just dink and dunk sometimes...

Other than that, I think this article is pretty accurate.

[HungarianColtsFan]

http://bleacherrepor...starting-nfl-qb

His main reason for RG3's A+? (and the only A+ of any QB) His completion percentage!

His main (only) reason for Luck's C+? (behind Tannehill and Wilson) He throws too many short passes.

1. I'm fed ap comparing QBs. You just can't do it properly, allways will be subjective. Not only throws and TDs are making a QB, but his command of O-line and decisions too, those factors cannot be quantized. You'll always find a number that makes Your QB shine.

2. nfl.com made a metric analysis showing that Luck yds/pass number is 8.6 that is far higher than QBs' average.

http://www.nfl.com/news/story/0ap1000000085902/article/andrew-luck-vs-robert-griffin-iii-making-case-for-luck

So much on BleacherReport. Or Bealcher...?

[FireJimCaldwell]

Fox Sports might hire this guy and give him his own weekly FQBR.

[SLILLINGTON10]

who cares. i like the qb we have and i wouldn't trade him for any other guy in the league.. lets these outsiders talk.

[ColtsBlueFL]

I am curious as to why every time an opinion piece is put up, that it gets shot down with the "It's Bleacherreport" type of response? I don't know the writers so I checked this guy-

—Five years as producer/Host of The Average Joe Sports Show (860AM KNUJ/KNUJ.net).

—NFL Analyst/Senior Writer: DraftTek.com (Covering Detroit and Carolina)

—Member of the Pro Football Writers of America

—2011 PFWA Dick Connor Award Winner for Column Writing

So having been published in Beacherreport outweighs any credentials to write an opinion piece?? Just want to get perspective. Not knocking anybody or thing. Not that I agree with this opinion piece, either. Just fell 'not in the know'.

[MR. Blueblood]

Cam gets a B- when his attitude and play have been stinking up the place, not to mention Carolina's record this year....I didn't need to go on any further than that.

[ar1888]

Bleacher report is the wikipedia of sports writing. Pretty much anyone can write for them. Its a freaking fan site.

[ColtsBlueFL]

Bleacher report is the wikipedia of sports writing. Pretty much anyone can write for them. Its a freaking fan site.

OK, I see. But in this case, this particular guy is not 'pretty much anyone', and probably shouldn't be lumped in that category, IMHO. His opinion should be debated on it's merit (or lack of), not the source of the publication. I'll check other writers in the future and see what cred they have for offering up opinion pieces to the masses.

[subvet]

Well, opinions are like many things, everyone has one but this one should have come with a roll of toilet paper....

[Andy]

And for the 600th time, Bleacher Report is a bad site. It's all bias, their writing style and structure is beyond terrible and they really don't know what they're talking about.

[braveheartcolt]

And for the 600th time, Bleacher Report is a bad site. It's all bias, their writing style and structure is beyond terrible and they really don't know what they're talking about.

SO I should trust your writing style and not theirs? Why should I do that Andy? You are good poster on here, don't get me wrong, but your comments hold no more sway than anyone elses.