Jump to content
Indianapolis Colts
Indianapolis Colts Fan Forum

Todd McShay's 2 Round Mock


Peytonparker

Recommended Posts

Has us selecting Fleener in the 2nd over players such as Ta'Amu, Reuben Randle, Alshon Jeffrey and Janoris Jenkins. Personally I would rather have any of these players I just mentioned over Fleener. Not a knock on Fleener, I just think the other players I listed would be better

http://insider.espn.go.com/nfl/draft2012/story/_/id/7745867/2012-nfl-mock-draft-projecting-first-two-rounds

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Round 2

Pick Team Player Position School 33 Rams Jerel Worthy DT Michigan State 34 Colts Coby Fleener TE Stanford 35 Vikings Alshon Jeffery WR South Carolina 36 Buccaneers Zach Brown OLB North Carolina 37 Browns Brandon Weeden QB Oklahoma State 38 Jaguars Nick Perry DE USC 39 Rams (from Was.) Rueben Randle WR LSU 40 Panthers Janoris Jenkins CB North Alabama 41 Bills Brock Osweiler QB Arizona State 42 Dolphins Bobby Massie OT Mississippi 43 Seahawks Mychal Kendricks ILB Cal 44 Chiefs Kevin Zeitler OG Wisconsin 45 Cowboys Amini Silatolu OG Midwestern State 46 Eagles Devon Still DT Penn State 47 Jets Brandon Thompson DT/DE Clemson 48 Patriots (from Oak.) Peter Konz C Wisconsin 49 Chargers Alameda Ta'amu NT Washington 50 Bears Dwayne Allen TE Clemson 51 Eagles (from Ari.) Ronnell Lewis OLB Oklahoma 52 Titans Orson Charles TE Georgia 53 Bengals Lamar Miller RB Miami (Fla.) 54 Lions Josh Robinson CB UCF 55 Falcons Vinny Curry DE Marshall 56 Steelers Doug Martin RB Boise State 57 Broncos David Wilson RB Virginia Tech 58 Texans Zebrie Sanders OT Florida State 59 Packers Trumaine Johnson CB Montana 60 Ravens Jeff Allen OG Illinois 61 49ers Kelechi Osemele OG Iowa State 62 Patriots Brandon Taylor S LSU 63 Giants Mitchell Schwartz OT Cal

This is his 2nd rd

Link to comment
Share on other sites

It's Todd McShay, not Mayock.

This is probably one of the most ideal drafts. We get Luck and Fleener and take off our 2 biggest needs while getting the 2 best players available (at the certain point in the draft). I'd love to have Fleener.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Sorry. It is McShay, LOL I was reading something by Mayock right before I posted this. I am not knocking Fleener, just saying that if the draft did fall this way I would rather have one of the players I listed earlier than Fleener, IMO they are all better talents who fill a more pressing need

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Sorry. It is McShay, LOL I was reading something by Mayock right before I posted this. I am not knocking Fleener, just saying that if the draft did fall this way I would rather have one of the players I listed earlier than Fleener, IMO they are all better talents who fill a more pressing need

What's a more pressing need than TE. Our current starter at TE is Brody Eldridge. I think it's out biggest need. There is no better player available (basing it off his projections) than Fleener. He's the best TE in the draft and he has a great bond with Luck. Also, his athleticism is one of the best I've ever seen from a TE.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

It would be really tough to pass on Janoris Jenkins. I wouldn't even mind trading back into the 2nd to get him. He's the 2nd best CB in this draft by far! TE is a bigger need though so we should pick Coby Fleener at 34 if he's there.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

What's a more pressing need than TE. Our current starter at TE is Brody Eldridge. I think it's out biggest need. There is no better player available (basing it off his projections) than Fleener. He's the best TE in the draft and he has a great bond with Luck. Also, his athleticism is one of the best I've ever seen from a TE.

Barring a FA signing, our biggest need is NT. Our defense will fail without one, and we don't have one.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

What's a more pressing need than TE. Our current starter at TE is Brody Eldridge. I think it's out biggest need. There is no better player available (basing it off his projections) than Fleener. He's the best TE in the draft and he has a great bond with Luck. Also, his athleticism is one of the best I've ever seen from a TE.

A fullback that can catch. The TE isn't even the first option in the Spider 3 Y banana (sarcasm). TE is a definite need, I just don't necessary think so in the 2nd round (and I still don't believe Fleener will be there when we pick). I give McShay less credit than anyone when it comes to mocks.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

nevis could play NT. TE is our biggest need

Nevis can not play 3-4 NT

Like Peytonparker said, there is no way Nevis can play NT in a 2-gap 3-4 scheme. 1-gap, yeah maybe. Nevis is now a DE, and will be more of a rotational guy. I wish we had gotten him 3 or 4 years ago, he would've been a beast in our schemes under Polian. Now, I am not sure what to expect out of him, especially after being on IR last year.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I would rather see Drake playing DE in the 3-4.

if i can take the words of our GM you dont put a round peg in a square hole. moloa would be better off playing DE opposite redding. moloa played 3-4 DE in college

Link to comment
Share on other sites

if i can take the words of our GM you dont put a round peg in a square hole. moloa would be better off playing DE opposite redding. moloa played 3-4 DE in college

I understand that, but aren't you doing the same thing with Nevis? He is a prototypical 4-3 DT and played a 4-3 in college

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I understand that, but aren't you doing the same thing with Nevis? He is a prototypical 4-3 DT and played a 4-3 in college

this is a smaller hole then what you wanna do. he can work and obviously the coaches think so too or else we would have picked someone up.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Drafting Talent is always preferred, and with all the needs we have, we are lucky to be able to do both. Fleener was listed in the first round on most mocks until recently and only because teams have other bigger needs than TE. We would be lucky if he is there for us. Look at what a draft TE did for NE in Rob Gronkowski who happens to be 6'6" 265 and Fleener is 6'6" 244. Give Luck someone to throw to besides old man Reggie.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

What's a more pressing need than TE. Our current starter at TE is Brody Eldridge. I think it's out biggest need. There is no better player available (basing it off his projections) than Fleener. He's the best TE in the draft and he has a great bond with Luck. Also, his athleticism is one of the best I've ever seen from a TE.

some good points you made but "hes the best tight end in the draft isnt saying alot this isnt a great draft for that position, as for more pressing need, Corner or Defensive Tackle thats simple, witht hat said I know we need a tight end that cant be overlooked but Id rather have one in the late rounds
Link to comment
Share on other sites

this is a smaller hole then what you wanna do. he can work and obviously the coaches think so too or else we would have picked someone up.

OK.....so obviously they also think our CBs and TEs can work or else they would have picked someone up. You are now working on assumptions.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

What's a more pressing need than TE. Our current starter at TE is Brody Eldridge. I think it's out biggest need. There is no better player available (basing it off his projections) than Fleener. He's the best TE in the draft and he has a great bond with Luck. Also, his athleticism is one of the best I've ever seen from a TE.

Don't agree at all Andy. TE's are easy to get in the 4th or 5th rd. and they can still be very good. NT is without doubt the biggest need (besides QB) on the roster. Without a good 3-4 NT the defense will not work no matter how good the players we have at other positions.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

OK.....so obviously they also think our CBs and TEs can work or else they would have picked someone up. You are now working on assumptions.

cb isnt as bad as some people make it out to be imo. we have three young cbs in powers,thomas,and ruckers that we can develop. TE hasnt been addressed because the colts will make a play to get coby fleener or another TE in the draft.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

We would be so fortunate to have Fleener available at 34. Slim chance that will happen. If he is, I hope the Colt rep is standing there with the selection already in his hand, shaking like a leaf in a windstorm with giddy excitement.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

We would be so fortunate to have Fleener available at 34. Slim chance that will happen. If he is, I hope the Colt rep is standing there with the selection already in his hand, shaking like a leaf in a windstorm with giddy excitement.

i cant really see any team wanting fleener in the first. theres too much first round talent plus the only team i can really see making a play on fleener is either the 49ers or giants, but both have another glaring needs like wr for the 49ers and safety for the giants.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I have Hill falling to the 49ers and Giants taking Doug Martin from Boise State. Travis Beckum is now expected to be fit for the Giants, which means they don't need a TE high.

I'm still hopeful Fleener will fall to us. Remember last year, Tight End Kyle Rudolph was marked as a lock to the Falcons in the first round? He ended up at pick #43.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Wow..there is so much DL talent on that board right there. And 3 fabulous backs. I've got to see who he had in round 1. To me Fleener is not what we need. We will be a run first team...meaning we need a starting TE that is a great BLOCKER...not receiver...who have Pitts typically had at TE....hmm not super athletic skilled slot type TEs...I seem to remember big wide bodied block 1st TEs with good hands. That can be filled in round 4 or 5 in the draft. Look what happened to Dallas when we tried using him as a blocker. It just didn't work..and it won't with Fleener. Fleener has been said to be one of the worst blocking TEs out of the top 5 TEs in the draft. Pass on that dude and get more value at another need position. DL or CB.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Ta'amu is more of a 3rd round prospect. With our need at NT and virtualy nothing happening in FA, I wouldnt be surprised if we get him in the 3rd, provided hes still there. I do not want Jeffry's lazy butt and Jenkins personality on this team imo. Id be glad with randle or fleener in the 2nd.

I have seen some draft boards where Ta'amu is listed in first round.

I watched him a lot. Hes great!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Wow..there is so much DL talent on that board right there. And 3 fabulous backs. I've got to see who he had in round 1. To me Fleener is not what we need. We will be a run first team...meaning we need a starting TE that is a great BLOCKER...not receiver...who have Pitts typically had at TE....hmm not super athletic skilled slot type TEs...I seem to remember big wide bodied block 1st TEs with good hands. That can be filled in round 4 or 5 in the draft. Look what happened to Dallas when we tried using him as a blocker. It just didn't work..and it won't with Fleener. Fleener has been said to be one of the worst blocking TEs out of the top 5 TEs in the draft. Pass on that dude and get more value at another need position. DL or CB.

Heath Miller is 6'5 250 Fleener is 6'6 250.. Miller was also a first round pick

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Wow..there is so much DL talent on that board right there. And 3 fabulous backs. I've got to see who he had in round 1. To me Fleener is not what we need. We will be a run first team...meaning we need a starting TE that is a great BLOCKER...not receiver...who have Pitts typically had at TE....hmm not super athletic skilled slot type TEs...I seem to remember big wide bodied block 1st TEs with good hands. That can be filled in round 4 or 5 in the draft. Look what happened to Dallas when we tried using him as a blocker. It just didn't work..and it won't with Fleener. Fleener has been said to be one of the worst blocking TEs out of the top 5 TEs in the draft. Pass on that dude and get more value at another need position. DL or CB.

i don't believe for a seconnd that the colts will be a run first team...unless luck is a disappointment.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I have seen some draft boards where Ta'amu is listed in first round.

I watched him a lot. Hes great!

Not for sure if we're watching the same player. Against the good teams he seemed to not perform very well at all. Against Baylor (Who honestly didn't have that great of an O-line) he was non-existent in that game. Against USC he wasn't really amazing either and against Stanford got beat up (But Stanford did have an amazing O-line) like everyone else. While he did have a pretty good senior bowl, he's still had a pretty inconsistent season. That game against Baylor just seemed to be a bad sign cause he seemed invisible the entire time. 482 rushing yards against Washington that game sums up how he played that game. He's likely to get picked near the middle or end of the 2nd round, but is more of a 3rd round pick or even a 4th round pick.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Don't agree at all Andy. TE's are easy to get in the 4th or 5th rd. and they can still be very good. NT is without doubt the biggest need (besides QB) on the roster. Without a good 3-4 NT the defense will not work no matter how good the players we have at other positions.

The Steelers defense was arguably the best this year and they had a declining Hampton. The Texans defense was one of the best and they had Shaun Cody, who isn't that great at all. The 49ers had another great defense, arguably the best, and they didn't have a very good defense. You can do very well without a good NT, especially with a genius like Pagano.

In this year's draft, the TE class is absolutely horrible. We're looking at, besides Fleener, Allen, Charles, Green and Egnew, there are no real starters. Maybe Ellison could be a starter. This is one of the worst classes I've seen in years. There is no depth in the class, so you either have to make it a priority or just take a guy in the middle rounds that would become a mediocre starter. I'm looking for a great starter. If Fleener is not there at 34, then it's just better to take out our other needs and wait until the middle rounds. It's hard to find a good starter in the middle rounds, and nearly impossible in this draft.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
  • Topics

  • Posts

    • If being a GM were easy, anyone could do it. Reality in life is like a hard teacher, she gives the test first, then the lessons come later.
    • Championing the Art of Mediocrity   In the realm of NFL management where big splashes and bold moves often steal the spotlight, Chris Ballard of the Indianapolis Colts stands as a beacon of mediocrity—oops, I mean, moderation and stability. Ballard has mastered the art of steering clear of both spectacular success and abject failure, opting instead for a comfortable middle ground where his team consistently hovers around average.   While other GMs chase after flashy signings and high-profile trades, Ballard prefers a more subtle approach. His teams are like the middle child of the NFL—neither the star of the family nor the problem child. Take, for instance, his draft picks: solid, dependable players who rarely make headlines but also rarely make Pro Bowls. It's a strategy that ensures the Colts remain perennially in the hunt for the playoffs without ever seriously threatening to win it all.   Critics may scoff at Ballard's reluctance to swing for the fences, pointing to the lack of marquee names on his roster or the absence of Lombardi Trophies in his trophy case. Yet, Ballard remains unfazed, steadfast in his belief that consistently finishing just outside the top tier is a commendable achievement in itself.   In a league where greatness is often measured by Super Bowl rings and MVP titles, Ballard's Colts serve as a refreshing reminder that there's honor in being consistently okay. While other teams chase after glory, Ballard quietly celebrates the virtues of stability and predictability—a strategy that ensures his team remains perpetually good enough to keep fans interested without ever giving them false hope of a championship.   So here's to you, Chris Ballard, our unsung hero of NFL mediocrity. May our Colts continue to embody the spirit of contentment in a league that sometimes seems obsessed with extremes. Your dedication to the middle ground is a testament to the fact that in a world of winners and losers, there's beauty in just being average.   Our Chris Ballard, the enigmatic mastermind behind the Indianapolis Colts' draft selections, continues to astound with his unconventional approach to player evaluation. Known for his ability to turn perceived draft flops into valuable lessons in resilience, Ballard has elevated the art of optimism in the face of adversity.   Take, for instance, his selection of Quincy Wilson, a cornerback whose career trajectory seemed to follow the path less traveled—straight to the sidelines. Wilson's ability to excel in the role of 'spectator extraordinaire' brought a new dimension to the Colts' bench, proving that even inactivity can be a form of contribution.   Then there's TJ Green, whose ability to redefine the term 'safety' by providing the opposing offense with a false sense of security is a testament to Ballard's commitment to strategic innovation. Green's unpredictable presence on the field undoubtedly kept quarterbacks on their toes, in excitement.    And who could forget Ben Banogu, a defensive end whose knack for demonstrating the art of camouflage by seamlessly blending into the turf has left spectators marveling at his commitment to environmental integration. Banogu's ability to remain inconspicuous during critical moments showcases Ballard's emphasis on adaptability and the importance of being one with your surroundings.   Ballard's genius lies not just in his ability to select players, but in his skillful navigation of the delicate dance between expectation and reality. His selections may not always align with conventional wisdom, but they consistently challenge perceptions and redefine what it means to be a draft bust.   As Ballard continues to forge ahead, his unorthodox approach serves as a beacon of hope for aspiring NFL general managers everywhere, including those perusing fan forums. Because if there's one thing Chris Ballard has taught us, it's that in the unpredictable world of professional football, even the most unexpected outcomes can be reframed as victories in disguise.   AKB
    • He started 14 games at SS in 2019 and started 8 games in 2018 for the Jags.  I meant to post this earlier in the thread.   https://www.pro-football-reference.com/players/H/HarrRo02.htm        
    • The additions of say Taylor, Raimann, and looking back to Leonard could be called important, savy drafting.  Our Colts have been waiting for awhile for a special, difference making player to surprisingly fall to US. Right when we really really needed it to happen, it sure looks like we got two of them. 🙏 for good health.  AR a surprise at 4, not at all.  But      
    • You're not certain...but you know it's a fact.  How does that work? Haha
  • Members

×
×
  • Create New...