Andrew Luck is the best QB in the NFL?

[thedude]

What did Brady do last season that was better than Luck?

Brady has a complete body of work developed over many years to lean on. He has led his team to several championships.

[shecolt]

It came up in another forum. 

 

This thread was started on 2/3 and the conversation stopped on 2/8.

 

You posted in this thread on 2/19 to ask, "Why did people lose interest in this thread?"

 

That opened up the conversation again and it lasted until 2/24.

 

Now, you are here again on 3/21 and it's just because this topic came up on another forum.

 

Dude, I may be naive; but I'm not stupid.

[thedude]

 

Dude, I may be naive; but I'm not stupid.

I should get kudos for not taking advantage of that prime set-up line.

[braveheartcolt]

Brady has a complete body of work developed over many years to lean on. He has led his team to several championships.

So that makes him better now? What he has done in the past? And by that reasoning, if Marino made a comeback, he'd better now as well?

 

Got ya.

[thedude]

So that makes him better now? What he has done in the past? And by that reasoning, if Marino made a comeback, he'd better now as well?

 

Got ya.

What kind of logic is that?

[braveheartcolt]

What kind of logic is that?

Good logic.

[thedude]

Good logic.

It's good logic to compare their recent performances against a player who has been retired for at least a decade to determine who's the better QB today? Really?

[AntonMcG]

This thread was started on 2/3 and the conversation stopped on 2/8.

 

You posted in this thread on 2/19 to ask, "Why did people lose interest in this thread?"

 

That opened up the conversation again and it lasted until 2/24.

 

Now, you are here again on 3/21 and it's just because this topic came up on another forum.

 

Dude, I may be naive; but I'm not stupid.

 

Is that a bannable offense? I hope so, because I consider him thoroughly annoying.

[braveheartcolt]

It's good logic to compare their recent performances against a player who has been retired for at least a decade to determine who's the better QB today? RNneally?

Well, that is what your doing. Using Brady's PAST to determine he is better now.

 

PS - personal opinions CANNOT be wrong. Just saying.

[thedude]

Well, that is what your doing. Using Brady's PAST to determine he is better now.

 

PS - personal opinions CANNOT be wrong. Just saying.

Brady is a current player with a recent history. Marino is a player from the past. An increasingly distant past.

[thedude]

Is that a bannable offense? I hope so, because I consider him thoroughly annoying.

Good.

[thedude]

 

PS - personal opinions CANNOT be wrong. Just saying.

If you state your opinion as a fact and that "fact" is incorrect, your opinion is indeed wrong.

[AntonMcG]

Good.

 

Ah, so you come on to an internet forum with the intention of annoying people you don't know... lol.

 

Must be a slow Saturday.

[thedude]

Ah, so you come on to an internet forum with the intention of annoying people you don't know... lol.

 

Must be a slow Saturday.

No, I'm just amused by those who get their knickers in a twist over extremely trivial things.

[thedude]

If someone irritated me that badly, I'd simply exercise the ignore option. That's what it was designed for...... I think.

That's just my opinion. I could be wrong though.

[braveheartcolt]

No, I'm just amused by those who get their knickers in a twist over extremely trivial things.

You are rather amusing.....

[braveheartcolt]

If someone irritated me that badly, I'd simply exercise the ignore option. That's what it was designed for...... I think.

That's just my opinion. I could be wrong though.

Now that is funny.

[thedude]

You are rather amusing.....

Sometimes you are as well. Other times, amusing isn't the word I'd use.

[thedude]

Now that is funny.

Was that an example of me being amusing?

[shecolt]

Is that a bannable offense? I hope so, because I consider him thoroughly annoying.

 

  Well, I turned in my mod badge; but I would say that it is more of a warnable offense.

[shecolt]

I should get kudos for not taking advantage of that prime set-up line.

 

Go ahead.  Make my day.

[thedude]

Go ahead.  Make my day.

My Dad taught me to never be mean to girls......well, now, women.

[ColtsBlueFL]

Well, that is what your doing. Using Brady's PAST to determine he is better now.

 

PS - personal opinions CANNOT be wrong. Just saying.

 

Well.... if the opinion is about something objective (and backed by observable fact), rather than subjective, it can be.  However, your point is taken. Sometimes it's just better to state your position, then agree to disagree and move on.

[thedude]

  Well, I turned in my mod badge; but I would say that it is more of a warnable offense.

Bumping an active, viable thread is a "warnable" offense? Odd infraction code here.

[thedude]

e.

[thedude]

But seeing as you brought up Brady, who do you suppose is better at reading a defense now? Brady or Luck? Who do you suppose is better at discovering tendencies in a defense and exploiting them now? Brady or Luck?

Those are softball questions which should be quite easy to answer.

[braveheartcolt]

But seeing as you brought up Brady, who do you suppose is better at reading a defense now? Brady or Luck? Who do you suppose is better at discovering tendencies in a defense and exploiting them now? Brady or Luck?

Those are softball questions which should be quite easy to answer.

You did. Post 201.

 

Who is fitter, faster, stronger and younger......15 all.

[thedude]

You did. Post 201.

Who is fitter, faster, stronger and younger......15 all.

So, you think the younger, less experienced guy is better at reading defenses and finding tendencies in a defense which can be exploited than the virtual hall of fame lock who's led his team to several championships?

And I never mentioned Brady until you brought up his name prior to post 201.

[AntonMcG]

No, I'm just amused by those who get their knickers in a twist over extremely trivial things.

Oh yes, your bumping of this thread is clearly to enlighten and continue to discuss the contentious debate.

Feel free to continue the rehash the same dribble that can be found on every other page of this thread.

You should be a sports analyst.

[1yrdandacloudofdust]

Prove it.

How about all of those ints in the playoffs and his qbr says he's not the best.

[braveheartcolt]

How about all of those ints in the playoffs and his qbr says he's not the best.

QBR? Wow. You got me there. No point in debating against such genius. You win.

[rsrobinson]

You did. Post 201.

 

Who is fitter, faster, stronger and younger......15 all.

Tim Tebow was also fitter, faster, stronger and younger than Brady. Not comparing Luck to Tebow, just sayin'.

Luck needs to improve on accuracy, consistency, and decision making to be considered in any discussion of top QBs.

[braveheartcolt]

Tim Tebow was also fitter, faster, stronger and younger than Brady. Not comparing Luck to Tebow, just sayin'.

Luck needs to improve on accuracy, consistency, and decision making to be considered in any discussion of top QBs.

Or maybe if he had an o-line like Tom?

[amfootball]

Or maybe if he had an o-line like Tom?

Tom was sacked more then Luck last year.

[braveheartcolt]

Tom was sacked more then Luck last year.

Yep, because he is aging and slow, and is losing his skills.

[amfootball]

Yep, because he is aging and slow, and is losing his skills.

 Good one. But I don't think Brady from ten years ago was any faster then Brady now.

[lennymoore24]

WAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAY too premature  to put Luck in that Top 5 list.  Are we forgetting his interception rant in the playoffs?  He lower completion percentage?I love the guy and I think he will at some time be considered the best QB in the NFL.  I just don't see that happen for 2-3 more years.

[thedude]

Feel free to continue the rehash the same dribble

It's drivel, not "dribble".

[AntonMcG]

It's drivel, not "dribble".

A well observed grammatical pickup for someone incapable of taking on board basic concepts of an argument without making the exact same points over and over.

Good luck with you silly internet trolling. Hope you have fun.

[AntonMcG]

Tom was sacked more then Luck last year.

Luck was pressured much more. It's not his fault he is wonderful at avoiding sacks.

He is not Brady-level yet though.