Jump to content
Indianapolis Colts
Indianapolis Colts Fan Forum

Polian's FA rankings


adfisher870

Recommended Posts

I'm not an insider.. Too bad, i would like to see what he thinks

Sorry about that forgot I was to be honest....his top 10 are Flacco, Steven Jackson, Wes welker, Mike Wallace, Martellus Bennett,Jared Cook, Greg Jones, Adam Levitre, Ryan Clady and Sebastian Vollmer.

 

 

Maybe its just me but I'll trust Polian on skill postition players but when it comes to O-line he doesnt exactly have a great track record I'm kind of leery on his analysis 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Sorry about that forgot I was to be honest....his top 10 are Flacco, Steven Jackson, Wes welker, Mike Wallace, Martellus Bennett,Jared Cook, Greg Jones, Adam Levitre, Ryan Clady and Sebastian Vollmer.

 

 

Maybe its just me but I'll trust Polian on skill postition players but when it comes to O-line he doesnt exactly have a great track record I'm kind of leery on his analysis 

 

 

 

Yeah I would be interested on what he says about skill guys, but beyond that I don't really care what he has to say. O-line and defense were not exactly his forte.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Sorry about that forgot I was to be honest....his top 10 are Flacco, Steven Jackson, Wes welker, Mike Wallace, Martellus Bennett,Jared Cook, Greg Jones, Adam Levitre, Ryan Clady and Sebastian Vollmer.

 

 

Maybe its just me but I'll trust Polian on skill postition players but when it comes to O-line he doesnt exactly have a great track record I'm kind of leery on his analysis 

the top 10 is just offense here is the defensive top 10 according to him....Henry Melton, Randy Starks, Anthony Spencer, Cliff Avril Dwight Freeney, Michael Johnson, Paul Kruger, Ray Malauga, Brent Grimes, and Cary Williams

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Sorry about that forgot I was to be honest....his top 10 are Flacco, Steven Jackson, Wes welker, Mike Wallace, Martellus Bennett,Jared Cook, Greg Jones, Adam Levitre, Ryan Clady and Sebastian Vollmer.

 

 

Maybe its just me but I'll trust Polian on skill postition players but when it comes to O-line he doesnt exactly have a great track record I'm kind of leery on his analysis 

 

That's actually not his top-10....   those are his top offensive players.   He's got a top defensive players as well.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

the top 10 is just offense here is the defensive top 10 according to him....Henry Melton, Randy Starks, Anthony Spencer, Cliff Avril Dwight Freeney, Michael Johnson, Paul Kruger, Ray Malauga, Brent Grimes, and Cary Williams

 

 

 

Out of those guys I would like....

 

Spencer - would be a great fit to replace Freeney

Kruger - also good to replace Freeney, but is seeking way too much money IMO.

Grimes

Williams - I like him more than Grimes because of his size and physicality.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Honestly, I was somewhat embarrassed about his list....

 

Steven Jackson and Dwight Freeney on his "A" list of FA's.    Really?    I mean, come on.

 

I'm not saying they're unworthy of offers,  but top offers as his "A" list says they'll get?     No.

 

He also didn't have Vazquez, the San Diego guard on any list,  A, B or C.    I hope it's an oversight.

 

These aren't my only objections,  but just a small sample of what I think is a poorly thought through list....

 

Just my two cents....   (and perhaps not worth that much!)       :thmup:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Honestly, I was somewhat embarrassed about his list....

 

Steven Jackson and Dwight Freeney on his "A" list of FA's.    Really?    I mean, come on.

 

I'm not saying they're unworthy of offers,  but top offers as his "A" list says they'll get?     No.

 

He also didn't have Vazquez, the San Diego guard on any list,  A, B or C.    I hope it's an oversight.

 

These aren't my only objections,  but just a small sample of what I think is a poorly thought through list....

 

Just my two cents....   (and perhaps not worth that much!)       :thmup:

 

 

Well Polian didn't have Vasquez on his list because he's absolutely terrible at judging O-line talent. Like I said earlier, if its not a skill position, Polian doesn't have much credibility IMO.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Honestly, I was somewhat embarrassed about his list....

Steven Jackson and Dwight Freeney on his "A" list of FA's. Really? I mean, come on.

I'm not saying they're unworthy of offers, but top offers as his "A" list says they'll get? No.

He also didn't have Vazquez, the San Diego guard on any list, A, B or C. I hope it's an oversight.

These aren't my only objections, but just a small sample of what I think is a poorly thought through list....

Just my two cents.... (and perhaps not worth that much!) :thmup:

Freeney will get big money from a team running a 4-3

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Freeney will get big money from a team running a 4-3

 

Not sure why.....

 

He hasn't performed like a big money player for several years....   and he's well past 30...     bad combination for someone seeking big money.

 

Maybe he'll get it,  but not from a team where I'm the GM.   

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Not sure why.....

He hasn't performed like a big money player for several years.... and he's well past 30... bad combination for someone seeking big money.

Maybe he'll get it, but not from a team where I'm the GM.

The four years before moving to a 3-4 he had 42 sacks and 12 forced fumbles. He is 33, not "well past 30".

And what team do you GM?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Not sure why.....

 

He hasn't performed like a big money player for several years....   and he's well past 30...     bad combination for someone seeking big money.

 

Maybe he'll get it,  but not from a team where I'm the GM.   

 

If your saying you no way Jose , then I'm agreeing with you disagreeing. I guess the 1st thing to do would be to qualify what is considered "big money." I would say 20-21 mill for three years with around 10-11 guaranteed would qualify . I think he get's something like 2 years at 9 mill.... around 4 guaranted.  Plus maybe an mill reachable in incentives. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

The four years before moving to a 3-4 he had 42 sacks and 12 forced fumbles. He is 33, not "well past 30".

And what team do you GM?

 

What Freeney did this year was troublesome.   It wasn't just that he was a bad fit in the system.   He also had trouble staying healthy.     And In football terms, 33 is well past 30.  Especially for a lineman.   About the only position it's not, is quarterback, and even then....   When you're past 30,  you can grow old very, very fast.

 

The expression "not any team where I'm the GM" is just that....   an expression.   It means in my opinion.   That's all.   Nothing more.    Sorry for the confusion....

Link to comment
Share on other sites

What Freeney did this year was troublesome.   It wasn't just that he was a bad fit in the system.   He also had trouble staying healthy.     And In football terms, 33 is well past 30.  Especially for a lineman.   About the only position it's not, is quarterback, and even then....   When you're past 30,  you can grow old very, very fast.

 

The expression "not any team where I'm the GM" is just that....   an expression.   It means in my opinion.   That's all.   Nothing more.    Sorry for the confusion....

 

 

That is especially true when your game is predicated on speed. The first thing to go for a player that depends on it the most for their success.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Why do I care about Polian's views on free agency?? He barely EVER dabbled in it.

 

 

 

When he first arrived , he was a big player. Then he started handing out record contracts for all the players he wanted to keep. Not that I'm blamimg him... you over pay to keep your best players just as you do when signing the high priority free agents. Just makig the point that he more than dabbled when he first came over from Carolina.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I agree with Cary williams he has a grit to him he fights for position on every play he is very vocal and passionate about winning !! I would be fine with grimes as well he is super good just comming of an injury scares me

Problem is he likes to fight referees as well.. He has suspension written all over him

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
  • Popular Now

  • Thread of the Week

  • Topics

  • Posts

    • With all the young gunslingers in our division  you may be pretty happy with the Latu pick if he’s planting them in the ground!  IMO we need a boost at Edge. Paye just hasn’t lived up to expectations.
    • Bills are gonna draft, with first draft pick of day 2, either McConkey or Mitchell.   Maybe, they'll surprise and pick another WR but past few draft selections show that different teams have different WRs at the top order of their draft board. 
    • Dane Brugler's profile on Latu in his draft guide:   3. LAIATU LATU | UCLA 6046 | 259 lbs. | 5SR Sacramento, Calif. (Jesuit) 12/31/2000 (age 23.32) #15   BACKGROUND: Laiatu (lay-AH-too) Latu (LAH-too), the oldest of four children (two boys and two girls), grew up in Sacramento. He was a do-everything athlete throughout childhood, playing baseball, basketball, football, soccer and rugby. Latu enrolled at Jesuit High School, a privat e Catholic school in the Sacramento suburb of Carmichael and played on the JV team as a 150-pound freshman. After adding weight and moving up to varsity as a sophomore, he flourished as a pass-rushing linebacker in the team’s 3-4 scheme. As a junior, Latu posted 65 tackles, 17 tackles for loss and 12 sacks, leading the program to 10 wins and earning first team AllMetro honors. As a seniorin 2018, he recorded 94 tackles and 29.5 tackles for loss to earn first team All-State and All-League. Latu finished his varsity career with 178 tackles, 50.5 tackles for loss and 27 sacks, adding 356 receiving yards as a tight end and 476 punting yards on special teams. Latu also lettered in rugby (his main love) and led the program to national championships in 2017 and 2019. He considered playing professional rugby overseas after high school.   A four-star recruit, Latu was the No. 6 weakside defensive end in the 2019 recruiting class and the No. 20 recruit in California (No. 3 pass rusher in the state behind 2022 draft picks Kayvon Thibodeaux and Drake Jackson). He started getting noticed as a recruit during his junior year and picked up his first offer (Oregon State). Latu later added offers from Alabama, Notre Dame and Tennessee, but he wanted to stay on the West Coast. He had a final five of Ca l, Oregon, UCLA, USC and Washington and signed with the Huskies in December 2018. Latu was the No. 3 recruit in Washington’s 2019 class behind Puka Nacua and Trent McDuffie. After playing a reserve role as a true freshman, he suffered a serious neck injury during practice before the 2020 season and was forced to medically retire in the spring of 2021. He stayed close to the Huskies program as a student assistant during the 2021 season, and a year after his injury, he saw a specialist (the same doctor who performed Peyton Manning’s neck surgery) and was medically cleared. He played rugby during his rehab and was offered a contract by the professional Seattle Seawolves rugby team, but he didn’t want to give up on his football dream.   Looking for a fresh start, he entered the transfer portal in November 2021. Ikaika Malloe, whom Latu considers a “father figu re,” was his position coach at Washington and left for the UCLA coaching staff in December 2021. Malloe recommended Latu to coach Chip Kelly,and Latu joined the Bruins in January 2022. In April 2022, Latu was officially cleared and put the pads back on that summer for the first time in almost two years. His younger brother (Keleki) played tight end at California (2021-22) before transferring to Nevada for the 2023 season. Latu opted out of the 2023 bowl game and accepted his invitation to the 2024 Senior Bowl.   STRENGTHS: Crafty, punctual pass rusher … owns a master’s degree in cross-chop maneuvers (his go-to move is a Euro chop) … fast, strong hands for effective armovers, ghost moves and quick sheds … bursts off the snap with body flexibility to corner at the top of rush … hits the turbo button after clearing the outside shoulder ofthe blocker … uses a filthy jab step to shorten the edge and displays an innate feel for creating rush angles … plays with a ton of energy and feet are never stagnant … stays balanced through contact and is accustomed to seeing extra attention … quick eyes/reads lead to line-of-scrimmage stops in the run game … always rallying to the football and pursing to the perimeter … rugby (his favorite sport) developed his toughness and aggression on the football field (turned down a professional rugby career in the Premiership in England) … flagged only once in 2023 (offsides) … heads-up player when zone dropping to find passing lanes … notched two interceptions in 2023, and NFL scouts say UCLA coaches believe he would have been their best tight end had they played him on offense … didn’t miss a game the past two seasons after his medical retirement in 2021 … highly determined and doesn’t waste an ounce of talent (Chip Kelly: “He works really hard at his craft.”) … productive college resume and led the team in sacks, tackles for loss and pressures in both of seasons at UCLA.   WEAKNESSES: Below-average arm length by NFL standards … tends to play tall versus the run and needs to be more consistent controlling the point of attack … must better anticipate outside design to contain runs to his side … more of a hug-and-drag tackler and needs toclean up his misses (had at least one missed tackle in every 2023 tape studied) … injury history will be scrutinized by NFL teams after two-and-a-half years away from football — suffered a neck injury in practice (November 2020) that created numbness and required surgery; after consulting several specialists, Latu was forced to medically retire i n the spring of 2021, but he kept his dreams alive and transferred to UCLA (January 2022), where he was cleared before the 2022 season … started only one season in college (although he played starterlevel snaps in 2022).   SUMMARY: A one-year starter at UCLA, Latu was an outside edge rusher in former defensive coordinator D’Anton Lynn’s scheme, splitting his time standing up and rushing with his hand on the ground (was also schemed inside at times). Medically rejected at Washington, he was cleared by doctors after transferring to UCLA and was extremely productive over the past two seasons,with 129 total pressures in 25 games. After leading the FBS in tackles for loss in 2023, the consensus AllAmerican cleaned up on the awards circuit as a senior, taking home the Morris Trophy (best DL in Pac-12), Ted Hendricks Award (top DE in FBS) and Lombardi Award (top OL/DL in FBS). For pass rushers, there is a saying: “Beat the hands, beat the man.” Latu lives by this principle with the cohesive way he weaponizes his hands and feet to defeat blocks (led the FBS with a 24.6 percent passrush win percentage in 2023). As a run defender, his lack of ideal length and pop will show at times, but he made significant improvements with his read/react in this area as a senior. Overall, Latu’s medical history will play a major part in his draft grade, but he is a passrush technician with the instinctive feel and athletic bend to be an impactful “two-way go” rusher in the NFL. His play style and journey are reminiscent of Miami Dolphins 2021 first-rounder Jaelan Phillips.   GRADE: 1st-2nd Round (No. 22 overall)  
  • Members

×
×
  • Create New...