Colts Fan Favorites (All Time) Brackett (Round 1)

[Andy]

Decided to do this (not just for this site

). It's a bracket. You pick the players that are/were your favorite and I'll mark it down and in a week, we'll tally the scores and make the 2nd round. The way you vote is you can either write (1. Peyton Manning, 2 Johnny Unitas, 30. Quinton Coryatt, 4. Reggie Wayne... etc) or you can reply to this and bold the ones that you like. Either or is fine.

Have fun!

1. Peyton Manning (QB)

vs

32. Jack Trudeau (QB)

2. Johnny Unitas (QB)

vs

31. Duane Bickett (LB)

3. Marvin Harrison (WR)

vs

30. Quinton Coryatt (LB)

4. Reggie Wayne (WR)

vs

29. Lydell Mitchell (RB)

5. Jeff Saturday ©

vs

28. Sean Dawkins (WR)

6. Jim Irsay (Owner)

vs

27. Dominic Rhodes (RB)

7. Tony Dungy (Coach)

vs

26. Alan Ameche (RB)

8. Jim Harbaugh (QB)

vs

25. Raymond Berry (WR)

9. Dwight Freeney (DE)

vs

24. Art Donovan (DE)

10. Tony Siragusa (DT)

vs

23. Ken Dilger (TE)

11. Robert Mathis (DE)

vs

22. Bert Jones (QB)

12. Ted Marchibroda (Coach)

vs

21. John Mackey (TE)

13. Bill Brooks (WR)

vs

20. Marshall Faulk (RB)

14. Chris Hinton (OT)

vs

19. Dallas Clark (TE)

15. Robert Irsay (Owner)

vs

18. Tarik Glenn (OT)

16. Eric Dickerson (RB)

vs

17. Lenny Moore (RB)

[FireJimCaldwell]

Decided to do this (not just for this site

). It's a bracket. You pick the players that are/were your favorite and I'll mark it down and in a week, we'll tally the scores and make the 2nd round. The way you vote is you can either write (1. Peyton Manning, 2 Johnny Unitas, 30. Quinton Coryatt, 4. Reggie Wayne... etc) or you can reply to this and bold the ones that you like. Either or is fine.

Have fun!

1. Peyton Manning (QB)

31. Duane Bickett (LB)

3. Marvin Harrison (WR)

4. Reggie Wayne (WR)

5. Jeff Saturday ©

27. Dominic Rhodes (RB)

7. Tony Dungy (Coach)

8. Jim Harbaugh (QB)

9. Dwight Freeney (DE)

10. Tony Siragusa (DT)

11. Robert Mathis (DE)

12. Ted Marchibroda (Coach)

20. Marshall Faulk (RB)

19. Dallas Clark (TE)

18. Tarik Glenn (OT)

16. Eric Dickerson (RB)

Could care less about Baltimore.

[WeSpy]

1. Peyton Manning (QB)

vs

32. Jack Trudeau (QB)

2. Johnny Unitas (QB)

vs

31. Duane Bickett (LB)

3. Marvin Harrison (WR)

vs

30. Quinton Coryatt (LB)

4. Reggie Wayne (WR)

vs

29. Lydell Mitchell (RB)

5. Jeff Saturday ©

vs

28. Sean Dawkins (WR)

6. Jim Irsay (Owner)

vs

27. Dominic Rhodes (RB)

7. Tony Dungy (Coach)

vs

26. Alan Ameche (RB)

8. Jim Harbaugh (QB)

vs

25. Raymond Berry (WR)

9. Dwight Freeney (DE)

vs

24. Art Donovan (DE)

10. Tony Siragusa (DT)

vs

23. Ken Dilger (TE)

11. Robert Mathis (DE)

vs

22. Bert Jones (QB)

12. Ted Marchibroda (Coach)

vs

21. John Mackey (TE)

13. Bill Brooks (WR)

vs

20. Marshall Faulk (RB)

14. Chris Hinton (OT)

vs

19. Dallas Clark (TE)

15. Robert Irsay (Owner)

vs

18. Tarik Glenn (OT)

16. Eric Dickerson (RB)

vs

17. Lenny Moore (RB)

[MTC]

1. Peyton Manning (QB)

vs

32. Jack Trudeau (QB)

2. Johnny Unitas (QB)

vs

31. Duane Bickett (LB)

3. Marvin Harrison (WR)

vs

30. Quinton Coryatt (LB)

4. Reggie Wayne (WR)

vs

29. Lydell Mitchell (RB)

5. Jeff Saturday ©

vs

28. Sean Dawkins (WR)

6. Jim Irsay (Owner)

vs

27. Dominic Rhodes (RB)

7. Tony Dungy (Coach)

vs

26. Alan Ameche (RB)

8. Jim Harbaugh (QB)

vs

25. Raymond Berry (WR)

9. Dwight Freeney (DE)

vs

24. Art Donovan (DE)

10. Tony Siragusa (DT)

vs

23. Ken Dilger (TE)

11. Robert Mathis (DE)

vs

22. Bert Jones (QB)

12. Ted Marchibroda (Coach)

vs

21. John Mackey (TE)

13. Bill Brooks (WR)

vs

20. Marshall Faulk (RB)

14. Chris Hinton (OT)

vs

19. Dallas Clark (TE)

15. Robert Irsay (Owner)

vs

18. Tarik Glenn (OT)

16. Eric Dickerson (RB)

vs

17. Lenny Moore (RB)

[CR91]

no bethea

[Smonroe]

1. Peyton Manning (QB)

2. Johnny Unitas (QB)

3. Marvin Harrison (WR)

4. Reggie Wayne (WR)

5. Jeff Saturday ©

6. Jim Irsay

7. Tony Dungy (Coach)

25. Raymond Berry (WR)

24. Art Donovan (DE)

10. Tony Siragusa (DT)

22. Bert Jones (QB)

21. John Mackey (TE)

20. Marshall Faulk (RB)

19. Dallas Clark (TE)

18. Tarik Glenn (OT)

17. Lenny Moore (RB)

[Nobody]

I have Madden 08 that I play on 'Franchise Mode' and I'm currently in year 2025.

I hate to tell you, but not only did he not show up in the draft in 2012, but he hasn't shown up at all.

© that's how you make a copyright sign, gonna be using that.

[GOCOLTS_ROLLTIDE]

EDGERRINN JAMES!!!!! 32

[GOCOLTS_ROLLTIDE]

has to atleast be top 5 imo

[Andy]

EDGERRINN JAMES!!!!! 32

Arguable, could have definitely been on there. Probably wouldn't changed the list drastically, or even make it out of the first round.

Can you please vote!!

[FireJimCaldwell]

James would easily be top 5.

Sanders, Stokley, Pollard, Clark.... All more deserving than the Baltimore Colts, or some of the ones up there...

Contest has been tainted.

It deserves to wear the Patriots logo.

If anything I'd prefer my vote to eliminated after seeing how many names have been left off.

[Andy]

James would easily be top 5.

Sanders, Stokley, Pollard, Clark.... All more deserving than the Baltimore Colts, or some of the ones up there...

Contest has been tainted.

It deserves to wear the Patriots logo.

If anything I'd prefer my vote to eliminated after seeing how many names have been left off.

Come on, don't be stubborn and immature.

I don't want to start a whole new 25,000 word argument like we did a couple of months, but you have to realize that the players from the Balimore Colts days are legends and were dearly loved by the fans back then.

Yes, leaving Edge off was a little silly, but let's be honest, it doesn't make the biggest difference. I would have put him at 11 or 12 and he would have been against Marshall or Dilger.

Oh and Clark is on it... Pollard and Stokely don't deserve to be on it. I see that you are clearly a 2000's Colts fan.

Let's not be crazy people...

[FireJimCaldwell]

Come on, don't be immature.

I don't want to start a whole new 25,000 word argument like we did a couple of months, but you have to realize that the players from the Balimore Colts days are legends are were dearly loved by the fans back then.

Yes, leaving Edge off was a little silly, but let's be honest, it doesn't make the biggest difference. I would have put him at 11 or 12 and he would have been against Marshall or Dilger.

Oh and Clark is on it... Pollard and Stokely don't deserve to be on it. I see that you are clearly a 2000's Colts fan.

Let's not be crazy people...

No arguments necessary and I'm not being immature. To me it's an invalid list and I want no part of it.

No, I'm not a 2000's colts fan, but I am not a Baltimore Colts fan. But to have some of the those names up there when Edgerrin James isn't. Yet Rhodes is?

It's called commonsense...

End of discussion.

[Andy]

No arguments necessary and I'm not being immature. To me it's an invalid list and I want no part of it.

No, I'm not a 2000's colts fan, but I am not a Baltimore Colts fan. But to have some of the those names up there when Edgerrin James isn't. Yet Rhodes is?

It's called commonsense...

End of discussion.

Fine, if it's really bothering you so much, because one player was left off this list and some old living legends were left on, then fine don't vote.

Badger me all you want for leaving Edge off it, but it doesn't make a big difference.

Invalid list? You're funny.

[Andy]

WE NEED MORE VOTES!!! I have to have more than 400 by weeks end and I'm expected quite a bit of them from here!!

[jvan1973]

Let me tell you how this ends..

Peyton manning wins

[Andy]

Let me tell you how this ends..

Peyton manning wins

We did one a few years ago and he didn't win.

[jvan1973]

How does dom and dickerson make the top 32 but no edge.. And quinton coryatt and no Jeff Herrod? Im pretty sure bob irsay will also receive no votes. and why are 2 owners and a coach on a list of favorite players?

[Andy]

How does dom and dickerson make the top 32 but no edge.. And quinton coryatt and no Jeff Herrod? Im pretty sure bob irsay will also receive no votes. and why are 2 owners and a coach on a list of favorite players?

We already went over Edge, a slip up and he wasn't on the list. I don't think he makes a huge difference. You guys seem to care a lot, so I'll redo the brackett.

This isn't a players list. It just says players, but I meant to say people. I thought people would understand the difference.

MOD TAKE DOWN THIS THREAD, SO I CAN RECREATE IT!!

[jvan1973]

Decided to do this (not just for this site

). It's a bracket. You pick the players that are/were your favorite and I'll mark it down and in a week, we'll tally the scores and make the 2nd round. The way you vote is you can either write (1. Peyton Manning, 2 Johnny Unitas, 30. Quinton Coryatt, 4. Reggie Wayne... etc) or you can reply to this and bold the ones that you like. Either or is fine.

Have fun!

1. Peyton Manning (QB)

vs

32. Jack Trudeau (QB)

2. Johnny Unitas (QB)

vs

31. Duane Bickett (LB)

3. Marvin Harrison (WR)

vs

30. Quinton Coryatt (LB)

4. Reggie Wayne (WR)

vs

29. Lydell Mitchell (RB)

5. Jeff Saturday ©

vs

28. Sean Dawkins (WR)

6. Jim Irsay (Owner)

vs

27. Dominic Rhodes (RB)

7. Tony Dungy (Coach)

vs

26. Alan Ameche (RB)

8. Jim Harbaugh (QB)

vs

25. Raymond Berry (WR)

9. Dwight Freeney (DE)

vs

24. Art Donovan (DE)

10. Tony Siragusa (DT)

vs

23. Ken Dilger (TE)

11. Robert Mathis (DE)

vs

22. Bert Jones (QB)

12. Ted Marchibroda (Coach)

vs

21. John Mackey (TE)

13. Bill Brooks (WR)

vs

20. Marshall Faulk (RB)

14. Chris Hinton (OT)

vs

19. Dallas Clark (TE)

15. Robert Irsay (Owner)

vs

18. Tarik Glenn (OT)

16. Eric Dickerson (RB)

vs

17. Lenny Moore (RB)

[Warhorse]

Why would you put Brooks against Faulk and Mathis against Jones in round one? To me that is like putting Manning against Unitas right off the bat. Like the thread though.

1. Peyton Manning (QB)

2. Johnny Unitas (QB)

3. Marvin Harrison (WR)

29. Lydell Mitchell (RB)

5. Jeff Saturday ©

6. Jim Irsay (Owner)

7. Tony Dungy (Coach)

25. Raymond Berry (WR)

9. Dwight Freeney (DE)

10. Tony Siragusa (DT)

11. Robert Mathis (DE)

21. John Mackey (TE)

13. Bill Brooks (WR)

19. Dallas Clark (TE)

18. Tarik Glenn (OT)

16. Eric Dickerson (RB)

[Andy]

EVERYONE:

I DID THIS WAY TOO QUICKLY, WHICH LED TO SOME ERRORS.

I'LL FIX THEM AND MAKE A NEW THREAD IN THE UPCOMING DAYS.

Sorry for the useless thread,

Andy

[ReMeDy]

lol oh well. I'd post a facepalm pic, but I'm sure we've seen it a million times

[ConBro]

Decided to do this (not just for this site

). It's a bracket. You pick the players that are/were your favorite and I'll mark it down and in a week, we'll tally the scores and make the 2nd round. The way you vote is you can either write (1. Peyton Manning, 2 Johnny Unitas, 30. Quinton Coryatt, 4. Reggie Wayne... etc) or you can reply to this and bold the ones that you like. Either or is fine.

Have fun!

1. Peyton Manning (QB)

vs

32. Jack Trudeau (QB)

2. Johnny Unitas (QB)

vs

31. Duane Bickett (LB)

3. Marvin Harrison (WR)

vs

30. Quinton Coryatt (LB)

4. Reggie Wayne (WR)

vs

29. Lydell Mitchell (RB)

5. Jeff Saturday ©

vs

28. Sean Dawkins (WR)

6. Jim Irsay (Owner)

vs

27. Dominic Rhodes (RB)

7. Tony Dungy (Coach)

vs

26. Alan Ameche (RB)

8. Jim Harbaugh (QB)

vs

25. Raymond Berry (WR)

9. Dwight Freeney (DE)

vs

24. Art Donovan (DE)

10. Tony Siragusa (DT)

vs

23. Ken Dilger (TE)

11. Robert Mathis (DE)

vs

22. Bert Jones (QB)

12. Ted Marchibroda (Coach)

vs

21. John Mackey (TE)

13. Bill Brooks (WR)

vs

20. Marshall Faulk (RB)

14. Chris Hinton (OT)

vs

19. Dallas Clark (TE)

15. Robert Irsay (Owner)

vs

18. Tarik Glenn (OT)

16. Eric Dickerson (RB)

vs

17. Lenny Moore (RB)

[Coltssouth]

Closed per original posters request.

Looking forward to the new one Andy. Great topic.