mcdonald or guy

[UKColt13]

Please don't pick up Landon Collins. He's Mark Barron 2.0.

He is a reasonable hitter who gets burned in coverage.

Would rather see what McDonald has got this season and address the Dline. A good Dline can mask shortcomings in the secondary and then address it next year in the draft if we need to.

[ProblChld32]

lets assume the colts will not draft a safety and wont pick one up in free agency and either mcdonald or guy starts. can they produce as a starter at a solid level, not even saying good level, a solid level. mcdonald does have good size at 6 foot 220 and was a good contributor on STs. guy is a former starter from the jags so he does have experience. im not advocating for either one, however there arent much options left. the colts dont seem to be interested in pollard and Im really not excited about any safety in the draft. perhaps we can draft josh shaw and move him to safety

 

I agree with MTC on this one it would have to be Mcdonald for me. the Kids intangibles are great. Good Size and Speed!

[GwinnettColt]

I think they'll go with McDonald but they'll draft one, too.  Collins probably won't be there when they pick.

[lollygagger8]

I still think Pollard would be a decent pickup as long as he's cheap. 

 

 

Put him in whenever we play the NE Cheaters so he can do his thing. 

[Horse Shoe Heaven]

I want to see what MacDonald can do got a feeling about that guy! I think we draft one too somewhere in the draft.

[Superman]

I don't think either of those two players will start for us in 2015. 

[throwing BBZ]

lets assume the colts will not draft a safety and wont pick one up in free agency and either mcdonald or guy starts. can they produce as a starter at a solid level, not even saying good level, a solid level. mcdonald does have good size at 6 foot 220 and was a good contributor on STs. guy is a former starter from the jags so he does have experience. im not advocating for either one, however there arent much options left. the colts dont seem to be interested in pollard and Im really not excited about any safety in the draft. perhaps we can draft josh shaw and move him to safety

 

Yes they can both produce at a solid level. Feel better?

[IndyColtScout]

The guy we want is the safety from Louisville Gerod Holliman. He's a bigtime playmaking ballhawk.

[Gavin]

Contract years don't count, everyone does well cause you tryna get paid

All years before last season he's been hurt and when he wasn't hurt he was below average

Of course contract years count, That's ridiculous, Based on the carries he had when healthy and touches he was not below average

[BleedBlu8792]

I don't think either of those two players will start for us in 2015.

Late pick-up after camp or rookie? I'm not sure going either route is safer than the other..

[JR Indy]

At this time the Colts don't a need a ball hawk safety. The Colts need a heavy hitter. If they can get Collins that would be great. If they can't I still think there are some pretty good safeties in this draft. According to some reports Tartt (Samford) or Clayton Geathers (Central Florida) are some heavy hitters, that can be had in later rounds. When Antoine Bethea came out Nobody was talking about him at all. I think he got drafted in the 5th or 6th round and how did he turn out. With that said the Colts need a safety that will make you pay if you come in that secondary. Could McDonald do that? I don't doubt it but I would be pleasantly surprised if not shocked

[Jonathan24]

I believe the Colts will draft a safety.

 

Whether it's in the 3rd round or the 6th round I think we'll take one. 

 

If the draft ends and we have not taken a safety I'd be very surprised. 

 

I think we draft Cody Prewitt in the 3rd or 4th round...

[Farns01]

In the video section Grigson interview at the owners meeting mention guy is impressing during the off season.