Jump to content
Indianapolis Colts
Conversations are moderated for civility. We ask that you please stay on topic. For more info, see our Community Guidelines ×
Indianapolis Colts Fan Forum
Enter To Win 2 Tickets to Titans @ Colts Sun 12/22 | 1:00 PM EDT
Enter To Win 2 Tickets to Jaguars @ Colts

If Peyton Manning Leads The Colts To ___ Wins Next Season, He Deserves Unanimous Mvp

theking213

By theking213
in Colts Football

 Share

Recommended Posts

oldunclemark Walk On

oldunclemark

Posted
Posted

Has a player ever won comeback player of the year and MVP in the same season? Now that would be pretty cool

There's the post of the day....sarow...

You win two tickets to the Colts game at NE next week!!!

(Second prize was four tickets..) :mellow:

LUVTHESHOE Walk On

LUVTHESHOE

Posted
Posted

There's the post of the day....sarow...

You win two tickets to the Colts game at NE next week!!!

(Second prize was four tickets..) :mellow:

lol, I heard him say he is not even cleared to swing a golf club, I hate to say it but, I am starting think that seeing Manning yelling at coach (and i use that term loosly) for his idiodic timeout was his last act in a colts uniform, but I hope im wrong.
oldunclemark Walk On

oldunclemark

Posted
Posted

lol, I heard him say he is not even cleared to swing a golf club, I hate to say it but, I am starting think that seeing Manning yelling at coach (and i use that term loosly) for his idiodic timeout was his last act in a colts uniform, but I hope im wrong.

Holding out hop..LUV..

but I've got to admit as Dec.1 comes up....I'm worried about him not being cleared..

..and then we are in limbo until next August really...

oldunclemark Walk On

oldunclemark

Posted
Posted

Holding out hop..LUV..

but I've got to admit as Dec.1 comes up....I'm worried about him not being cleared..

..and then we are in limbo until next August really...

Actually...that's HOPE I''m holding out......(spelling is a skill)
MAC Walk On

MAC

Posted
Posted

I heard him say he is not even cleared to swing a golf club,

One of the announcers mentioned this in the broadcast multiple times with disbelief, as if swinging a golf club was trivial. I really don't understand.

I'm not a golfer, but it seems to me that swinging a golf club involves leveraging nearly every muscle in your body, while going through an extremely wide range of motion. As someone who had the same surgery as Peyton, I'm fairly confident that swinging a golf club with any kind of torque would be significantly more challenging than throwing a football.

If he comes back next year and the Colts make the playoffs, he will be in the MVP conversation for much of the year - but if someone is having a year like Rodgers is having this year, they will be hard to ignore. Now if he is having a comparable year to the other candidates, I would think that "the tie goes to the person whose team was horrendous without him".

LUVTHESHOE Walk On

LUVTHESHOE

Posted
Posted

One of the announcers mentioned this in the broadcast multiple times with disbelief, as if swinging a golf club was trivial. I really don't understand.

I'm not a golfer, but it seems to me that swinging a golf club involves leveraging nearly every muscle in your body, while going through an extremely wide range of motion. As someone who had the same surgery as Peyton, I'm fairly confident that swinging a golf club with any kind of torque would be significantly more challenging than throwing a football.

If he comes back next year and the Colts make the playoffs, he will be in the MVP conversation for much of the year - but if someone is having a year like Rodgers is having this year, they will be hard to ignore. Now if he is having a comparable year to the other candidates, I would think that "the tie goes to the person whose team was horrendous without him".

Yes but your head and neck are the only two things you don't move in a golf swing, until the follow thru.
CCH Walk On

CCH

Posted
Posted

If we win 10 next year it's guaranteed he wins MVP. Heck, maybe even 9-7 would win it for him if the numbers are there.

Zachris Walk On

Zachris

Posted
Posted

If we win 10 next year it's guaranteed he wins MVP. Heck, maybe even 9-7 would win it for him if the numbers are there.

With the easy schedule we should get next year, we should have at least 12 wins! :)

supremecoltsfan300 Walk On

supremecoltsfan300

Posted
Posted

The thing about the schedule is that it wont be muchhaasier. Chargers might end up in last place n so will the browns. Itll be like what this year was supposed to be. One hard team in the pats n one easy one in kc this year. Next year one hard in the chargers n one easy in the browns. I expect to still win a lot of games next year n i think peyton will definitely get mvp.

Andy Walk On

Andy

Posted
Posted

11, but I think even if they make the playoffs with 9 wins, he'll still win it. I think he'll be the first player in history to win the comeback player, and the MVP (who knows, maybe even the OPY)

Jason_ Hall of Famer

Jason_

Posted
Posted

If he suits up next year and plays all 16 games then he wins MVP and CPOY. Yes I'm jokingly exaggerating....but not by much.

As for the golf swing thing....I would imagine that he has not been cleared for ANY type of athletic physical activity that would involve any use or movement of the shoulders/neck/arms....including swinging a golf club, tossing a bowling ball or even playing ping pong until the fusion has completed. So yeah, the fact that he's not cleared to swing a golf club should come as a surprise imo since he's also not been cleared to throw a football.

doogansquest Walk On

doogansquest

Posted
Posted

Yes but your head and neck are the only two things you don't move in a golf swing, until the follow thru.

But you move a ton of muscles, tendons, ligaments, vascular and nerve tissue attached to the head and neck. Swinging a golf club is infinitely more strenuous on a body than throwing a football.

The phrase was poorly chosen, as if to suggest golf is "easier" than football. Which it isn't. Some math nerds at Oxford proposed convincing probability logic that shows an athlete is more likely to win 3 Super Bowls than even one of the PGA Majors.

With the easy schedule we should get next year, we should have at least 12 wins! :)

We won't have an easy schedule. The record you finish with only affects 2 games.

Xfiles Walk On

Xfiles

Posted
Posted

But you move a ton of muscles, tendons, ligaments, vascular and nerve tissue attached to the head and neck. Swinging a golf club is infinitely more strenuous on a body than throwing a football.

The phrase was poorly chosen, as if to suggest golf is "easier" than football. Which it isn't. Some math nerds at Oxford proposed convincing probability logic that shows an athlete is more likely to win 3 Super Bowls than even one of the PGA Majors.

We won't have an easy schedule. The record you finish with only affects 2 games.

I believe its four since the Colts only have 3 other divisional teams. 6 divisional games. I could be wrong though, its happend many times. :)

I think if the colts were to finish 8-8 or better next year with a healthy Peyton at the Helm, he is undeniably the MVP again, and its no longer an argument who the greatest QB of all time is......Good Lord I hope that doesnt spark an out of control debate!! :(

MAC Walk On

MAC

Posted
Posted

I believe its four since the Colts only have 3 other divisional teams. 6 divisional games. I could be wrong though, its happend many times. :)

I think if the colts were to finish 8-8 or better next year with a healthy Peyton at the Helm, he is undeniably the MVP again, and its no longer an argument who the greatest QB of all time is......Good Lord I hope that doesnt spark an out of control debate!! :(

I'm sure that we'll all welcome an out of control debate if it means that Peyton is in top form again. :smile:

Yeah, it's two games. You play 6 in your division, 4 against an entire in-conference division, 4 against an entire other-conference division, and two games against the two other teams who finished in the same position as you in the other two divisions. I'm pretty sure that we play the NFC north next year (which might well be harder than playing the NFC south like we did this year - particularly if we end up on the road to Chicago or Green Bay after the weather turns), and I'm pretty sure that we play the AFC east next year, which may be a little bit easier than playing the AFC North like we did this year, unless - same problem - we end up on the road at Buffalo or New England or New York after the weather turns. It's way too early to tell whether that will be an easier schedule or not, but without the NFC west or AFC west in sight, there isn't likely to be a whole lot of difference.

So the two extra games are going to be Cleveland (who we probably walk over if Peyton plays), and either KC or SD (who would probably still find a way to beat us even if they were losing to everyone else.

Bottom line, I wouldn't count on an easy schedule next year. Although after a year like this, it's hard to view ANY opponent without trepidation.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
 Share
Go to topic listing

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...