how many colts make the top 100

[CR91]

id say luck mathis and hilton. anyone think reggie gets in just by rep

[sfergson727]

T-Rich.

[sfergson727]

Seriously though, Luck and Mathis are good bets, and probably the only ones even though Reggie does deserve it.

[ColtsFanMikeC]

The top 100 of all time?  Or the top 100 of today?

[CR91]

The top 100 of all time?  Or the top 100 of today?

 

you know the top 100 that they do every year once the season is over

[mintor]

21 Reggie Wayne ,

 

23 Andrew luck .

 

71 Trent Richardson

 

78 Robert Mathis

 

 

[ColtsFanMikeC]

Mathis and Luck should both be in the top 20. 

 

I think Vontae Davis has a case for a spot in the 65+ range and TY, too.

[Bluefire4]

Luck, Mathis, Hilton, maybe Freeman. Do they include K/P?

[21isSuperman]

Freeman should make it, but won't

[Gibbons180]

Mathis, Luck, I could definitely see T.Y Hilton, possibly Vontae, I think he earned it. and if we want to really push it possibly gosder cherilus. great great tackle. Freeman should be on there, but he got snubbed from the probowl so im not sure if theyd do the same thing with the top 100. he should be though.

[GoColts8818]

Mathis, Luck and MAYBE Hilton. 

[jameszeigler834]

The top 100 of all time?  Or the top 100 of today?

the top 100 is crap anyway.

[RealityIsLuck]

Luck, Mathis, Vontae. Possibly T.Y I would hope because of his play when it mattered most (v.s. KC when probably the most of the nation was watching)

 

I wish Freeman wasn't so damn underrated. He definitely should be top 60 but unfortunately he gets no attention when he should.

[Dark_Indy]

Mathis Freeman Luck Hilton

 

In that order.

 

Mathis will be top 10

Freeman top 40

Luck will be midfield

Hilton will be 80's

[Can'tStandYa]

Luck, Mathis, Hilton, maybe Freeman. Do they include K/P?

Would you include a kicker or a punter in your top 100 players in the nfl this year??

[CCH]

Mathis in the teens

Luck in the 30's

TY in the 60's

Freeman in the 90's

Maybe McAfee sneaks in there being the best punter in the league, but who knows

[Dark_Indy]

Would you include a kicker or a punter in your top 100 players in the nfl this year??

 

Matt Prater at #100

[Can'tStandYa]

Matt Prater at #100

If that's the case justin tucker is 99.

[Bluefire4]

Would you include a kicker or a punter in your top 100 players in the nfl this year??

.. No. 

[BPM_Colt]

Luck, Mathis, Hilton, and maybe Vontae

[IndyTrav]

2...maaaaaybe 3 with Vonte....

 

Mathis/Luck somewhere in the top 30...Vonte maybe but dunno where....

 

As much as we Colts fans love Hilton, Im not sure he even gets consideration. 20th in rec, 18th in yards, 40th in TDs......not good enough for the list IMO

[kjyb]

 

21 Reggie Wayne ,

 

23 Andrew luck .

 

71 Trent Richardson

 

78 Robert Mathis

 

 

 

thats was last year.. this year should be mathis 7 andrew luck 12 vontae davis 70 ty hilton 40 

[Indygal1218]

Luck, Mathis, Hilton.

Wayne and Freeman are good candidates, but unlikely to be voted in IMO.

Since it's a "player's only" popularity contest, it's tough to say.

[coltsfanatic24]

13. Mathis

 

27. Luck

 

Hilton will make it next year

[IndyTrav]

Looking at last yrs list, I see 17WR (although Jacoby Jones made it, weak sauce):

 

I think WR who should easily make it ahead of TY.

 

Calvin, AJ, Marshall, Jeffery, Gordon, Brown, Andre, DT, Welker, Decker, Dez, Boldin, Fitz, Julio, Pierre, Desean, Jordy, Cruz...thats 18, so I guess its possible TY makes it, but its gonna be in the 90s....