Why I like Luck more than Manning

[BPM_Colt]

Manning was always great in the 2 minute drill. I would say that was one of the most exciting moments in sports when 18 would have the ball with 1:45 and a timeout left. I don't know how anyone could say he wasn't great in the 2 min drill. If he does take a knee, I'm sure Manning is disagreeing with the call 9 out of 10 times

[oldunclemark]

I like Luck more than Manning right now because of the uniform he wears

That's the correct answer, 'A'

[Warhorse]

Why I like Luck more than Manning...........

 

 

ummm..........that is as awkward and as dysfunctional as saying why I like my Dad more than my mom.

[Robert Johnson]

I like Luck more than Manning right now because of the uniform he wears

That says it all,Luck is our guy now.

[jskinnz]

Both are incredible QBs, The biggest aspect for me is Luck's ability to score points in the final minutes of the half. He's done it multiple times in the year and half he's been with the Colts. He even pulled off a HUGE drive against Denver capping off with a 8 yard TD pass to Fleener.

 

This is the biggest difference. I grew weary of Manning always taking a knee with 45s left instead of driving for more points. 

 

I absolutely love that Luck always has his sights set on more points!

Sorry, but the entire premise of why you like Luck is wrong. Manning was great in two minute offense - end of game or half. Manning teams rarely took a knee and when they did, it was a coach decision and not 18's. My guess is the largest reason you like Luck is the laundry he wears.

[Wayne Carter]

it looks like Peyton is hurting when he runs. Jim made the right call going with Luck and i love the the way he diverted attention away from Andrew and the team by making those comments about Peyton leading up to the Colts/Broncos game.

[luvdacolts67]

Andrew luck is the one who Knocks!

But seriously Manning was the master of the no huddle. Lucks just learning how to points out blitzes IMO.

Ones on the colts, the other is not. That is why I like luck better.

Manning changed the way the QB position was played, Luck is playing it.

[Gavin]

Manning changed the way the QB position was played, Luck is playing it.

I hear that all the time but no one ever said or says how he changed the way the game is played, He is not the first person to call his own plays, or audible out of plays he dont like, or run the hurry up offense or confuse a defensen, Has he done it better then everyone else? yeah...probably. But I dont think he has changed how the game is played

[jvan1973]

I hear that all the time but no one ever said or says how he changed the way the game is played, He is not the first person to call his own plays, or audible out of plays he dont like, or run the hurry up offense or confuse a defensen, Has he done it better then everyone else? yeah...probably. But I dont think he has changed how the game is played

I agree, he didn't change the way the game is played. Because nobody else does what he can.

[Gavin]

I agree, he didn't change the way the game is played. Because nobody else does what he can.

depends on what ya mean

[jvan1973]

depends on what ya mean

Who does what he does at the line of scrimmage?

[Warhorse]

I think he has changed the level of expectation for QB preparation.

[Knuckles79]

Attack attack hike flag thrown to many men on the field for defense. Come on now how many did that before Peyton

[Gavin]

Who does what he does at the line of scrimmage?

Marino did if I remember right