Colts Player comparisons by members on this forum

[Boss7894]

Any Comparisons of Current Colt players to players of the past? Any random player throw their name in the mix whoever you are thinking about…  I think the closest thing to Reggie Wayne despite what he says is AD and the closest thing to Larry Fitzgerald in ceiling in what he can do is MPJR. I’ll be back, be sure to do defense guys too…

[holeymoley99]

Rodney Harrison to Cato June....

 

Ryan Kelly to Jeff Saturday...

[TheNewGuy]

 

Franklin to Brackett...different schemes but both overachievers.

 

 

[John Hammonds]

Bernard Raimann to Anthony Costanzo.  May never make a pro bowl, but solid and dependable.

[Archer]

Zaire to Gary Brackett.  Not particularly fast, not particularly big.  But boy do they make tackles!

[Stephen]

Carries a faster ej speed

[jvan1973]

Rigo and most every punter ever

[Archer]

14 hours ago, TheNewGuy said:

 

Franklin to Brackett...different schemes but both overachievers.

 

 

Sorry, I didn’t see yours before I wrote the same thing.  You got it first!

[smittywerb]

On 6/13/2024 at 11:57 PM, Boss7894 said:

Any Comparisons of Current Colt players to players of the past? Any random player throw their name in the mix whoever you are thinking about…  I think the closest thing to Reggie Wayne despite what he says is AD and the closest thing to Larry Fitzgerald in ceiling in what he can do is MPJR. I’ll be back, be sure to do defense guys too…

 

I think it’s backwards.  MPJ is definitely Reggie based on skill set and tendencies.  AD can become Marvin with his explosiveness.

 

Raimann - I think he’ll be Castonzo.  Ol reliable, underappreciated, majority won’t realize how good he was until he’s gone.

 

AD - if he becomes what we think he can, Ocho Cinco.  Cocky, competitive, but will perform his butt off and will dance every chance he gets lol

 

Jelani Woods - Jimmy Graham, fast for his size, walking mismatch.

[TheNewGuy]

7 hours ago, Archer said:

Sorry, I didn’t see yours before I wrote the same thing.  You got it first!

No sweat!  Great minds and all😉

[Fluke_33]

AR has similar if not superior physical traits of AL and I just saw something on his ability to recall is similar to PM.  

[indyagent17]

Alec Pierce to EG Green

[csmopar]

AR to Curtis Painter 

[Fluke_33]

6 hours ago, csmopar said:

AR to Curtis Painter 

that poor kid was thrown into the worst situation.   
 

Orlovsky has a special place in my fandom for saving us from the dreaded 0-fer completely defeated season. 

[indyagent17]

6 hours ago, Fluke_33 said:

that poor kid was thrown into the worst situation.   
 

Orlovsky has a special place in my fandom for saving us from the dreaded 0-fer completely defeated season. 

🤪

[CR91]

JT is the closest colts have had to Erik Dickerson. Greyhound that can truck you and still out run you