-
Recently Browsing 0 members
- No registered users viewing this page.
-
-
Thread of the Week
-
-
Topics
-
-
Posts
-
-
-
By Dark Superman · Posted
Pinter's too small and not strong enough to play guard in the NFL. He's a huge liability, and his struggles are affecting Smith and Kelly's play. Reich needs to bench Pinter ASAP. -
You are definitely right about blown blocking assignments and blown coverages. That is impossible to grade without knowing the play call. But there is a lot that can be graded and I think PFF does a decent job of giving us an idea. You can certainly grade man on man matchups on the line and things and football is at the same time way more complex and less complex than people realise. Remember that most players receive no grade on most plays. For instance a QB gets no grade on a handoff. Graders can tell coverages for the most part by looking at what everyone is doing, not necessarily the person or two involved in the play. Blocking assignments are harder to grade without the play calls. So I agree there are things that can't be graded accurately, but overall PFF gives you a pretty good ball park idea how guys are playing. Grading really isn't that hard. Anyone can do it if they are told what to look for. It's hard to collate but it's not hard to look at a guy on a play and note either ++ + 0 - -- If you are given good guidelines, most people will come up with similar grades on individual plays. -
-
-
Members
-
Recommended Posts