top 100

[CR91]

how many colts you see making it this year and where do you think they will be ranked

i say luck wayne mathis and maybe freeney. i hope freeman makes it hes ballin.

[Moncrief]

Luck, Wayne, Freeman(wishful thinking), Bethea, Redding, Mathis

[Tark The Shark]

Luck and Wayne definitely.

Honestly, I don't think anybody else will make it on the list even though Freeman probably should.

[CR91]

Luck, Wayne, Freeman(wishful thinking), Bethea, Redding, Mathis

id love for bethea to get in but its all about stats. tackles arent good enough for people. they want the exciting play the pick sixs. sacking the qb. causing fumbles.

[supremecoltsfan300]

Luck, Mathis, Wayne.

Mathis is the lowest rated (closest to 100).

Don't know where wayne and luck will fall but I'd say 70 or lower for both

[Moncrief]

id love for bethea to get in but its all about stats. tackles arent good enough for people. they want the exciting play the pick sixs. sacking the qb. causing fumbles.

I thought this was the top 100 where only NFL players choices actually matter and make the list, not the fans.

[CR91]

I thought this was the top 100 where only NFL players choices actually matter and make the list, not the fans.

it is, but how much reorganization does bethea get? to us we think bethea is having a great year because of the impact he has on our defense and we see that week in and week out but question is do other players see that? heck peyton got in at 50 last year and didnt take a snap

[Moncrief]

it is, but how much reorganization does bethea get? to us we think bethea is having a great year because of the impact he has on our defense and we see that week in and week out but question is do other players see that? heck peyton got in at 50 last year and didnt take a snap

I still think he'll get in. Maybe...

[CR91]

I still think he'll get in. Maybe...

hope your right

[CjMcGirt23]

I completely forgot about that show... but man am I looking forward to seeing it now. Players talking about Wayne incredible catching ability and Lucks ability in the clutch.

[Nobody]

It's all about hype so no chance Freeman makes it.

Probably something ridiculous that makes you wonder if they watched a single Colts game, like Freeney is 30 and nobody else makes it.

It's all about hype so no chance Freeman makes it.

Probably something ridiculous that makes you wonder if they watched a single Colts game, like Freeney is 25 and nobody else makes it.

[JustAColtsFan]

IMHO Freeman was the greatest find Grigson had. I mean where have they been hiding this young man for the past four years - oh I forgot - in the wilds of CANADA LOL.. I guess there is nothing like being stuck out in the sticks like that to make you HUNGRY GGGRRROOOWWLLLL :heh: :devil:

[Robin]

Players watch film on their opponents so people have seen how good Freeman is, I'm sure he gets in.

[Kenny]

The top 100 is a popularity contest so Freeney, Mathis, Luck, and Wayne are a lock. Freeman truly deserves it though.

[oldunclemark]

Pat MacAfee...????

Okay, maybe not

[PrincetonTiger]

Luck, Wayne, Mathis and either Freeman or Freeney

[Kyle]

the show and rankings are crap and will stay that way until they pick a way to rank.

currently they say it is the top 100 from that season.... but then guys like Manning (who didnt play last year) make the list...

Is it top players in the NFL over their career, or is it top players from the previous season? Even the people interviewed that vote on the top 100 ask that question and never get a straight answer. It is a cool idea for a show but they need to have it one way or the other.

[oldunclemark]

Andrew Luck wont make it...

..How many QBs can there be in the top 100?

Think about it

[MSColtsFan]

Andrew Luck wont make it...

..How many QBs can there be in the top 100?

Think about it

There were 12 QBs on the list in the spring of 2011, and 13 in the spring of 2012. 2011 included Donovan McNabb. 2012 included Tim Tebow (and Manning who didn't play). There's a chance Luck makes it. Cam Newton ended up 40th on the spring 2012 version, after his rookie season.

[supremecoltsfan300]

Luck should definitely make it. Let's say 13 qbs make it.

1. Manning 2. Brady 3. Rodgers 4. Brees 5. Eli 6. Ryan 7. RG3 8. Schaub 9. Cutler 10. Ben 11. Flacco 12. Dalton 13. Romo 14. Luck

I think Luck will beat out one of those 13 other qbs to make the list. If tebow made it, luck will somehow

[Peytonparker]

I think T.Y makes it