Jump to content
Indianapolis Colts
Indianapolis Colts Fan Forum

Greatest winning QB's in SB history (1966-2020 seasons) SB wins/SB Apps as a starter

2006Coltsbestever

By 2006Coltsbestever
in NFL General

Recommended Posts

2006Coltsbestever Ring of Honor

2006Coltsbestever

Posted
Posted

For fans that think winning SB's or getting to one comes easy, here are the top 7 QB's that have won 2 SB's + had at least 4 appearances as a starter. 55 SB's  have been played. SB Apps are the tie breaker over the QB's that have won 2. 

 

1. Tom Brady 7 SB wins, 10 Apps

 

2. Joe Montana 4 SB wins, 4 Apps

 

2. Terry Bradshaw 4 SB wins, 4 Apps (tied with Montana)

 

4. Troy Aikman 3 SB wins, 3 Apps

 

5. John Elway 2 SB wins, 5 Apps

 

6. Peyton Manning 2 SB wins, 4 Apps - 1 win with Indy and 2 Apps

 

6. Roger Staubach 2 SB wins, 4 Apps (tied with Peyton)

 

-very short list in 55 seasons, 7 QB's out of thousands. Just a little history for you folks :sip:. 

 

Bottomline, we need the right QB to go to multiple SB's and win at least 2! I guess we can play the lottery lmao . 

Link to comment
Share on other sites
jvan1973 Ring of Honor

jvan1973

Posted
Posted
22 minutes ago, LJpalmbeacher2 said:

The super bowl is a very poor way to measure a QB's greatness. 

Especially since so many teams/cities are not wanted in the Big Game by Networks, Advertisers and other preferred teams & markets.... it's a lot to overcome by some very good teams & QB's.

If market size were a factor,  the Jets wouldn't have sucked this long.   The Steelers and Packers wouldn't have had the success they have.    Indy wouldn't have had the success they had in the 2000s.    I know you think the "football gods " do certain things.    They don't

Link to comment
Share on other sites
LJpalmbeacher2 Ring of Honor

LJpalmbeacher2

Posted
Posted
4 minutes ago, jvan1973 said:

If market size were a factor,  the Jets wouldn't have sucked this long.   The Steelers and Packers wouldn't have had the success they have.    Indy wouldn't have had the success they had in the 2000s.    I know you think the "football gods " do certain things.    They don't

 

Right, lol.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
jvan1973 Ring of Honor

jvan1973

Posted
Posted
2 hours ago, LJpalmbeacher2 said:

 

Right, lol.

Explain why the Patriots have had such a giant run,  but the largest fan base hasn't been successful for nearly 30 years.  Almost  all of your "football god" predictions have been wrong.   The reality is on my side,   not yours

Link to comment
Share on other sites
LJpalmbeacher2 Ring of Honor

LJpalmbeacher2

Posted
Posted
32 minutes ago, jvan1973 said:

Explain why the Patriots have had such a giant run,  but the largest fan base hasn't been successful for nearly 30 years.  Almost  all of your "football god" predictions have been wrong.   The reality is on my side,   not yours

I'm not right 100% but

My bets and parlays would have made anyone playing them a pretty penny. I know they did for me. Just what was made yesterday on Brady was probably more than anyone here made all season.

 

If you don't understand or are too naive or too Holy to accept how things really are in this world so be it. 

 

I've said early on that I didn't buy into the Hype on Ballard like so many here did..... and now after 5 seasons so many here are posting their displeasure of his moves AND non-moves. 

Saying things that aren't in agreement with hopeful homers isn't usually popular but I give my opinions and my opinions have been right more often then not to the dismay of many.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
LJpalmbeacher2 Ring of Honor

LJpalmbeacher2

Posted
Posted
8 minutes ago, jvan1973 said:

@LJpalmbeacher2 where am I wrong

 

I can tell you lots of stuff but it's not allowed...neither is posting what former coaches, players, and others say on internet. But someone posted last week about what a  former Buccaneer said on a radio interview. 

 

I'm done responding to you on this and may put you on "ignore" LOL

Link to comment
Share on other sites
GoPats Practice Squad

GoPats

Posted
Posted
16 hours ago, LJpalmbeacher2 said:

I'm not right 100% but

My bets and parlays would have made anyone playing them a pretty penny. I know they did for me. Just what was made yesterday on Brady was probably more than anyone here made all season.

 

If you don't understand or are too naive or too Holy to accept how things really are in this world so be it. 

 

I've said early on that I didn't buy into the Hype on Ballard like so many here did..... and now after 5 seasons so many here are posting their displeasure of his moves AND non-moves. 

Saying things that aren't in agreement with hopeful homers isn't usually popular but I give my opinions and my opinions have been right more often then not to the dismay of many.

 

big will ferrell GIF

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Go to topic listing

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.

  • Popular Now

  • Thread of the Week

  • Topics

  • Posts

    • crazycolt1
      Colts have 4th pick (Official Discussion Thread)

      By crazycolt1 · Posted

      Personally I have a little more faith in Minshew if it boiled down to him starting.  Think what you may but don't bet the farm on getting a top 5 pick.  Just saying 
    • compuls1v3
      Post free agengency power rankings

      By compuls1v3 · Posted

      Some men might think he’s hot!?! I don’t. LOL
    • crazycolt1
      Colts have 4th pick (Official Discussion Thread)

      By crazycolt1 · Posted

      You seem to draw a conclusion on what?
    • TomDiggs
      Colts have 4th pick (Official Discussion Thread)

      By TomDiggs · Posted

      Also, I was very curious to see how the early analysts were projecting this class at the end of the 2021 season to see how widely things have changed. Found this super interesting.   On May 4, 2022 Dane Brugler put out his super early mock draft for 2023 before this recent 2022 season was played. Super interesting to see much of this has not changed a whole lot. (I also like Brugler and think his opinions are some of the better ones amongst analysts, which is why I tried to see if he had said anything)   His top 10 (posting in case people can't access the article on The Athletic):   1. CJ Stroud 2. Bryce Young 3. Will Anderson 4. Kelee Ringo 5. Will Levis 6. Jalen Carter 7. Tyler Van * 8. Jaxon Smith-Njigba 9. Bryan Bresee 10. Michael Mayer   Outside of Ringo, you could argue that the top-6 has not changed a whole heck of a lot.   Why is this important if at all? Mainly because these NFL teams scout these guys for years. They aren't just looking at them now for the first time.    Also interesting, in his post-2021 and pre-2022 future draft rankings for 2022 Brugler had the QBs ranked as the following (with their best asset listed):   1. CJ Stroud- touch and anticipation 2. Bryce Young- Poise and processing 3. Will Levis- NFL level tools 4. Tanner McKee- Ball placement 5. Anthony Richardson- Rare physical profile     Sound familiar?  All these things are stillllllll the same. Especially amongst the big 4 QBs.   So I, for one, am not going to go down the path of hating on Levis if he is the choice. He may be my 3rd option, but he has the goods and is worthy of the 1.04 if the staff thinks they can work with him and unlock his potential and make him even more consistent.      https://theathletic.com/3290071/2022/05/03/nfl-mock-draft-2023/     https://theathletic.com/3415147/2022/07/12/nfl-draft-2023-qb-scouting/
    • krunk
      Colts have 4th pick (Official Discussion Thread)

      By krunk · Posted

      Making up a boogie man out of thin air i see! Analysis paralysis. Quarterback coaches exist for a reason to help out with identifying pressures and navigating the pocket. So basically we would just tank the whole season bc you feel like(not confirmed in the least bit) Stroud would have problems with pressure so we can be in position to have the #1 pick. And once in position what happens when you find out a new stat about the QB in 24 you dont like? Do we tank again? How many times you want to do that? All this bc of your unconfirmed fears and concerns? Last generational QB we had what did that get us? Not even 1 Super Bowl.   You cant hang your whole hat on that. Chasing the mythical Golden Goose. Sometimes you have to take a guy as he is with all his positive attributes, and whatever needs work you get down in the trenches with him to bring that weak part up to par. Being very honest the tanking proposal itself has desperation all over it, but then you chide somebody else about picking a QB due to desperation? You'd really need to do a whale of a job explaining how picking Stroud represents an act of desperation. Youve made a problem out of something you dont even know will be a real issue.

  • Members

×
×
  • Create New...