Luck, Manning, Ryan, Breese Airial Stats

[King Colt]

For Sunday 10-7-12 Yards Passing:

Breese:370

Luck: 362

Ryan: 338

Mannig:332

I will offer a guess here years from now Luck will be a Hall of Famer with the rest of these guys.

[SLILLINGTON10]

little early and a very small sample size

[Mouthfire]

little early and a very small sample size

Yes, but still promising, nonetheless.

[lollygagger8]

I care more about the team W more than I care about the passing yards.

[coltsfanatic24]

yes i think luck eventually will. hes on pace for 4,800 yds 28 td's 20 int's.

[21isSuperman]

It is was too early to call Luck even a potential Hall of Famer. The talent and work ethic is there, but he is still a rookie. Let him get a few seasons under his belt. But the future certainly looks bright in Colts Nation!

[SLILLINGTON10]

Yes, but still promising, nonetheless.

in that case matt flynn last year threw for 480 yds and 6 tds. he should be on track to be the greatest qb ever. but instead he is on the bench behind a rookie. sample size has to be taken into account even for it to be promising.

[Mouthfire]

in that case matt flynn last year threw for 480 yds and 6 tds. he should be on track to be the greatest qb ever. but instead he is on the bench behind a rookie. sample size has to be taken into account even for it to be promising.

Yes, true, but he's been statistically consistent over the course of four games (8 games, if you count preseason). More important than that, you see all of the consistent mechanics which made him the overall number 1 draft pick.

I really don't think we're looking at a Flynn-like career....

[SLILLINGTON10]

Yes, true, but he's been statistically consistent over the course of four games (8 games, if you count preseason). More important than that, you see all of the consistent mechanics which made him the overall number 1 draft pick.

I really don't think we're looking at a Flynn-like career....

i agree with you Luck has all the tools and has played very well for the situation. i do believe he could be an all time great. i just can't bring myself to put him in the elite category yet. look at matt ryan who has a few real good years in the league, a lot of people doubt his elite status cause he hasn't won a playoff game. if luck doesn't have a sophmore slump and instead improves he could be in the consideration for that talk.

[Mouthfire]

i agree with you Luck has all the tools and has played very well for the situation. i do believe he could be an all time great. i just can't bring myself to put him in the elite category yet. look at matt ryan who has a few real good years in the league, a lot of people doubt his elite status cause he hasn't won a playoff game. if luck doesn't have a sophmore slump and instead improves he could be in the consideration for that talk.

Can't disagree with that.

[Synthetic]

Brees continuing to prove that he should have won that MVP last year.

[Hans Moleman]

As confident as I am that Luck will be an All-Pro, HOF caliber player, I have to give him two years as a starter to really rate him.

There's a lot of QB's who can play one great year. Then defensive coordinators start really focusing on you, and they'll expose what you're really made of (for better or worse). The "sophomore slump" isn't something that happens magically- give any NFL caliber D-coordinator a year's worth of game film to identify your tendencies, strengths, and weaknesses, and they'll dial up a game plan to exploit it. They'll test you real quick to see if you've learned from the flaws in your game or if you're a one year wonder. I doubt Luck will turn out to be fool's gold, but I'll still wait to rate him.

[loluck]

Talk about cherry picking. What about the 54 percent completion percentage and the 77 rating thus far? He's not even close to those guys loluck