Is T.Y. Hilton a top WR in the NFL?

[Superfly Jay]

He is if not at least top 5.

[crazycolt1]

Oh, but he will NEVER be another Marvin......

 

Route running blah blah blah

 

:yay:  :yay:  :yay:  :yay:  :yay:  :yay:  :yay:

 

Are you kidding me?

Wake up and smell the coffee folks.....And get used to it.

 

True receiver greatness is once again thriving in the Colts Camp.

 

It's undeniable.

 

ColtsHappy

Putting his name up against Marvin is not right. Let's look back in a few years.

[chrisfarley]

He's gettin' there - he's doing pretty good against good teams and he has very few drops.  And speed kills.  How would we compare him to Wallace?  Different receivers but do you think people think of him in that comparison (as far as popularity league-wide).

[wesd2890]

Good WR. But he's to small to be an all around great WR. Hes not gonna be the guy that is an endzone threat.. at 5'9 hes not gonna be the endzone jump ball fade type player.. his size in the redzone really puts a damper on his game.. hes a big play player.. id say top ten at best.. people saying top 5 have lost their minds

[t-rex]

Yes.

[coltsfanatic24]

Hilton is a top 10 WR. He's the best deep threat in the league and he's a good route runner. He gets so much separation vs the DB's because of his elite speed.

[mattceinicram]

Him, Luck, Allen, and Trent are only going to get better

 

 

Do we have this era's Marvin, Peyton, Edge, and Dallas in place?