2006 and 2009 are the best years because we won and made the SB with Peyton Manning. Nothing else that has happened can beat that as that is the objective of playing football, to make and win the SB. 2014 was great and bad. Great because we made the AFC Championship in Lucks 3rd year, but terrible because we got blown out and it showed how far away we still were from competing with the Patriots at that point in time. I never watched Harbaugh in 95 here (was playing in little league baseball at that time), but almost making the SB is a big deal. Probably the last one I enjoyed was 2018. That was when we thought Luck was back for us, we had Chris Ballard and that amazing 2018 draft class, and the O-Line started to be elite.
So in my top 5: