Toler vs Butler

[danlhart87]

Lets pretend the Colts do very little to add anymore CBs. Who do you want as the #2 CB?

[tydontlie]

Easy, Toler.

[danlhart87]

Any particular reason behind your pick?

[Mitch]

Most definitely Toler with Darius as #3. I'm very happy about both of those signings even though 5 mil seems a little steep. I really don't see us drafting a CB first round anymore though, even though I'd love to get Rhodes(IF he slipped). If we don't, I say we get Tyrann in the 5th!

[NewColtsFan]

I think the answer is Toler....    there's a report out there that we're paying him $5 Mill per.   My hunch is that's at least double, if not more than we're paying Butler.    So, I think that right there is a tip that we see one as the starter, and the other as the nickel corner.

 

If Butler was clearly our #2 I think we would've re-signed him much sooner than we did, which was today....

 

Just my read of things....

[Captain Americolt]

Any particular reason behind your pick?

Because we just signed him for 5m a year.

[James]

Toler is a capable #2 for sure. I'd still consider drafting Xavier Rhodes or even Trufant if they're there at 24. You can never have too many good corners. 

 

Davis, Toler, Butler, Rhodes/Trufant, Vaughn would be amazing, and the competition between them would only benifit the team. 

[smittywerb]

With butler, Davis, and tiler signed, it's no need to draft a cb with our first pick unless its a sure fire cb. I can see us picking up a dime cb in te later rounds.

[Andy]

Very easy choice Toler.

 

He's the more proven starter. He's more athletic and has better intangibles than Butler. Butler is a nickel guy anyways, whereas Toler is an outside guy, who can also play inside if needed. He'd be a better nickel than Butler, but they need a guy on the outside.