Jump to content
Indianapolis Colts

TomDiggs

Member
  • Content Count

    411
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by TomDiggs


  1. I actually find the idea fascinating to be honest.

     

    I remember when Luck retired and articles came out saying that Luck and the Colts front office came to a "compromise" or "settlement" (two words I often saw used and found weird. I found it weird since the "compromise" or "settlement" was basically the Colts letting him keep everything and not demanding money back. The real compromise/settlement as far as I read was that the Colts reserved his rights if he came back and that was the agreement.

     

    So it sets it up that if he ever did decide to return, the Colts either take him back or sell to the highest bidder.

     

    My opinion (as many others) is that he is never coming back. But playing along with your hypothetical scenario, he would fetch way more than a 2nd rounder in my opinion.

     

    The longer he is away from the game, the less he will fetch coming back. But if he came back next year and had only missed one game and was still only 31 years old next year with all of his talent, there is zero doubt in my mind that he commands at least a 1st rounder and maybe even multiple picks. 

     

    I'll be honest, it is a good problem to have but one I hope we don't ever have to decide on or deal with. I hope for his sake that he made what is a good decision for him and his family and he stays retired. And if he does not, it would put some interesting pressure on our front office to see what they would do.

     

    Still a fun topic to think of and hypothetically run through scenarios with.

    • Like 2

  2. 5 minutes ago, chad72 said:

     

    My opposition fell on deaf ears, this is how my team ended up (1 QB, 2 RBs, 2 WR/TE, 2 WR/RB/TE, DEF was the agreed format for half PPR league, can play up to 4 RBs):

     

    In an ESPN, half PPR draft, my team looks like this:

     

    QB: Wentz, Jimmy G (last round)

    RBs: Chris Carson, Mark Ingram, Austin Ekeler, Duke Johnson, Dion Lewis

    WRs/TEs: Michael Thomas, JuJu Smith Schuster, Evan Engram, Emmanuel Sanders, Geronimo Allison

    DEF: Ravens, Chargers

     

     

    Looking pretty good man. Ekeler and Johnson are going to surpise folks and being able to trot out Thomas and JuJu for your two WRs is beastly.

     

     

    • Like 1

  3. 3 hours ago, chad72 said:

    I have a league where they are constructing the roster as 2 RBs, 2 WRs/TEs, 2 FLEX (WR/RB) and I told them it would be a bad idea if someone drafted 4 starting RBs and played them all year long leading to slim pickings for the others.

     

    It is a 0.5 PPR league. What do you guys think about that? Is it a good thing or bad thing?

     

    That can be rough. I also don’t particularly enjoy a league where TE is optional simply because when there isn’t a mandatory starting TE required, then the TE position loses a ton of value. 

     

    So in the end this will will be a horse race to hoard RBs and WRs with RBs taking the main focus if you can start 4. 

     

    If your opposition falls on deaf ears just plan accordingly and load up. 

    • Like 1

  4. While I highly doubt Luck comes back, and I hope for his own health and well being that he does not, I am super curious to see how it gets handled if he does.

     

    If he decides in 2021 that he wants to come back and the Colts then still hold his rights (as I know they would), does his contract simply pick up in 2021 w what he would have made in 2019?

     

    Does it pick up in the 2021 year of his contract?

     

    Or do they just hold his rights and have to negotiate a completely new deal?

     

    Not sure that I know much of a precedent for that scenario to know how it would go.

     

    I doubt we ever find that out, but crazier stuff has happened.

     

     


  5. Look, I will miss Luck. So will our team and our fans.

     

    But at the end of the day I feel for him as a person.

     

    In a league where teams cut guys for multiple reasons and guys get hurt and cut, I would never begrudge this man for walking away when he said "enough is enough" with the injuries.

     

    Truth be told, if I were newly married and about to be a new dad and had millions of dollars and I kept getting hurt and was miserable going to work every day and I could afford to walk away, I would. And that is all this guy is doing here.

     

    It sucks for fans. But he is also walking away from potentially a lot of money. And he thanked almost everyone under the sun and broke down a lot. This isn't some quick decision.

     

    I can only imagine the mental torment he's been going through along w the physical.

     

    And quite frankly if he is not in it mentally, he is smart to get out now before he gets even more hurt physically.

     

    We have been spoiled with Manning and Luck. Now we get to see what it is like to build around lesser talent at the position.

     

    It can be done and done well. Teams ramp up and win around QBs on their rookie contracts. So we will have to see how this shakes out going forward.

     

     

    • Like 7

  6. This has always, always been the likely case.

     

    McCoy refused a pay cut off of his $13M figure.

     

    That always meant his starting point was going to be around that number because that is where he valued himself in refusing the cut.

     

    I also think most teams (and maybe us as well) were always going to want to come in around $8-$10M.

     

    So it also does not surprise me to hear the $11M figure cited since it is probably to hopefully help bring that number up from contenders that are probably offering in the 8-10 range.

     

    We basically paid Hankins $10.5M for one year when he was here.

     

    I always thought that left a slightly bitter taste in management's mouth and it was unlikely we would approach that $10M a year figure in these McCoy discussions.

     

    If the reports are true then the Colts interest was exactly what many figured:

     

    We called and asked "hey what are you looking for?"

     

    We heard the number and said "oh ok thanks" and we moved on.

     

    Now if he comes down, then maybe we play. But if he comes down then he probably falls right in the range of what the Browns/Ravens etc are also offering. And since he visited those teams, had good visits, they showed a good amount of interest beyond a simple phone call, etc then he likely goes to one of them.

     

    I wish McCoy well and hope he gets as close to that $13M as he can. But it sure seems like he will not get anywhere close w the Colts and it has always been unlikely that he would anyhow.

     

     

     

     


  7. 3 hours ago, ColtsBlueFL said:

     

     doubt that... if he sees his #, he pulls out the pen. Not call other GM's and say 'can you beat this?'

     

    The only reason I doubt this logic is that there was a good report out of Cleveland from a reliable reporter that he has one offer of $11M for one year but it’s from a team that isn’t as much of a contender and as such he’s considering other teams and seeing what they’re willing to give. Same source says the offer in Cleveland would be under $10M

     

    so he isn’t just seeing his number and signing. If that were true he’d have signed for that $11M on the dotted line as soon as he got it (unless he’s looking for more than $11M which would be rough). He’s smartly shopping around. Trying to find the best mix of team (contender if we believe him wanting to go to a contender) and money

     

    so it’ll come down to which “good” team makes him the best offer 

     

    as such I can see his agent shopping him and playing off the offers. Hell a good agent should do that

     

    so again, we may already be out or we may be right in the thick of things behind the scenes 

     

    he does have ties to a coach on the ravens as well. And has allegedly had them on his short list too. So that Tuesday visit next week will be a key one. 

     

    Im not optimistic for us but I’m still hopeful that we at least engaged w his agent and have an idea of where things are at continuously 

    • Like 1

  8. I never ever worry about cap space for teams at this point. They can restructure or make any moves they want to fit a guy under the cap. Especially in a multi year deal. 

     

    So so really just about anyone can truly “afford” McCoy. 

     

    The Ravens have issues but are a historically well coached and great defensive team. Makes sense for defenders to want to go there. 

     

    I still want McCoy. But unless there’s rumors of a visit to Indy then I’m not getting any hopes up

     

    for all we know we reached out to his agent and kicked the tires. We though we’d offer $7-$9M. We heard $10+ and we said good luck and he started to take his visits. 

     

    Im not saying that’s how it went down. But that could easily be the case and we could already be out. 

     

    Or or we could be waiting to see what he gets offered and swoop in later to match or beat it. Who knows. 

     

    I just always thought ought it was an unlikely marriage w the colts once so many teams got involved or expressed interest. 

    • Like 2

  9. 44 minutes ago, Irish YJ said:

    I still wonder if we ever talked to Suh. 9.25 for one year seems really reasonable. I would given him that in a heartbeat. I'd happily give McCoy 10-12 a year for 2 years. 

     

    Either one of these guys could have been, or could be signed with little to no impact to our fiscal situation. 

    Agreed! That said Cleveland has like $30M or soo too I believe. 

     

    so I can easily see them making an offer that we need to beat. And I just don’t think it’s in Ballard’s dna yet to do that. And definitely not for a 31 yr old 3-tech where he seems to have a lot of faith in Autry/Lewis/Ward. I would do it but that’s why I’m not leading this team lol. 

    • Like 1

  10. I would love to get McCoy.

     

    I just think that our fans need to prepare as if it is not gonna happen.

     

    Not because we do not want him or he is not a fit or anything like that.

     

    Mainly because he is going to have a lot of suitors.

     

    At the end of the day, the Colts will have to win a bidding war for him if they want him. There will likely be even more.

     

    Typically we do not go that bidding war route. We will make an offer and if it's good enough and he takes it then cool.

     

    But my guess is he will shop offers around.

     

    He did not want to take a pay cut from his $13M figured before he got cut. So I feel like $10-$13M is probably the sweet spot.

     

    I'd offer it for one year, but someone might be willing to go multiple years or more for one year.

     

    So we have to hope that our offer is better than others or at least as good.

     

    We have the cap room to do it. Question is will we?

     

    I am happy w how we stand without him. I'd be even happier with him. I am just not confident that we get it done. I hope I am wrong.

     

     

     

     


  11. On paper the Browns have the look of a team that could win 10-12 games.

     

    They have not played together and it is only a paper exercise until they prove it.

     

    That being said, Baker Mayfield looks like the real deal.

     

    Their OL is solid. If the right side of the line holds up they will be above average there.

     

    They have crazy offensive skill position firepower. Beckham, Landry, Callaway, Njoku, Chubb, Hunt, Duke Johnson.

     

    Their offense could be scary if the gel.

     

    Defensively they look pretty well stacked too.

     

    A D-Line featuring Myles Garrett, Sheldon Richardson and Olivier Vernon could be great if they all perform up to their capabilities.

     

    Kirksey and Schobert are solid LBs.

     

    And their secondary is talented as heck.

     

    Ward, Greedy, Burnett and Randall make for a nice group.

     

    Again, they have yet to play together so it is all projection. But there is talent all across the board on this team.

     

    Combine that with the Ravens rebuilding on the fly and the Steelers playing without Bell and Brown for an entire season and the Bengals being the Bengals and all of the sudden you have a team that could go something like 4-2 or 5-1 in their division.

     

    If they can split with the Steelers and the Ravens, they could easily reach 10 wins

     

    Potential wins: Ravens, Steelers, Bengals (2), Jets, 49ers, Broncos, Bills, Dolphins, Cardinals

    Potential losses: Ravens, Steelers, Patriots, Seahawks, Titans, Rams

     

    I feel like 8 wins is their floor and 12 wins is their ceiling. They will be fun to watch this year.

     

     

     

     

    • Like 3
    • Thanks 2
×
×
  • Create New...