Andrew Luck will be greatest ever

[peytonmanning18]

By these qualifiers then Manning is out of that conversation. And I don't know How you stand on Manning.

Well Manning is not in consideration for greatest of all time

[Defjamz26]

At this point, I think it's a definite that he'll be better than Manning. He's breaking all of his team records, and he's already winning more playoff games. He definitely has a better physical skill set, but isn't as cerebral as Manning....YET.

GOAT, IDK yet. We can get a better idea of that about year 6.

[Coltsman1788]

Yeah nothin' like getting dealt 4 aces.

meanwhile we gotta scramble for 6th rounders

Well to be fair...we have also had to endure Art Schlitzer, Jeff George, Mike Pagel and the like. Dark times indeed. The Elway diss was the ultimate slap in the face and hindered this franchise for over a decade. The Colts ultimately had to relocate as a consequence.

I think the Colts were due some good "Luck" so to speak.