2006Coltsbestever

What, no McDaniel's?

Yeah, it is all subjective, like any debate about GOAT's. It depends on what era someone might think was tougher to win in as well. Breaking down the decades, IMO there were 2 coaches that stood out in each decade regarding wins and SB wins: 60's 1. Vince Lombardi - Won 2 SB's in the 60's. 2. Weeb Ewbank - Won the SB in 1968 as a huge underdog. 70's 1. Don Shula - Won 2 SB's in the 70's, went undefeated in 1972. 2. Chuck Knoll - Won 4 SB's in the 70's. 80's 1. Bill Walsh - Won 3 SB's in the 80's. 2. Joe Gibbs - Won 2 SB's in the 80's, 3 overall. 90's 1. Jimmy Johnson - Won 2 SB's in the 90's. Built a team from 1-15 to a dynasty. 2. Mike Shannahan - Won 2 SB's in the 90's. 2000's-09 1. Bill Belichick - Won 3 SB's in the 2000's-09 2. Tony Dungy - Won a SB in 2006 and won 76% of his games with Indy. 2010's-19 1. Bill Belichick - Won 3 SB's in the 2010's-19. 2. Andy Reid - got a SB win in 2019. -I guess, pick your poison. Belichick does has the advantage because he dominated for 2 decades.

Kenny Moore. Not just because of the past week but that obviously helps. He has 3 INTs, 2 for TDs, 61 tackles, and 1.5 sacks. He is doing all of that with almost no other help in the secondary.

I would rather have Mustache. What is funny about this, Rams passed on him in the draft and took Goff instead. Goff is gone and now they end up with Wentz anyway.

Last 20 years: 1. Hasselbeck 2. Mustache 3. Brissett Mustache by a hair over Brissett. He gets the ball out faster and is more accurate is why. Hasselbeck is #1 to me.

We had no business losing in 2005. We were by far the best team in the NFL. I blame Dungy for that loss vs Pitt. He got outcoached by Cowher.

That is hard to top.

I forgot Lombardi . He won 5 Championships and the 1st 2 SB's.

To your last sentence, that is tough to argue because he has won 6 SB's but without Brady he is 27-32 and hasn't won a playoff game. I could throw 4 other names in a debate that were arguably better: Shula - Has the most wins in NFL History + has led the only team to an undefeated season. The 72 Dolphins went 17-0. Shula won 2 SB's with the Dolphins (72 and 73) and went to another in 1984 with them, he had Dan Marino but no run game or Defense in 84. Walsh - Won 3 SB's with the 49ers during the 80's and invented the West Coast offense. Gibbs - He won a SB with 3 different QB's that aren't even Hall of Famers (1982, 1987, 1991). 3 SB wins with Theismann, Williams, and Rypien lol. Gibbs has a strong argument to being the GOAT, he had no Montana, Brady, or Peyton - not even close and still won 3. Lombardi - 5 Championships, won the 1st 2 SB's.

Manning threw for 333 Yards, 1 TD, 1 INT in SB 44. His INT at the end stings but he had nothing on Earl's SB 3.

Manning only had 1 INT in that SB - at the end. You lost me?

Winning SB's are tough. There is a reason why only 12 QB's in the history of the SB era have won 2 or more as a starter in the 57 SB's played. Can't win the SB every year, besides winning a SB and going to 2 here, you can't discredit our 109-35 Regular Season record between 2002-2010. Most team would kill for that.

I posted the same thing above. I agree.

Way worse than Manning. Even had Manning scored, it would have just tied the game. Saints get the ball back with 4 minutes left. We couldn't stop the Saints all 2nd half, so they still would have won with a last second FG in probability. Plus the onsides kick changed that game, Manning's INT just sealed it but it was 1 play. Regarding Earl, he was throwing to the jets all day with pinpoint accuracy, he made 4 or 5 bad plays that were crucial.

Here in Indianapolis the game is on the NFL Network and it is also on FOX.

Yeah, he was the best QB on the field for the Jets in SB 3.

Most Patriots' fans will say it isn't rivalry, but they are lying just to be arrogant. I will tell you why, they are still sour about Deflategate because that questions a SB win they had in 2014. The Ravens said they deflated balls and they barely beat the Ravens that year. They actually may have lost to the Ravens had they not deflated balls. Brady got suspended for 4 games because of what happened. If the deflate accusation would have been nothing, the NFL would have never suspended him. Them beating us 45-7 has nothing to do with the situation. Also anyone that is older than 50 will tell you this is a rivalry. People younger than 50 must not know 80's football. Learn your history youngins'

Same here. I thought Stafford was playing as well, that is why I took the Rams. Had I known he wasn't playing I would have gone Packers. I need to be more careful from here on and out. That is a mistake I normally I don't make as in I normally who is playing and who isn't.

I will go ahead and make my picks too shortly because at worse we can always change a pick if a key injury happens to a team we pick.

You may win this, long way to go. I have my work cut out for me. Just not you but 3 or 4 others are right there.

This has been the most fun I have had with this in the 3 years doing it. So much great competition is why. Chad has been outstanding so far.

I agree.

@EasyEhas been quietly hanging around I see. I am only 1 game ahead of him.

Thanks. Everything is updated too.