Aaron86

Isn't Geathers a starter?never mind he's not ruled out...lol

So many people get hung up on stats and I think you really have to look at what a player like Andrew really brings to the table. Luck has proven he can carry a team time and time again. I mean look at this season alone we have been right there almost every game. Luck is Elite in my opinion.

Elite to me is a player who can carry your team like Von Miller, Manning, Brady, Watt, Rogers, Luck, Brees just to name a few. Stats can sometimes be misleading and miscued. But that's just my opinion.

Let's just forget all the amazing things Andrew has done and just focus on the BONEHEADED throws.

They all have had some pretty boneheaded throws. I would put Luck as elite because he will wreck havoic on a defense and has to be accounted for week in and week out. For him to be playing at this level after what two years off. That's the kind of player I consider ELITE. Wait til next year he's gonna be a monster for teams to deal with.

I'm gonna stick him in the top 3 partly because I'm a hommer. But also look at everything he has went through not just physically but mentally and getting better each week. He's had to play with virtually no receivers except Ebron. And was still putting our team in a position to win.

Give me nine other QBs playing better then him now. What does this guy have to do to prove he is elite.

This line has been shuffled so muchin the past I don't get why now that it works we should move him.

If it ain't broke don't fix it. Just my opinion.

Why would you move smith? He is balling right now.

Glad someone posted it. Tired of all the Fairweather fans. Luck does carry this team and God forbid he has a bad game after the injury he had. How about that bomb to ty and the hail Mary pass!!!

Agreed. If we keep bringing free agents in we will really never quite know what we already have. Trial by fire.

I think your a bit paranoid. Anybody in this game is one hit away from being over. Andrew has been throwing just not footballs. I don't think soreness is going to be a big deal at all.