To say Taylor isn't an elite player is absolutely laughable. I'll agree that he doesn't deserve the same payday McCaffery is getting but as far as a true running back Taylor is better. Has better explosiveness, power and vision. This is coming from someone who favorite collegiate player of all time is CMC. If a player can single handedly put the team on his back and bring in a win then they are elite and that's what Taylor has done for us several times. If the Colts get to any relevancy with in the next 3-5 years and he puts up 3-4 more +1300 rushing yards a year he will at least get some HOF talk when he retires.