That's just it. Some posters here think the conversation is about JT being 'worth it'. The conversation is, "Is any running back worth it' in the 2023 version of the NFL (and if yes, how much); and is JT a stud RB anymore. He's young, but that doesn't mean he still has the physical ability to produce at an elite level. That is the gamble.
The Colts have consistently said (over and over, in lockstep):
They LOVE Jonathon Taylor
They believe it is necessary to pay their 'special' players
They haven't discussed extensions with any player this off season because they have a new coach and a new system
They are willing to discuss an extension during the season. This season. But they have to know first if the player fits into what they are doing now.
All of this is reasonable and is great news for Jonathon Taylor. The Colts are likely to overpay for a running back's services, this year, if he would get on the program. Or, is he hurt, and can't perform (does he know this and this is what this is all about)?
REMEMBER: This isn't a free agent negotiation. This is a player who is already on contract with the team and is expected, is contractually obligated, to play football for this team. That is, unless he cannot perform or until the team decides they can and should trade him for something.
Mr. Taylor, can you perform your contractual obligations this season? If not, how do you expect to be traded; and/or how do you anticipate being able to earn a new, longer contract?