Jump to content
Indianapolis Colts
Indianapolis Colts Fan Forum

18Manning

Senior Member
  • Posts

    1,178
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    1

Posts posted by 18Manning

  1. I guess it could be the beginning to end, but either one could go on to have very productive years. Peyton/Denver was literally one play away from advancing to the AFC Championship game and I think they will be better next year. Brady/NE was only one game away from another SB and had the best offense this season. With a good supporting cast and adjustments they'll keep going, but they're both certainly on the way down (beyond the half way point). 

  2. There was some speculation that maybe he had a dead arm after the ravens game. If he is healthy I'm sure he will go

     

    I meant to add that to my original response (wouldn't miss unless a physical reason).

  3. I doubt either he or Peyton go..

     

    I could be wrong, but I don't think Peyton has ever missed becasue he was eliminated from the playoffs (assuming that's what you mean). Anyone know any different?

  4. I hate to admit, but since the Colts and Peyton/Denver were knocked out of the playoffs, I set my home page to Google (don't have to see the headlines, etc.). I didn't want to see all the rah rah rah about NE. I respect NE and Brady, I just get tired of them. Finally, a Super Bowl I can enjoy even though one of the teams I wanted to see isn't in there.

  5. Brady did play like crap. Think about this, Adam missed a FG when we played Baltimore. Luck on the road as a rookie with no protection actually just scored 1 less point then the Pats offense did.

     

    Wow.

     

    I feel bad for Manning tonight since I honestly think that if the Broncos won the game last weekend they had a real shot vs. NE in Denver with probably better weather and the rust shaken off.

     

    Me too. I don't think Peyton/Denver would have had too much trouble getting that win. After all, they hung right in there with the team that just smoked NE at home.

  6. As much as I hate to say it. I want the Ravens to win it. Why, you ask?

     

    Whether you believe in the Unitas or Baltimore curse or not, I believe the Colts win the SB only after the Ravens get ahead by 1 in the count. So, I am guessing big bro. John Harbaugh wins one in New Orleans, and then comes the Colts chance in the next few years. But then, Jim Harbaugh has the experience of already playing in NO this year. It is going to be interesting.

     

    But just like Dungy beat Lovie Smith, the older coach wins, IMO.

     

    Plus, to know the Super Bowl champ eliminated you makes it a little easier too (for both Colts and Manning/Denver fans).

  7. Manning choked like he always does. Just be glad they played the Bears in the Super Bowl, who had Grossman at quarterback or he would still be like Marino, best at the position to never win a ring.

     

    I'm going to just provide a link to this article that was provided to me. I suppose though, you're set in your ways and opinion...

     

    http://bleacherreport.com/articles/1484410-why-does-peyton-manning-always-come-up-short-in-the-playoffs

  8. agreed . . .

    yes . . . it is tough when people try to pin something on one person . . . and tough too when you are the last one to turn off the lights and everyone is going to blame you . . . but for me unless there are clear bonehead mistakes . . . it is generally a mix among all players and coaches and of coarse the other team performing well . . . alas, it was a game in which you could not afford a mistake and sadly for Manning there was no time for make up after the pick . . .

    I remember late in SB 38 leading by 5 Brady the pats were driving down the field in a similiar one score you can't make a mistake game. we were in the red zone and thus had a sure 3 points to make it at least a 8 point game . . . Brady rolled out and threw an inexcusable pick, as opposed to throwinng the ball through the back of the endzone . . . 3 plays later on 3rd and long , Delomne throws an 85 yard TD pass and now we are down by 2 points . . . an alsolute killer, but fortunately we had some time left and drove the field for a TD to go ahead . . . but not the less Brady threw a back pick but, unlike Manning, had time to correct the mistake . . . the Brady pick is mostly forgotten about, but i have not, it was a costly mistake that fortunately Brady had time to make up for, had it been later in the game, result of the game could of been different . . .

    you may of already seen this article, but its a good read . . .

    http://bleacherreport.com/articles/1484410-why-does-peyton-manning-always-come-up-short-in-the-playoffs

     

    That's a great article. But, even with all that data at hand, many will still blame Manning entirely. If you look at the post immediately below the article, there's a prime example. It amazes me that so many fans can't seem to look at an entire game to draw a logical conclusion. Most will only consider Peyton Manning is the common variable, therefore the reason for the losses.

  9. Was the post in this thread or another? . . . I would like to read it . . . just let me know the thread and I can find it . . .

    As for your points I would like to say the following . . . the pick 6 was a bad bounce (i don't think it was PI frankly), the WR was looking into the sun and it was cold . . . the pass was a tad high but that was it from Manning, it was otherwise a fine pass . . . the fumble was a fumble and was past the tuck point, bad luck for Manning had he just dropped the ball it would of been a incomplete pass, like what happen to Romo in a game last year, but he lost control of the ball and tried to corral it and was able to grab it with both hands, so to that extent it was on mannning and just bad luck it was past the point of the tuck (whereas Romo was saved by dropping the ball). . . the final pick was on manning . . .

    The D did not play lights out, but on the other hand were not awful either, they gave up 21 points on hail marys that work about once in 15 tries, the other 14 points were on the pick 6 and the short field based on Manning's fumble . . . so not great, but not awful, bad luck maybe

    the team was helped by 14 points on ST, the missed FG i believe was from beyond his range and, like a golfer trying to kill a ball, you can hit the dirt before the ball . . .

    so was the game on manning . . . no it was not . . . nor was it totally on the D either . . . the one thing that i will say is that in games like that, you really need to avoid trying to make a mistake, and it has happened to everyone . . .so to that extent I feel that it was ill advise for Manning not to throw away the ball OT, was it the be all end all, no of coarse not, but merely a situation were a mistake was made, like the safety play and coaching, could not be afforded . . .

    hey all QBs have had mistakes and many times have made ones that are just a mere part of a game . . . this is simple what happened . . . so the pick, like the coaching and safety play, were all parts of the loss . . . alas, when your team around you are making mistakes it carries an extra burden on teammates not to make a mistake themselves . . .

     

    I pretty much agree with everything you said here. Anyone I've disagreed with basically put the loss on Manning alone (the pick in double OT was the loser as far as they're concerned). I'd have to look back to see where I commeneted before, but I'm basically in agreement with what you posted.

  10. There is nothing wrong loving your hero. He was my super hero the past 10 yrs until last Saturday. And I really hate Pats :)

     

    So, Tony (I assume that's your name), a man you referred to prior to this loss was your "super hero"? He loses a game and is no longer a hero or super hero to you? Isn't that called a fairweather fan? I'll be a fan of the Colts and Peyton Manninig regardless. So I guess if the Broncos make it to the SB next year and win, Peyton Manning is your super hero again? I have the utmost respect for Peyton Manning as a person and a player for his accomplishments on and off the field. I thought super heros were for kids, but depending on your definition of a hero, maybe Peyton Manning is my hero among many other good people. 

  11. He was not put in the position to throw the pick. Contrarily he was on the way to drive his team down the field for a game-winning TD and nobody would ever talk about his mistakes and instead he'd be praised as the greatest of all time for an entire week before meeting the Pats. Even on that very play he had one WR on top that was open and his target Stokley open, and nobody was near him to bring him down. He made a bad throw. That's it.

     

    OMG are you serious? He made a bad throw? I thought every throw he made was perfect.

  12. Missing FGs is also part of a game. If you really think your super hero should never be put in the position, for three times, to prove his greatness by moving the chain for 30-40 yards and let his kicker finish the game, I guess you should really ask yourself how much you really trust your greatest-of-all-time.

     

    Boy you people that don't like Manning REALLY DON'T LIKE MANNING. Just because my avatar is a picture of Manning and I use the 18Manning as my name, doesn't make him my "super hero". I trust him completely. Let me guess, you're a Brady fan? Some other QB fan? Are you jealous your QB isn't talked about as a GOAT? Well, talk to the media about that. Don't cry to me...

×
×
  • Create New...