Jump to content
Indianapolis Colts
Indianapolis Colts Fan Forum
  • entries
  • comments
  • views

And They Talked About Peyton's Legacy



Whew! What a week. The Super Bowl was fantabulous, Indianapolis was the best host city in years, and the media covered all the angles---no, wait, they just pulled out all their articles from four years ago... Copy and paste covers a multitude of sins...and typos, too. :)

Anyhow, one of the main topics discussed all week was Peyton Manning. Questions ranged from his health to his children and seemingly never ended, but the question that led to the topic of this week's blog was even termed 'blasphemous' by one of the analysts on NFL Total Access. It is as follows: "Has Eli surpassed Peyton?"

I decided to tackle this question---not only because it is pertinent to the Colts---but because my Mind and my Heart were just itching to get into the debate. This discussion was different from all the past debates and probably all future ones as well. Why? My Mind and my Heart agreed.

British Prime Minister Winston Churchill once said, "A fanatic is one who can't change his mind and won't change the subject." By Winston Churchill's definition, I am a fanatic. That means my Heart and Mind are as well. Thus, I cannot change my convicton and won't change the subject that was most discussed this past week. That being said, let's dive into and trudgen along in the middle of the discussion that my Heart and my Mind engaged in. Last night.

My Mind started things off. Maybe he was quick to begin this week because he didn't want my Heart giving him grief over being wrong the last time the two matched wits. My Mind said, "Heart, can you believe that people are even asking this?"

My Heart responded, "Well, Mind, we knew that no matter who won the Super Bowl, some question of this nature would come up. Either it would have been Brady being the greatest of all time or it would have been Eli as the better brother. Eli's team won, and so---here we are."

"Well," My Mind answered, "That's true. But you know, I remember seeing a comment on the forum the other day that went something like this: 'Great teams win Super Bowls. Great quarterbacks put up stats.' I don't know if I could agree more with that poster. When you look at Eli and Peyton, you see Eli having few good years and two Super Bowls, while Peyton has multiple good years and 2 Super Bowl appearances. It seems then, to me, that Peyton is a greater QB than Eli, because he has put up stats even with less than championship caliber teams."

My Heart would've been nodding its head if it had possessed one. "Exactly, Mind. And that's not to say that Peyton hasn't had good teams or that Eli has had better teams his whole career, it's simply stating the fact that Peyton's legacy is still bigger than Eli's because of his consistent success. Do you realize that Peyton holds over 50 NFL records? Eli holds under 5."

My Mind was in agreement. "Absolutely. And no matter what happens, Peyton will always be remembered as the better Manning. Even though Eli's season was amazing, it wasn't even close to one of Peyton's great ones. Do you realize that Eli's best season is only better than 5 of Peyton's 14? And if anything, the Colts 2-14 record this year only solidified Peyton's place."

They kept talking, even though it was late, and I hated to interrupt. So instead, I penned this to post here on my blog. I won't take the time to outline the arguments for Peyton's place as the better Manning, because any real fan of the game can see that for themselves. I will, however, requote Winston Churchill.

"A fanatic is one who can't change his mind and won't change the subject." I am a true fanatic. Of Peyton. Of football. Of the Colts. And of the truth. 'Til next week!

  • Like 1


Recommended Comments

I think Peyton also never had a GREAT coach like Coughlin and or BB. I am sorry I think Dungy is a good coach but not one of the greats.

Link to comment

I think this was an extremely well written blog! Very Nice: Great job WeSpy!!

JimJaime: Dungy came in to the right place at the right time...as did Gruden who followed him I think Coughlin has been underrated all along. His annual firing notice is beyond me. Bill Belichick is a Hall of Famer for sure. Scary though when Parcels does not get in first ballot.

Link to comment

The few analyst that made a case for Eli being the better Manning either have lost their minds or were paid to make statements that would bring ratings/viewers, even ticked off viewers. The latter is most likely the case. I just can't believe that anyone actually thinks Eli is the better Manning. (Maybe Jamie Dukes does ... he's lost his mind!)

Tony Dungy was brought in to make the defense better. It is debatable whether he did this. The Tampa 2 made the pass defense better but the run defense was generally horrible. In my opinion, the defense did not get better and certainly not to the extent needed for a championship. Football is a team sport and I don't know of one Super Bowl winning team that had a consistently poor defense ... except for the Colts (I think)!

Link to comment

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Blog Statistics

    Total Blogs
    Total Entries
  • Create New...