2006Coltsbestever

I mean I post in here more than anyone, and I have clearly said where I rank Minshew numerous times. I said great backup, average to above average starter that can win you a few games. I also have stated numerous times, I would rather have AR playing. Not much else I can say. Of course, I have been happy we have been winning with Minshew, but that doesn't mean I think he is good or great. I posted a few days ago he could possibly be in the top 20 QB's in the league and that is the highest praise I have ever given him. Top 20, and I meant 20th isn't much of a praise. There are around 10 starters that are worse than Minshew in reality.

I never did but you keep including me in this.

I never said Minshew was Purdy level, that is the problem. People need to quit putting words in my mouth.

I know I am on that one. Minshew doesn't stink, he isn't great either and hardly nobody thinks so. If people would be levelheaded in here and not act like 7 yr old babies every time he has a bad game or we lose a game, this place would be a much better place.

Well I can compile a spreadsheet with the people that have said Minshew stinks much longer than you can compile a spreadsheet saying he is like Purdy. I would put money on that.

I had no idea Stephen said that. That is 1 person out of 1000.

I never said you did.

Yeah it seems like an ongoing thing that never stops.

HUH? I never said you were trolling?

Who said Minshew is better than Purdy? I have never seen that or read that anywhere. Purdy is very good if not great as a starter.

ESPN and the NFL Network and even Peyton Manning said Minshew is the best backup QB in the league. I think I will defer to them rather than read some the of the bull in here. Sorry, they no more you and even me.

You confuse me man. Above average isn't stinking. We lost today. It is what it is.

No, people are posting a bunch of dumb trolling crap, and it ruins every thread.

I have never once said Minshew was elite. I have always said great backup and above average starter that has played good football at times. So don't include me on whoever said that. As a matter of fact, most people in here thinks Minshew stinks, read the posts. I defend him when people post dumb bullcrap like that. Plain and simple.

Despite everything, with the Houston loss we are still #7 and after we beat Pitt next week, we will be #6 at worse. Pitt isn't anywhere near as talented as Cincy is. We have just won 4 in a row, not sure why anyone needs to be this ridiculous over 1 loss. I have never seen anything like this in all my years here. I even said before the game we may lose because Cincy needed this a lot more than us. The loss doesn't prove anything to me 1 way or the other. We had a bad game it happens.

I haven't talked about JB since 2019.

Browning has had 1 great game, that was last week. Minshew has won 4 games in a row, and has had multiple good games in his career. Minshew played great against the Browns but we got screwed. Any QB can outplay a QB for 1 game. Overall, I think Minshew is better. Look at their career's.

Bad defense there.

That is their problem, not mine. Minshew doesn't suck is the main point, if someone says so I have a right to call them out just as much as they have the right saying he sucks.

Poop sounds like a great first name for him.

Yeah then you get to see me act like the hulk - just joking my friend.

I wasn't either but I never panic. I honestly thought we could at least get it to one score before the Half when it was 14-0. This is much better than I thought.

14-14 at Half. We are good. I will take it.

Minshew is better I am fair. Browing has had 1 great game, last week. If people would quit saying Minshew sucks, I wouldn't have to put my foot down. Just ridiculous take after take.

@Nadineread the posts, people saying Minshew sucks and Browning is a lot better. Than you will understand.