[starting O]

I also think Diem should be cut. I'm not sold on that Peyton-whatever guy at QB, I'm expecting an open competition for the starting QB spot between Painter and Manning, Painter's youth gives him the early advantage...

[How long will it take to get Peyton and the O back on track?]

I don't think it will take very long for the offense to gel. I know Peyton has those guys working out together anyways and Manning is famous for having the entire playbook memorized. He will be writing everything down for all of the offensive guys and making sure they practice game situations. One thing about this lockout is that coaches can't talk to players, but Manning knows the whole playbook, so he will be able to teach the rookies.

[Can the Colts Survive Without Robert Mathis]

It depends on how Hughes is progressing. Obviously he is talented, but he has nearly 0 experience and isn't as good a pass rusher or player as Mathis. If we don't resign Mathis, I won't be very happy and I will expect Hughes to have a big season right off the start. Personally, I think Mathis stays a Colt

[Peyton over Brady]

What better way is there to start off a Colts forum than with a good ol' Brady-Manning thread