Jump to content
Indianapolis Colts
Indianapolis Colts Fan Forum

HOFClipboardHolder

Member
  • Posts

    485
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by HOFClipboardHolder

  1. Stanford, ability to read Ds and a lot of intangibles, that is about it at this point.

    Arm strength - Elway was way ahead.

    To me, Luck is more Peytonish than Elwayish in arm strength and ability to read Ds but with mobility like Rodgers.

    Luck is more athletic than Rodgers. I would compare his athleticism to Jim Kelly, who was originally recruited by Penn State to play linebacker

  2. You mean the five Super Bowl appearances by the 199th rounder? The 11th pick that went to three? The 32nd pick that brought a city their first?

    I mean I guess I'm being harsh on top 10 picks. It must've felt good for the Browns when Tim Couch brought home the trophy. Same for the Raiders and Jamarcus Russel, Leaf and the Chiefs, Sanchez and the Jets, Akili Smith and the Bengals, Vick and the Falcons, Harrington and the Lions, Palmer and the Bengals, Smith and the Niners.

    There are 250+ picks every year. Not counting UDFAs and top ten picks, You have 240+ chances that one of them will be succesful vs 10 in the top 10. If you look at it as a percentage, top 10 picks are a lot more likely to succeed.

    and Leaf played for the chargers

  3. We didn't need the "best ever" to be successful in coming years after Peyton. Later picks statistically perform better in the NFL. Peyton and Eli are the only two first rounders to win a Super Bowl in recent years. Stafford, Rodgers, Brady, Brees were not all "the greatest prospect ever." I'll give Luck my full support, but accepting mediocrity because of our owners ego isn't what seems best for the team.

    Is this serious post? You do realize there is a much bigger pool to choose from when talking about later picks. If you look at it as a percentage, the early first rounders are a lot more succesful

×
×
  • Create New...