[Manning Mvp Every Year!]

10+ Secs to throw, step up, have 10 more secs + Great team + Great coach/has fallen apart in the last 3 playoff appearances in spite of all that. The team isn't complete/is much less likely to win a championship without him, but it's still possible with a decent QB.

VS

2 Secs to throw (if lucky) Nowhere to go. No D. No O-line. No run game. No special teams. No coach. Potential one or two win team to annual playoff contender?

There has never realistically been any thing to debate. Our team without ONE player is terrible/bottom of the barrel and makes the playoffs every season. No other QB brings this team to the playoffs. Period. Let alone how many years in a row now?

perfect example of coattail rider see my post

[Manning Mvp Every Year!]

Im a true Indianapolis colts fan bieng a fan since the colts moved to indiana AND I am ashamed of any colts fan that feels this way or think that since peyton is hurt and is probably out for the rest of the season that the colts are done and act like peyton is the whole team now dont get me wrong peyton is the greatest qb in the league and am am a big fan and glad we have him but i as a true colt fan that has followed this team thru good and bad seasons and knows alot about this team and football in general I am really disapointed in any realcolts fan that feels this way and it really tics me off when all these band wagon jumpers (fans as long as the colts are winning ) and peyton coattail riders (fans cause peyton is qb ) get on the real fans site and talk all this crap that the colts are done because peyton is injured assuming that there are no other Quality players on this team when in fact there are mutiple pro bowl players on this team 29 players in that locker room have been to the superbowl and alot of veterans on this team and even with todays loss i still believe that there is potential and hope with this team and i didnt mean any bad thoughts toward peyton I wish him well and hope that you feel better soon and cant wait to have you back when you feel able but dont risk everything over playing take as long as you need

[Manning Mvp Every Year!]

Yep proves what i have known for years,without peyton we are a joke.

this proves what Ive been sayin that fans like you are coat tail riders only like the team because manning is on the team