Playmakers

[Matabix]

Who is your top 5 playmaker on offense and 1 up and comer that maybe on the PS.

I still have JT 1st

Pittman 2nd, but Downs closing in

Downs 3rd

Moss 4th

Ogletree 5th

 

I got Mallory as my up and comer.

[John Hammonds]

I don't have JT at #1 yet.  He hasn't shown it yet this year.  But historically he would be #1.  And potentially again.

Otherwise, Pittman is our #1.

Then Moss.

Then Downs.

Then Ogletree.

 

And as you say, Downs is moving up the list quickly.  I made a prediction in the preseason that he could beat AR for team's rookie of the year.  Even with AR still playing.  Downs is quickly becoming TY 2.0.  I certainly hope so.

[Matabix]

I remember you saying that about Downs. I put JT 1st not because of the games he missed but because of the games he played. Same reason I still have Leonard in my top 5, but he was 1st but has slid this year.

[Moosejawcolt]

10 hours ago, Matabix said:

Who is your top 5 playmaker on offense and 1 up and comer that maybe on the PS.

I still have JT 1st

Pittman 2nd, but Downs closing in

Downs 3rd

Moss 4th

Ogletree 5th

 

I got Mallory as my up and comer.

JT and that's it.

[Stephen]

1 hour ago, Moosejawcolt said:

JT and that's it.

Downs

[Moosejawcolt]

47 minutes ago, Stephen said:

Downs

To me, playmakers are defined as players who a defensive coordinator have to scheme for.

[Stephen]

13 minutes ago, Moosejawcolt said:

To me, playmakers are defined as players who a defensive coordinator have to scheme for.

That will be downs

[Moosejawcolt]

1 minute ago, Stephen said:

That will be downs

Not yet. Let's pump the brakes. He looks good but still a rookie. 

 .

[John Waylon]

Under ideal circumstances Taylor should be #1. Pittman should be #2. That will open up Pierce, Downs, and the TEs in whatever order it winds up being. 
 

But it’s not really working out real well. 

[GoColts8818]

1.  Downs

2.  Taylor

3.  Pittman

4.  Moss

5.  Ogletree or Mo.

 

that’s my list after the Browns game.

 

 

[compuls1v3]

1. Downs

2. Taylor

3. Moss

4. Pierce

5. Ogletree

[Smoke317]

1. JT
2. Downs
3. Moss
4. Pierce
5. Pitt
6. Ogletree

Pittman & Pierce is a toss up.  Pierce has more big play potential but Pittman is getting all of the gritty tight end type tough catches over the middle.  Especially in garbage time. That 75 yarder will go a long way towards helping his yards per catch. Imagine if we had AR…  He’d be #1 and this would be a damned good list of playmakers. 

 

 

[LJpalmbeacher2]

Minshew is the top playmaker for opposing teams when playing the colts. 

[sb41champs]

1.  Jonathan Taylor

2.  Quenton Nelson

3.  Ryan Kelly

4.  Zach Moss

5.  Michael Pittman Jr

 

 

Up and comer - Bernhard Raimann w/ honorable mention to Blake Freeland

 

[Blueblood23]

21 hours ago, Moosejawcolt said:

To me, playmakers are defined as players who a defensive coordinator have to scheme for.

No one on the receiving bunch is going to scare any coordinator. 

[Stephen]

22 hours ago, Moosejawcolt said:

Not yet. Let's pump the brakes. He looks good but still a rookie. 

 .

The breaks won't be pumped  downs is a star!

[jvan1973]

19 hours ago, Blueblood23 said:

No one on the receiving bunch is going to scare any coordinator. 

Yeah, I doubt the saints are watching any film on Downs or Pittman.   

[Nickster]

11 minutes ago, jvan1973 said:

Yeah, I doubt the saints are watching any film on Downs or Pittman.   

 

Why wouldn't they be?  Don't we play the Saints this week?

 

Or did you think they just watch Tyreek Hill and AJ Brown every week even when they aren't playing them?

[jvan1973]

1 minute ago, Nickster said:

 

Why wouldn't they be?  Don't we play the Saints this week?

 

Or did you think they just watch Tyreek Hill and AJ Brown every week even when they aren't playing them?

I was being sarcastic.   The Colts have playmakers contrary to the person I quoted

[Nickster]

Just now, jvan1973 said:

I was being sarcastic.   The Colts have playmakers contrary to the person I quoted

 

Me too Jvan.

[Defjamz26]

This season its

1. Moss

2. Downs

3. Pittman

4. Taylor

5. Richardson

 

Downs and Moss have carried this offense tbh.

[4daUColts]

On 10/23/2023 at 3:13 PM, sb41champs said:

1.  Jonathan Taylor

2.  Quenton Nelson

3.  Ryan Kelly

4.  Zach Moss

5.  Michael Pittman Jr

 

 

Up and comer - Bernhard Raimann w/ honorable mention to Blake Freeland

 

Nice list

[lollygagger8]

Downs

Pittman

Moss 

JT 

Ogletree 

 

I understand playing JT more cuz he got paid, but I'd like to see more Moss

 

I'd also like to see Downs, Pittman & McKenzie (Pierce role on outside) on the field at the same time.